Author Topic: Locked and Loaded appraisal- Youve Gotta be Kidding!  (Read 952 times)

Ramps

  • Guest
Locked and Loaded appraisal- Youve Gotta be Kidding!
« on: April 20, 2009, 12:24:17 AM »
1.                          (The way we are going No 1 is probably our best player)
2. Will Thursfield       ( Dropped and we're not going well at all. Could be traded)
3. Brett Deledio        ( Does he still want to play for us? Good player being wrecked)
4. Andrew Raines      ( Should be Gold Coast Bound for mine)
5. Troy Simmonds     ( Gone - age and pace of game have caught up with him)
6. Graham Polak        (Gone because of his accident- not his fault at all just bad luck)
7. Nathan Brown       (Gone - see Simmonds)

8. Jack Riewoldt        (Looked to be coming along nicely, struggling badly atm. Keeper for now)
9. Trent Cotchin        (Keeper)
10. Shane Edwards    (Cant kick for mine, should be put up for trade at years end)11. Joel Bowden        (Gone- see Brown)
12. Matthew Richardson (Gone - the side is so bad Richo wont see any success with us at 34yo sadly)
13. Jordan McMahon   (Gone - no further comment needed imho)

14. Dean Polo            (Cant kick but atleast he tries - you cant sack them all. Keep for another year
15. Kayne Pettifer       (Gone)
16. Luke McGuane      (Keep unless he packs up and goes home to Gold Coat)
17. Chris Newman       (Keep - one of the few who can kick)
18. Alex Rance           (Keep - needs to work on kicking but he should be a part of the future
19. Dean Putt            (Keep - until we find out if he can play or not)
20. Mitch Morton        (Keep - Not the worst on the list, could be a good player in a good side)
21. Shane Tuck          (Gone - never been able to kick for mine. Id put him up for trade as well.
22. Jarryd Oakley-Nicholls (Gone - did he ever arrive)

23. Daniel Jackson       (Gone - Cant kick the footy to the desired level, tries hard but No)
24. Mark Coughlan       (Gone - He was getting slow before injury, its been a long road back)
25. Jay Schulz            (Gone - No just No)
26. Adam Pattison       (Gone - Tries very hard, but not a ruck and not a KPP for mine)
27. Tom Hislop            (Gone - Tries hard but No. We only needed Thomson not both)
28. Kane Johnson        (Gone - Age
)
29. Tyrone Vickery       (Keep)
30. Richard Tambling     (Gone - This saddens me greatly, I think hes career at RFC is shot. Trade)
31. Adam Thomson       (Keep - until we see what he has to offer)
32. Ben Cousins            (No decision yet- but not looking good after 1st hammy)
33. --------------> rookie
34. Cleve Hughes         (Gone - Had chances hasnt taken them yet. Times running. Trade option.
35. Matthew White       (Gone - Cant kick)
36. --------------> rookie
37. Jayden Post            (Keep)
38. --------------> rookie
39. Daniel Connors         (Keep)
40. Kelvin Moore            (Keep)
41. Nathan Foley           (Keep)
42. Andrew Collins          (Keep)
43. --------------> rookie
44. Angus Graham           (Gone)
45. --------------> rookie
46. Jake King                  (Gone)

Offline Infamy

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 4426
  • For We're From Tigerland
Re: Locked and Loaded appraisal- Youve Gotta be Kidding!
« Reply #1 on: April 20, 2009, 12:31:04 AM »
When exactly do you plan on cutting all these players and who exactly do you intend to replace them with?

Ramps

  • Guest
Re: Locked and Loaded appraisal- Youve Gotta be Kidding!
« Reply #2 on: April 20, 2009, 01:04:11 AM »
Its not about who should be cut and who should survive. Its my opinion based on can these players help us win a flag. When they get the arse and how is up to the club not me.