The Free Agency compo will only be half as good as the compo given to clubs that lost players to GWS & GC.
One for the roadJake Niall
March 14, 2012CLUBS that lose a superstar to free agency would get roughly half the compensation that Geelong and Melbourne received for losing Gary Ablett and Tom Scully, under the incoming system for free agency.
Any club that loses an elite player will receive a maximum of one first-round draft pick, not the two early picks Geelong and Melbourne received for losing Ablett and Scully to expansion teams.
Collingwood would receive just one first-round pick if it lost its gun forward Travis Cloke to free agency - Cloke is eligible this year - while St Kilda would only receive one for Brendon Goddard if he walked to another club.
The same would also be true for Hawthorn, which would get only one first-round choice for Lance Franklin - regarded by many as the premier player in the game - in the highly unlikely event that he exercised his option as a restricted free agent during 2013 and was snared by a rival club.
Clubs have been told that the compensation they will receive for losing free agents will be less generous than the draft picks they received for losing players to the Gold Coast and Greater Western Sydney. Melbourne received two first-round picks - which it can utilise in the coming years - when Scully joined GWS last October, while Geelong received exactly the same deal when superstar Ablett went to the Gold Coast and became the game's highest-paid player. The Cats successfully lobbied for a better deal during 2010 when it was evident that they faced a battle to retain Ablett.
Critically, the AFL will award a club ''net'' compensation for losing or gaining a free agent player. Thus, if St Kilda lost Goddard, but gained another player, the compensation would be based on the difference between the players. If the player gained is judged to be at the same level to the one lost, the relevant club would receive nothing.
The free agency system has five ''bands'' of compensation. The highest-ranked players - who will usually have completed eight years and be ''restricted'' free agents - will bring a return of a first-round pick, the next level is an end of first round pick, the third category is a second-round choice, the fourth is an end of second round, and the last bracket is a third-round pick.
At this stage, clubs are unclear where in the first round the compensation pick would be awarded, but it is likely either to be based on a club's ladder position in the year they use it [immediately after their ''normal'' first pick], or to be in the middle of the first round.
The AFL has suggested to clubs that they would have perhaps three years in which to utilise a compensation pick (they have five years under the GWS/Gold Coast compensation), but this is yet to be confirmed.
Clubs believe that the AFL does not want too many first-round compensation picks interfering with the function of the national draft.
http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/one-for-the-road-20120313-1uyiy.html#ixzz1p0vay2UD