The "Official" DO NOT bring Polak to Punt Road thread!

[Razorblade]

He is stuffing hopeless!

I've seen him in 6 contests in the last quarter and a bit, 4 times he has been marked on, the 5th time he gave away a free and the 6th time he gave away a free that wasn't paid.

H-O-P-E-L-E-S-S!

[Captain__Blood]

I'd love him at Punt Road.

Promsing young KPP in the age range we are lacking. Pick 4 in the strongest ever draft and still a pup.

[mightytiges]

I didn't think he was hopeless but nothing to write home about either. An average solid game at best as a pure defender who would dish the ball off by hand or foot. The only time I recall him involved in rebounding was on the wing where he did a nice lookaway deft handball. Also his kicking action appears awkward in some ways. He doesn't seem to have a natural flowing kick. He did hit his targets mind you. 

Freo would want a high price for him anyway such as first round pick plus. I would pass just for that reason alone.   

[Razorblade]

I think your getting a bit technical there! 

Also, not only does he appear to have average skills, he appears to hace no stamina and isn't exactly an athletic person.

Granted his coming back from injury, but by the 3rd quarter he was puffing and panting in a way that would make an obese 12yo ruckmen jealous!

[Captain__Blood]

I think your getting a bit technical there! 

Also, not only does he appear to have average skills, he appears to hace no stamina and isn't exactly an athletic person.

Granted his coming back from injury, but by the 3rd quarter he was puffing and panting in a way that would make an obese 12yo ruckmen jealous!

Maybe you shouldn't make judgements after 1 game, more so when he wasn't the worst on ground and comming back from injury.

Freo would want a high price for him anyway such as first round pick plus. I would pass just for that reason alone.   

I'd trade away a 2nd round pick and a decent players.

a Krakouer, Hyde type.

[JohnF]

I hear ya Razor, stay clear of Polhack.