Finally, down and dirty footballJon Pierik
The Age
April 3, 2015RICHMOND 2.3 7.10 9.13 15.15 (105)
CARLTON 4.7 6.9 6.12 11.12 (78)
Best:
Richmond: K McIntosh, B Ellis, J Riewoldt, B Deledio, T Chaplin.
Carlton: B Gibbs, T Bell, S Docherty
Goals:
Richmond: J Riewoldt 4 B Griffiths 3 S Lloyd 3 S Grigg 2 D Martin K McIntosh N Gordon.
Carlton: L Jones 2 S Rowe 2 T Menzel 2 B Gibbs K Jaksch K Simpson T Bell Z Tuohy.
Injuries:
Richmond: Nil.
Carlton: D Thomas (dislocated shoulder).
Reports:
Richmond: B Deledio by field umpire B Rosebury in the first quarter for rough conduct against S White.
Carlton: Nil.
Umpires: Ben Ryan, Robert Findlay, Brett Rosebury.
Official Crowd: 83,493 at MCG.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In a week where drugs and gambling issues have overshadowed the game, there was something almost quaint when attention turned to Thursday night's season opener at the MCG.
Instead of the spotlight being on who allegedly took drugs and why, it was finally about where would the Blues get their goals from, and were the Tigers the real deal? All serious questions, but ones which at least can be laughed about.
In the end, it was Richmond which had the last laugh with a 27-point win, but supporters of all kinds were the winners with the focus back on the field.
That focus, though, in the opening seconds was on Tigers star Brett Deledio and his report for a heavy hit on Simon White, and minutes later when Dale Thomas was crunched and suffered what could be a season-ending left shoulder injury.
On a relatively mild autumnal night, the temperature quickly rose, and it was debutant midfielder Kamdyn McIntosh, former Cat Taylor Hunt, Brandon Ellis, Brett Deledio, Sam Lloyd and Jack Riewoldt, the latter having shifted to full forward from midway through the second term, who led the way for the Tigers.
"It was pretty amazing night. I just wanted to use my fitness," McIntosh, who will celebrate his 21st birthday on Friday, said.
However, they could well have asked whether some of their key movers, including skipper Trent Cotchin and raging bull Dustin Martin, were ready for the season to start in the first term, for it was the Blues who appeared harder at the man and ball.
Blues mentor Mick Malthouse and his assistants had implemented a surprise move, sending customary defender Simon White into the middle to shadow Martin. The Tiger had just the one touch in the first term, and was barely sighted for the rest of the night.
Much to the bemusement of some fans, the Tigers also had a surprise of their own through the opening term. Riewoldt, their premier key forward, was used as a half-forward flanker - and had little to no impact.
This left fellow tall Ben Griffiths and a swag of small men as the marking options. While Griffiths responded with two goals on new Blue Kristian Jaksch (who had a dirty night), it was a questionable move by Damien Hardwick. If the Tigers are to launch a serious September campaign, surely Riewoldt needs to be in a position all game to kick a bag, a point reinforced by commentators, and goal-kicking greats, Jason Dunstall and Garry Lyon.
Bryce Gibbs and Chris Yarran provided plenty of drive, and with Chris Judd working hard and Liam Jones a viable target inside 50, the Blues skipped out to a 23-point lead early in the second term.
The Tigers appeared in a malaise when Troy Menzel grittily tackled Troy Chaplin, forcing a free kick close to goal and converted a goal. But in the blink of an eye, the Tigers found momentum, and it was their opponents who were under immense pressure.
McIntosh, after two years in the VFL, led the way. While certainly not a pretty player, his toughness and will to win the ball - as shown when he roved a pack, dashed away from Judd and converted to kick spark the comeback - was impressive. The Tigers look to have found themselves a player.
The Tigers took control in the contest and away from the gaggle of bodies, enjoying a whopping 35-15 advantage in uncontested possession through the second half of the second term.
When Riewoldt, Shaun Grigg and Sam Lloyd converted, the latter after Steven Morris forced a turnover from a poor Sam Rowe intended pass, the Tigers found themselves in front.
If the suddenly sluggish Blues, having activated substitute - and draftee - Clem Smith in the opening minutes, were to rebound, they needed to again turn the contest into a grind. This they did in the opening 10 minutes of the third term but when Lloyd ignored a Riewoldt lead and goaled from 50, the Tigers had notched six of the last seven goals.
There was a poignant moment when Riewoldt, after flying unsuccessfully for a mark, quickly regained his feet, accepted a handball from Cotchin and snapped a goal. He immediately shot a kiss to the sky, no doubt in memory of his cousin Madeleine - the sister of Nick Riewoldt - who died recently at the age of 26.
Now working closer to goal, Riewoldt was a handful for Michael Jamison, at a time when the Blues needed more - and improved efficiency - from Gibbs, skipper Marc Murphy and Yarran, the latter complaining of a knock to the knee. The Blues would be goalless in the third term.
Errors by Yarran and Murphy in the forward half early in the final term ended hopes of Carlton revival, while at the other end Riewoldt and Lloyd continued to have the answers.
In terms of the bigger picture, this opening contest proved the Blues - without the departed Jarrad Waite - are likely to struggle for potency inside 50. Whether the Tigers are a legitimate top six, even top four, chance, only time will tell. But with the Western Bulldogs, Brisbane and Melbourne to come in the opening month, they have the chance to build the perfect platform.
http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-match-centre/finally-down-and-dirty-football-20150402-1mdwyl.html