Chris Newman or Kane Pee-Pee Johnson - Who was a worse captain?

[(•))(©™]

I can't spilt them.
The culture of mediocrity.

[mat073]

Why dont you enjoy the moment ??  Favorites to go 4-0. Enjoy the fact we have a young Daniel Rioli playing for us or that Dusty is performing like the best player in the comp.

Why bring up crap from the Wallace era ??

[Chuck17]

Its a hard call, two of the most uninspiring players let alone captains I have ever had the misfortune to watch

You should have done a poll.

[Willy]

Sugar was worse IMO.

[🏅Dooks]

Johnson was never desperate at the ball.

[Damo]

Pee pee was a better player

[(•))(©™]

Pea was WAS definitely a better player.....until he came to the rfc.
As for "savouring the moment", Mat - I am.

Having beaten the two other worse teams in the comp and the non-travelling Eagles, I think I'm keeping a lid on it.

Easily.

[Rodgerramjet]

Newman was a better captain in his latter years, Kane was a tougher player in my opinion but not a better captain.

[cub]

It's complicated but I'll give it a go

https://youtu.be/j1o9ZWqCnKk

[mat073]

Pea was WAS definitely a better player.....until he came to the rfc.
As for "savouring the moment", Mat - I am.

Having beaten the two other worse teams in the comp and the non-travelling Eagles, I think I'm keeping a lid on it.

Easily.

We could do another "we could of had Buddy" thread if you want - about as relevant.

[(•))(©™]

Pea was WAS definitely a better player.....until he came to the rfc.
As for "savouring the moment", Mat - I am.

Having beaten the two other worse teams in the comp and the non-travelling Eagles, I think I'm keeping a lid on it.

Easily.

We could do another "we could of had Buddy" thread if you want - about as relevant.

I'm sure that makes sense.

[MintOnLamb]

When Chris put his hand up to play in the final against Carlton he lost me.

[Chuck17]

Get a poll happening slack arse

[tdy]

What about a best captain and worst of the last 10 captains? That'd include Tony Free, Wayne Campbell, Cotchin who else?

[tdy]

1983–1984   Barry Rowlings   
1985–1987   Mark Lee   
1988–1992   Dale Weightman   
1993   Jeff Hogg   
1994–1996   Tony Free   
1997–2000   Matthew Knights   
2001–2004   Wayne Campbell   
2005–2008   Kane Johnson   
2009–2012   Chris Newman   
2013–   Trent Cotchin   

Here you go.