Who has had the better career: Josh Kennedy (WC) or Jack Riewoldt? (afl site)

[one-eyed]

Who has had the better career: Josh Kennedy (WC) or Jack Riewoldt?

https://twitter.com/CalTwomey/status/1381864848879849472

Discussion 15:30 - 18:30 min mark: https://player.whooshkaa.com/episode?id=813786

Twomey and co. chose Jack.

[Andyy]

Is this a damned joke?

Jack by a million Flemingtons

More goals
More flags
More Coleman's

Pretty much of anything that indicates individual or team success.

[Damo]

What rubbish saying Jack by a million flemingtons.
Jack, but it’s close
Kennedy has been a super player for a long time and their stats are almost identical. In fact goals per game goes to Kennedy.

Both been awesome for a very long time.

[Andyy]

What rubbish saying Jack by a million flemingtons.
Jack, but it’s close
Kennedy has been a super player for a long time and their stats are almost identical. In fact goals per game goes to Kennedy.

Both been awesome for a very long time.

I'm exaggerating. Love JR.

Kennedy is a gun but I wouldn't trade

[mightytiges]

Both have had great careers but Jack would be in front.

The loser has been Carlton. They had Fevola so they went for mids in 2006 (Gibbs when they could've had Jack) & a ruck in 2007 (Kruezer). They of course traded out Kennedy, picks 3 & 20 for a quick fix in Judd. Fevola then implodes, Judd at his peak can't get them beyond week 2 of the finals and Kruezer couldn't get on the park due to injuries.  Another whole decade in the wilderness for the Blues  while Richmond x3 and the Eagles won a flag(s) each with a respective champion key forward.