Author Topic: Richmond recruiter Matt Clarke's draft reviews (Fox Footy & SEN)  (Read 6796 times)

Offline Fluffy Tiger

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 2450
  • Yes I was realy born in Richmond
    • Canning A.R.T.S.
Re: Richmond recruiter Matt Clarke's draft reviews (Fox Footy & SEN)
« Reply #30 on: November 26, 2021, 03:54:40 PM »

Just based on national draft selections nothing else.

2017
Jack Higgins - Gone and done nothing with us or St Kilda
Liam Baker - tick
Callum Coleman Jones - Gone to Norf done Nothing
Noah Balta - tick
Patrick Naish - Gone Delisted
Ben Miller - 1 game, Question Mark as to future

Ok I will play along...

Higgins - started well in his first, 2nd season suffered his brain bleed issue so not sure that counts. Comes back after illness and wasn't the same player. Gets dropped and then decides wants out rather than fighting to get his spot back... that's not a recruiting issue, that's a player/person issue

CCJ - will be a very good player even moreso at N0rt... but again not recruiting that's the player walking out on a club

Miller - will be a good KPP. Actually I am pleased that they've taken their time with him. Play him before he was ready and folks on here would have torn him to shreds

Quote
2018
Riley Collier Dawkins - Question Mark
Jack Ross - Looks Ordinary after bright start - Question Mark
Fraser Turner - Delisted
Luke English - Delisted

No ticks 2 maybes at best. Nothing exceptionsl here.

RCD - will be great player. Will be a perfect replacement for Cotch. Will he be as good as Cotchin? Who knows but he showed enough in his games this year that he will be a very good player. Reckon he's been judge very harshly because he was our 1st round pick and because he didn't debut immediately folks are critical. Club always said he was going to take time.

Ross - agree been disappointing the last 2 seasons. But I think that's got more to do with them bulking him up and then changing their minds. But 2022 certainly is a crunch year for him

English was pick 62, Turner was pick 58. late picks are always hit and miss, these were clearly misses. But what exactly did we lose?

Quote
2019

Thomson Dow - Question Mark Shows signs a Maybe
Noah Cumberland - hasnt played - Question Mark
Will Martyn - Dont rate him on performance so far
Hugo Ralphsmith - Ill give a tick Just.
Biguo Nyuon - Hasnt played - Question Mark at best

1 tick 3 Question Marks

5 kids who've been in the system only 2 years that with due to the impact of COVID have had very little 2nd tier footy to help with development.

Kids who have come to a club that's won 3 of the last 5 flags.


Quote
2020
Samson Ryan played hasnt shown much - Question mark
Maurice Rioli - Father Son only shown glimpses

0 ticks so far

2021 was their first year and it's already "zero ticks" come on? how unrealistic/unfair is that?

Ryan - a ruckman taken at pick 40. Played 1 game and if we are honest he should have played that game as he was clearly not ready. 

Quote
2021
Josh Gibcus
Tom Brown
Tyler Sonsie
Sam Banks
Judson Clarke

All just drafted. So no judgement can be made.

Based on that we have 3 ticks in 4 years. Matt Clarke needs to have picked some decent players this draft because our national draft selections have been ordinary at best and theyve hidden behind the 3 premierships delivered by players drafted between 5 and 10 years ago.

In your opinion Ramps, it's 3 ticks

IMO making calls on kids who've only been on lists for 2-3 years, especially when you throw in the chaos COVID created with the VFL comp, relocating to QLD for 3 months in 2020 etc is simply not fair.

Yes season 2022 is going to crunch time for a couple but for now I'm prepared to back them and support them.

Great Post. The numbers that some are posting here should never be taken in isolation. There are so many factors that effect each and every player and each and every pick.  I couldn't be bothered going into such detail to prove this statement but Ill bet if you compared us to other clubs you would find similar results.

Its been many years since we have had even a decent draft hand in both numbers and quality (early pick). Lets see the results in a few years before we start jumping up and down about who we did or didn't pick.
Here , kitty kitty. Here , kitty kitty.   AAAUGH!

Online lamington

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 2873
  • For We're From Tigerland
Re: Richmond recruiter Matt Clarke's draft reviews (Fox Footy & SEN)
« Reply #31 on: November 26, 2021, 03:57:20 PM »
Like most people here I would have preferred we go after more mids. I gotta trust the since they brought us 3 flags but it’s still perplexing why we didn’t get more mids

Offline Rampsation

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 3105
  • For We're From Tigerland
Re: Richmond recruiter Matt Clarke's draft reviews (Fox Footy & SEN)
« Reply #32 on: November 26, 2021, 04:58:33 PM »
WP

I have hopes for Miller and Collier Dawkins and I respect your view but the numbers dont stack up and excuses dont change the reality. Higgins and CCJ left but they still havent done anything... they may become good players who knows, covid has effected every club not just ours so thats not an excuse either imho. I just think there are a lot of busts over the last 4 years and the recruiting team need the picks they selected over the last 2 days to be good players because if this draft is a bust again then we are stuffed for the next 10 years.

Offline 1965

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 5647
  • Don't water the rocks
Re: Richmond recruiter Matt Clarke's draft reviews (Fox Footy & SEN)
« Reply #33 on: November 26, 2021, 06:26:11 PM »
Lots of words. Personally I am looking forward to watching the team grow together. We are in the mix for a flag next year and have set ourselves up for the next 10 years. Hoping Mate Colina becomes something special.
Yeah we're already going to vote for him mate, you don't need to keep selling it.....

Offline camboon

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 2445
Re: Richmond recruiter Matt Clarke's draft reviews (Fox Footy & SEN)
« Reply #34 on: November 26, 2021, 06:34:28 PM »
Who knows  how well some of the back flankers and the small forward we picked will turn out but what’s the chances we will get , Richmond could have picked ..... midfielder in the future.

Offline one-eyed

  • Administrator
  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 98247
    • One-Eyed Richmond
Re: Richmond recruiter Matt Clarke's draft reviews (Fox Footy & SEN)
« Reply #35 on: November 27, 2021, 06:23:05 PM »
Matt Clarke on SEN yesterday with Dwayne Russell:

AUDIO: https://player.whooshkaa.com/episode?id=933034

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

RICHMOND TOOK “BEST PLAYER AVAILABLE”, ADDED FLEXIBILITY WITH DRAFT HAUL

Richmond recruiting manager Matthew Clarke insists Josh Gibcus was the “best player available” when it came to the club’s first selection in the draft.

The Tigers took the key defender with pick 9 despite some draft experts predicting they may take a quality midfielder with their premium pick.

The likes of Neil Erasmus, Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera, Josh Sinn and Ben Hobbs were all taken in the picks after the Tigers took Gibcus, so how did Clarke and his recruiting team land on the backman?

Did they target him to fill a specific need, or was he simply the best player available?

“We put our ranks in order towards the end of the season when we got all the data together and it just came out that Josh we rated the best player available,” Clarke said on SEN’s Dwayne’s World.

“It just happened that he’d be a key position player who we think has got some flexibility. He’s obviously played a lot of footy down back in recent years, but he’s played some footy before that as a forward. We think he’s got flexibility to play at both ends of the ground.

“It just turned out that way that he was our highest ranked and we were happy to select him.”

The arrival of Gibcus adds depth to the Richmond defence which already consists of reigning Jack Dyer Medallist Dylan Grimes, the promising Noah Balta and recently acquired veteran Robbie Tarrant, among others.

With 22-year-old Balta returning from a syndesmosis injury, and Gibcus waiting in the wings, will it move the 44-gamer to a different position?

“He’s still an integral part of our back six,” Clarke said of Balta.

“With Robbie Tarrant coming in with Dave Astbury’s retirement, I think that will help both Noah and Dylan.

“Noah’s got the flexibility, as we’ve seen in games where he’s played as a forward, as a back, in the ruck.

“He’s still very young at 22 years of age, we’re only scratching the surface with Noah. We’ll see how his pre-season goes and we’ll see what the coaches want to do with him.”

It was a busy draft night for the Tigers who also selected rebounding defender Tom Brown with pick 17, midfielder Tyler Sonsie with pick 28, medium defender Samuel Banks with pick 29 and small forward Judson Clarke with pick 30.

Clarke explained the mindset of Richmond’s recruiters after they landed Gibcus inside the top 10, saying it was versatility and flexibility they were seeking.

“Once we got into our picks in the 20s there was a bit of flexibility in terms of type, the flexibility to play roles in our side, so we went for a bit of a combination there,” he added.

“We still ranked all of those boys really highly on talent, so I don’t think there was a great difference between any other guy in other position in terms of our talent rating.”

Clarke continued: “We’re pleased that we were able to add a good range of types to our list.

“We filled some needs in terms of some young, developing depth particularly in the key position with Josh early.

“We added some really good running power with Brown, Banks and Clarke and we think Tyler has got some really good scope as a midfielder.

“We were pleased with it. It’s up to the boys now to put the head down and do the work and we think we provide the right environment and platform to do that.”

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2021/11/26/richmond-took-best-player-available-added-flexibility-with-draft-haul/

Offline one-eyed

  • Administrator
  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 98247
    • One-Eyed Richmond
Re: Richmond recruiter Matt Clarke's draft reviews (Fox Footy & SEN)
« Reply #36 on: November 29, 2021, 04:23:11 PM »
Hey @Richmond_FC fans we are ready to roll on a TT podcast draft special next Tuesday.

If you have a question for our Recruiting boss Matt Clarke send them through using #talkingtigers.

Plus a summer edition of Chief watch of course!!!

https://twitter.com/mattricho0/status/1464027483276079105