Swans' hard work shows up Tigers
Michael Gleeson | August 10, 2009
SYDNEY - 4.6 9.10 17.10 18.15 (123)
RICHMOND - 3.3 5.5 7.6 10.8 (68)
GOALS - Sydney: Goodes 4, Moore 2, White 2, Jack 2, O'Loughlin 2, Kirk, Barlow, J Bolton, McVeigh, Ablett, O'Dwyer. Richmond: King 3, Rance, Cousins, Deledio, Polo, Morton, White, Vickery.
BEST - Sydney: Goodes, O'Keefe, Jack, J Bolton, Kirk, C Bolton, Jolly, Grundy. Richmond: King, Cousins, Newman, Polo.
INJURIES - Sydney: Crouch (thigh), McVeigh (hamstring).
UMPIRES: Stewart, Chamberlain, McInerney.
CROWD: 32,216 at MCG.
JAKE King is not Richmond's best player, nor anyone's idea of an elite AFL talent, but he was the Tigers' best and only real player yesterday.
This in part explains why they lost, for when King is your best player and leading goal scorer, you are unlikely to win a game of AFL football.
Which is not to condemn King, but is to condemn Richmond. King, a scrappy kick and a bigger scrapper, gets games because he offers Richmond what so few others do.
Honesty. He weekly plays with the same belligerent earnestness and in-your-face defiance that makes him an oddity at Richmond.
Yesterday he played a defensive forward role on Rhyce Shaw, closed the Swan out of the game and ended up kicking three goals himself - one of them a gift for an interchange foul-up by Sydney in the first quarter when Ed Barlow ran on to the ground without bothering to wait for the inconvenient encumbrance of another player exiting.
The King performance was notable because his was a more Sydney effort than Richmond. This match was indeed so typically Sydney and so utterly Richmond.
The historically aware, sensitive Swans, sorry Bloods, were acutely conscious of the moment yesterday. It was dripping with do-it-for-Mickey-O sentiment from the moment they ran on the ground, to the tight group huddles and, apparently, the regular loud urgings from Brett Kirk at stoppages that the Swans had to do it for their mate.
This was something that has not been a mark of Richmond, this desire to work for something weekly, to play doggedly like Kirk or the Boltons, Craig and Jude, who reflexively fight through games as if they know no alternative. Because for them they don't.
As Jade Rawlings observed after the game, Sydney yesterday ''epitomised playing for the team''. Which magnified the fact that Richmond did not.
''Brett Kirk brings his game to the table every week,'' Rawlings said. ''He had 14 tackles today and didn't have much offensive involvement but he brings what he brings every week, and we have people who pick and choose what they bring to the game very week. Who is going to turn up and that is a question mark on a lot of our players at the moment.''
It is a harsh observation but true of many. Chris Newman does not deserve the tar of that brush, nor Ben Cousins, but these are quibbling asides.
The point that illustrated this difference in mentality and attitude came at quarter-time. The game had been a mess for the first quarter where Richmond's sloppy possession was outstripped only by Sydney's.
The Swans in the first term had 44 kicks and 24 were ineffective or clangers, they had kicked a profligate 4.6 and led the game by only nine points.
Yet the Swans refused to be cowed by their own wastage. They fought into the game and created the momentum that their skills were denying them early. Tellingly in that first term they went inside 50 13 times and scored on 10 of those.
They were efficient in scoring if not goalling. Adam Goodes was the main culprit. In the first quarter he had 1.3 and could reasonably have goaled all four shots.
The change in the game came because Sydney worked harder to create the opportunities and then corrected their disposal. The Swans' eight straight goals in the third term put the match beyond doubt.
It was in that period the match became an education for Richmond. Young forwards Jayden Post and Jack Riewoldt spent the third and fourth quarters respectively on Goodes enduring a lesson in how to play forward.
Brett Deledio, the player Richmond has most sought to re-educate latterly locating him permanently in the midfield as a tagger with instructions to learn the accountable side of his game, was the fourth man dispatched to Goodes. The game was lost but not the lesson.
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/rfmatchreport/swans-hard-work-shows-up-tigers/2009/08/09/1249756209795.html?page=fullpage#contentSwap1