Changes next week for the doggies game?

[taztiger4]

B: Newman Thursfield Connors
HB: Farmer Moore McGuane
C: Cotchin Deledio Nason
HF: Cousins Astbury Roberts
F: Nahas Reiwoldt Morton

R: Browne Jackson Martin

Int: Vickory Collins Thomson Tambling

Out Edwards, Simmonds, Hislop
In Astbury, Browne, Collins

Post ? is he injured od a bit underdone ?

[jackstar is back again]

Couldnt possibly play Nahas again, they are kidding themselves.Any player who doesnt attack the ball when in dispute but look at his opponents arent going win you many games, it certainily wont win you a final.
As for Richard Tambling, trade at years end.
Is never going to make an impact on a game
Cant have players trying to grab a ""hot ball"' with one hand.
At least with a Hislop, not much ability but will do everything to win the ball in dispute. Credit where its due for Tom
And Tom is only 21.

[tony_montana]

Forfeit

lol
wow its going to be ugly next week

[rufio_1991]

OUT: Newman, Nahas, Tambling, Vickery.
IN: Tuck, Post, Browne, Polo.

[1965]

I think I might wait and see how the boys do for Coburg on the weekend.

 

[tigersalive]

if u cant kick u cant play

out simmonds thomson hislop moore nahas connors
in browne taylor post king astbury and another kid, donmt care who it is

Does not compute.

[WA Tiger]

I hope the hell Johnson plays for the Dogs on Sunday otherwise we will play them on his 350th and that is the scariest thing we will ever encounter..

[Chuck17]

if u cant kick u cant play

out simmonds thomson hislop moore nahas connors
in browne taylor post king astbury and another kid, donmt care who it is

Does not compute.

I thought we must have drafted another King into the side.

[Hellenic Tiger]

Mark my words Simmo will be retained and Minson and Hudson will go bezerk against us.

What I would like to see is a few ins of the ilk of

Astbury Collins Webberley Grimes Browne Taylor Rance

We should strive in this early part of the season to give a debut to a first gamer every week.

Ilk of players that should be dropped

Simmonds McGuane Nahas Tambling Thompson

Players who are deficient and have failed repetitively at this level.

[WA Tiger]

Mark my words Simmo will be retained and Minson and Hudson will go bezerk against us.

What I would like to see is a few ins of the ilk of

Astbury Collins Webberley Grimes Browne Taylor Rance

We should strive in this early part of the season to give a debut to a first gamer every week.

Ilk of players that should be dropped

Simmonds McGuane Nahas Tambling Thompson

Players who are deficient and have failed repetitively at this level.

And Edwards BTW!! We are going to be ........... Simmonds, McGuane and Tambling have more experience than most, I agree with playing the kids but at this rate we may as well play the Coburg side. How do we build if we make so many changes, Hardwick already said he would do that.

[Hellenic Tiger]

Mark my words Simmo will be retained and Minson and Hudson will go bezerk against us.

What I would like to see is a few ins of the ilk of

Astbury Collins Webberley Grimes Browne Taylor Rance

We should strive in this early part of the season to give a debut to a first gamer every week.

Ilk of players that should be dropped

Simmonds McGuane Nahas Tambling Thompson

Players who are deficient and have failed repetitively at this level.

And Edwards BTW!! We are going to be ........... Simmonds, McGuane and Tambling have more experience than most, I agree with playing the kids but at this rate we may as well play the Coburg side. How do we build if we make so many changes, Hardwick already said he would do that.

To expect all of those changes in one week is nuts WAT, as I said I would hope that some of the names I mentioned get to play. Yep we need some experience out there too agree wholeheartedly there but that experience that remains must not hinder the opportunity of a newbie. Eventually all these kids will be thrown to the wolves this year and one only hopes it helps to fastrack their learning experience. At least if we play the kids one feels we may be going somewhere with these kids future and the future of the RFC one way or another.

[WA Tiger]

Mark my words Simmo will be retained and Minson and Hudson will go bezerk against us.

What I would like to see is a few ins of the ilk of

Astbury Collins Webberley Grimes Browne Taylor Rance

We should strive in this early part of the season to give a debut to a first gamer every week.

Ilk of players that should be dropped

Simmonds McGuane Nahas Tambling Thompson

Players who are deficient and have failed repetitively at this level.

And Edwards BTW!! We are going to be ........... Simmonds, McGuane and Tambling have more experience than most, I agree with playing the kids but at this rate we may as well play the Coburg side. How do we build if we make so many changes, Hardwick already said he would do that.

To expect all of those changes in one week is nuts WAT, as I said I would hope that some of the names I mentioned get to play. Yep we need some experience out there too agree wholeheartedly there but that experience that remains must not hinder the opportunity of a newbie. Eventually all these kids will be thrown to the wolves this year and one only hopes it helps to fastrack their learning experience. At least if we play the kids one feels we may be going somewhere with these kids future and the future of the RFC one way or another.

Cool man, agree.. . stuff the wolves, I hate them mofo's.

[yellowandback]

I'd keep the changes to a couple.......3 at the most. Because you are really just shifting chairs and it is too disruptive to overall team when making massive changes.
2-3 changes demonstrates turnover for poor performance 5 or more smacks of straw clutching - not a smart ploy with 21 games remaining.
It would be fair too say that 40 odd players on our list will get a game this year, it's just a matter of when.

Troy Simmonds is as ineffective a player as Jordan and infinitely worse than Shane Tuck.
It sent the wrong message retaining him, it sent a disengaging message putting him in the leadership team and it would be a disgrace to see him ever disrespect our jumper by playing for Richmond ever again.
You could not play worse as a ruckman so throw either browne or Graham into the team.
I think Tambo should be sent a message by dropping him. You have to wonder how many games he'd have if he was drafted at 60 instead of 4. Great bloke and I reckon a good player in a top 4 team.
Leave the rest and flog 'em on the track this week. Get hafey to take training. He'd embarass a few of them  and find many of them out.
Pack of soft coks.

[jackstar is back again]

You couldnt possibly play Graham or Browne next week.
Forget about Rance as well.
Would be playing Tuck next week and possibly McMahon at the dome.
Did I just say McMahon .
Thats how bad we are

[Infamy]

You couldnt possibly play Graham or Browne next week.
Forget about Rance as well.
Would be playing Tuck next week and possibly McMahon at the dome.
Did I just say McMahon .
Thats how bad we are

What happened to Richmond "surprising" this year?