I had Chaffey as the 6th or 7th best player at Richmond before this year. This year his kicking got worse, he didn't use his aerial abilities like he had in the past, he looked more tentative than in previous years and he would have been struggling to be in the top 22 by years end.
I'm not sure what went wrong this year, or whether it was just that he overachieved in 2002, 2003 and I then overrated him, but I expect him to do a little better next year than he did this year.
By the way just on Liberatore, though he became a dirty prick in the twilight of his career, I thought he was a little champion in the early to mid 90's. I was watching the round 16 match between Richmond v Footscray in 1994 and Liberatore was an absolute star back then.