All other trade talk

[mightytiges]

Damien Barrett just reckoned before a swap of Tambling for Mark Blake would be a good deal for Richmond as "he's a premiership ruckman" 

Who is made look good by the sheer talent and experience around him. No thanks!!!

Mackie would be handy though....

Tambling for Mackie - straight swap?

Mackie is 26 so too old for us IMO. He also plays HB so it's not a position we really lack nor can't find in the draft.

Geelong recruiter on 3aw said no club has mentioned Blake's name so Barrett is just being an idiot.

[tiga]

Geelong recruiter on 3aw said no club has mentioned Blake's name so Barrett is just being an idiot.

Well that's a given....

[Penelope]

Damien Barrett just reckoned before a swap of Tambling for Mark Blake would be a good deal for Richmond as "he's a premiership ruckman" 

Who is made look good by the sheer talent and experience around him. No thanks!!!

Mackie would be handy though....

Tambling for Mackie - straight swap?

Mackie is 26 so too old for us IMO. He also plays HB so it's not a position we really lack nor can't find in the draft.

All the players supposedly targeted have been 24 or under.
Cameron said that 20-23 was the age group they were interested in so yes Mackie is too old.

[WilliamPowell]

That's the other thing if he hated us why agree to a new contract only two months or so ago. He could have hold off contract discussions and walked to the Gold Coast. We would've got a similar pick in the 20s as compo so it wouldn't have made a difference to the RFC as it seemingly will turn out.

I will repeat Tambling DID NOT sign a contract extension a few months ago

The Club extended his contract at the end of the 2009 season. Coming into 2010 the extension was signed and sealed

[Rodgerramjet]

Tambling absolutely hates us.

Nothing could be further from the truth

Don't take what Ricky Nixon says as gospel to what his client's think

Ramps is right on the money

You obviously didn't read my second post on this subject.

My first post was an immeadiate reaction to the article without giving it any thought. On reflection you have my second post which is alot closer to the truth.

[WilliamPowell]

You obviously didn't read my second post on this subject.

My first post was an immeadiate reaction to the article without giving it any thought. On reflection you have my second post which is alot closer to the truth.

Sorry Rodger - you are correct! I posted without reading all the other posts and then I had to go out - that'll teach me 

[WilliamPowell]

Yep it was Miller.

Possibly but there was other person who may have some input into it

[Francois Jackson]

Tambling absolutely hates us.

Nothing could be further from the truth

Don't take what Ricky Nixon says as gospel to what his client's think

Ramps is right on the money

With the greatest respect what makes you on expert on Tambling, WP?

your mate there Ritchie is the softest player on our list. He gladfully signed the contract and took the clubs money and then when he hits the field he plays like he doesn't want to be there. He has played the last year like he doesn't want to be there.

He is a 2 faced fool that let a draft selection get the better of his football career. End of story.

[3rogerd]

250k not enough, well done tiges

[WilliamPowell]

With the greatest respect what makes you on expert on Tambling, WP?

your mate there Ritchie is the softest player on our list. He gladfully signed the contract and took the clubs money and then when he hits the field he plays like he doesn't want to be there. He has played the last year like he doesn't want to be there.

He is a 2 faced fool that let a draft selection get the better of his football career. End of story.

daniel I am not talking about his performances this season - you've dragged that into it

The statement was "Tambling absolutely hates us"

I replied to that and that only. My view is and I posted it and that was that IMO and that is nothing could be further from the truth. I added that on top of that I wouldn't take what Nixon said as being what his client thinks... Ricky Nixon makes comments about things to get the best possible deal for .............. RICKY NIXON not necessarily his clients

End of story

When it's all said and done of the bloke wants to leave and people like you daniel want him gone then what does it matter how he goes as long as he goes

[Owl]

Tambling absolutely hates us.

Nothing could be further from the truth

Don't take what Ricky Nixon says as gospel to what his client's think

Ramps is right on the money

With the greatest respect what makes you on expert on Tambling, WP?

your mate there Ritchie is the softest player on our list. He gladfully signed the contract and took the clubs money and then when he hits the field he plays like he doesn't want to be there. He has played the last year like he doesn't want to be there.

He is a 2 faced fool that let a draft selection get the better of his football career. End of story.

So much hate....what he do poke your missus and wipe the curtains?



Edit: Let's keep the discussion above the waistline and back on topic.

[tony_montana]

Yep it was Miller.

Possibly but there was other person who may have some input into it

jackstar? 

[one-eyed]

WHICH players is your club interested? Trade week began with little happening but here is the low-down after the opening day.

Chris Tarrant (Fremantle): Wants to be welcomed back to Collingwood but there are stumbling blocks. Freo wants a premiership player. Hawthorn and Carlton interested.

Leon Davis (Collingwood): Pies would entertain a trade but clubs aren't knocking down the door. Perth best hope but Fremantle not keen.

Mitch Clark (Brisbane): Wants to go home to WA but Victorian clubs very keen - as are the Lions. Manager says you better have the dollars.

Justin Sherman (Brisbane): Wants to go to the Bulldogs, and history says that means the deal gets done.

Bachar Houli (Essendon): Bombers want him but will trade. The Tigers have an offer on the table.

Setanta O'hAilpin (Carlton): Dogs are sniffing around the Irishman in what could be a surprise deal.

John Anthony (Collingwood): Part of the Tarrant talks - but remember, the Dockers want a premiership player.

Shaun Grigg (Carlton): Out of the Blues and has the Tigers and Suns hot on his trail.

Josh Fraser (Collingwood): Could be, would be, maybe ... no one really knows. Gold Coast a chance.

Jared Brennan (Brisbane): Big dollars required. Gold Coast on pole, Carlton second on grid.

Patrick Veszpremi (Sydney): Welcome to the western suburbs, Patrick. Dogs well placed.

Andrew Krakouer (WAFL): Tricky. Should be listed by Gold Coast, but then will be ontraded to West Coast or Collingwood.

Andrew Walker (Carlton): Adelaide firming. Dogs will struggle to get a deal done.

Sam Jacobs (Carlton): Wants the Crows but Carlton baulking at asking prize. Is he worth pick 14? Doubtful.

Andrejs Everitt (WB): Set to follow in footsteps of his brother Peter by landing in Sydney - Everitt for Veszpremi a chance. Freo sniffing.

David Hale (North Melb): Melbourne and Gold Coast out in front, Hawks emerging from the pack.

Nathan Djerrkura (Geelong): Western Bulldogs keen but if it happens, will be late in the week.

Mark Blake (Geelong): No interest yesterday for the disgruntled ruckman.

Ben McKinley (West Coast): Wants to come home to Victoria and live on either Arden St or Royal Pde.

Jonathon Griffin (Adelaide): Wants to live in Perth.

Matt Spangher (West Coast): Looking for a Melbourne home.

Sam Sheldon (Brisbane): Injuries and limited opportunities cruelled time up north - looking to come home to Victoria.

Daniel Motlop (Port Adelaide): Wants to head west for family reasons.

Brennan Stack (W Bulldogs): Has ties to Western Australia.

Josh Hill (W Bulldogs): West Coast the frontrunner.

Stephen Tiller (W Bulldogs): Wants out of Whitten Oval - mild interest.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/trade-week-off-to-sluggish-start-after-day-one/story-e6frf9jf-1225934576871

[one-eyed]

The Age's possible trades

Bulldog Andrejs Everitt for Sydney forward Patrick Veszpremi and a late draft pick.

Lion Justin Sherman in exchange for the Bulldogs' compensation pick they received for Jarrod Harbrow's move to the Gold Coast.

Bulldogs could delist and then trade Will Minson, plus the compensation pick they would receive for him, to the Gold Coast, receiving pick 44 and one of the pre-listed players the new club is able to trade in return.

The Dogs may also do a late deal for Geelong's Nathan Djerrkura, possibly for Stephen Tiller.

Carlton wants in exchange for Sam Jacobs, the compensation pick the Crows received for the Gold Coast-bound Nathan Bock - at the end of the first round - but the Crows want only to swap first-round draft picks so they can give Carlton their No. 14 pick and get the Blues' No. 18. The Blues knocked back a straight swap for Adelaide's second-round pick, in the 30s.

Demons would trade their first and second-round picks in exchange for David Hale and North's first-round pick.

The Lions are seeking two first-round draft picks from the Gold Coast for utility Jared Brennan. Talks last night centred on a deal involving Brennan and pick 10 to the Gold Coast, with the Suns giving back pick five and a later first-round pick, possibly pick 20 they could secure from Fremantle in a complicated side deal involving compensation picks and pre-listed players.

Fremantle and Collingwood made no headway in negotiating a path for Chris Tarrant to return to the Magpies. The Dockers inquired unsuccessfully about premiership players Chris Dawes, Tyson Goldsack and Sharrod Wellingham. Collingwood suggested John Anthony, who is open to a trade, and Leon Davis.

Uncertainty over the future of enigmatic forward Carl Peterson and a decision to cut goalsneak Rhan Hooper after just one season has increased Hawthorn's push for out-of-favour Bulldog Josh Hill

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/hawks-look-to-move-on-hill-as-bulldogs-call-the-shots-in-trade-week-20101005-1663v.html

[WA Tiger]

Not doing/linked to much player trade wise are we, not sure why some at Richmond raved on about how involved we were going to be... ???