All other trade talk

[torch]

No, torch. It seems brennan is not traded to GC. GC do not loose a pick, but brisbane gain one, still to be decided which.
This is an extra pick pulled out of thin air that pushes all picks after back by one.

Big difference.

Then how did Brennan get to CG?

Why did GC give Brisbane Pick 5?

[cub]

McMahon ? No movement, offers  ???

[Smokey]

McMahon ? No movement, offers  ???

One movement - door!

[torch]

McMahon ? No movement, offers  ???

One movement - door!

We should celebrate!

 

[mightytiges]

No, torch. It seems brennan is not traded to GC. GC do not loose a pick, but brisbane gain one, still to be decided which.
This is an extra pick pulled out of thin air that pushes all picks after back by one.

Big difference.

Then how did Brennan get to CG?

Why did GC give Brisbane Pick 5?

New rules from last year allow clubs to swap draft picks without a player needing to be involved in the trade. It allows greater flexibility during trade week as two or more clubs can initially agree to do a trade in principle with most of the player swapping details sorted out immediately while the clubs then go and work on other deals. They then all come back together later on when those other deals are done and agree to exchange draft picks between them to balance things out and make everyone happy.

So the trade of swapping Brisbane's pick 10 for Gold Coast's pick 5 plus Collingwood's compo pick was technically done separately to Brisbane allowing Brennan as an uncontracted player to go to the Gold Coast for which the Lions receive a compo pick themselves. I hope that makes sense.

[torch]

No, torch. It seems brennan is not traded to GC. GC do not loose a pick, but brisbane gain one, still to be decided which.
This is an extra pick pulled out of thin air that pushes all picks after back by one.

Big difference.

Then how did Brennan get to CG?

Why did GC give Brisbane Pick 5?

New rules from last year allow clubs to swap draft picks without a player needing to be involved in the trade. It allows greater flexibility during trade week as two or more clubs can initially agree to do a trade in principle with most of the player swapping details sorted out immediately while the clubs then go and work on other deals. They then all come back together later on when those other deals are done and agree to exchange draft picks between them to balance things out and make everyone happy.

So the trade of swapping Brisbane's pick 10 for Gold Coast's pick 5 plus Collingwood's compo pick was technically done separately to Brisbane allowing Brennan as an uncontracted player to go to the Gold Coast for which the Lions receive a compo pick themselves. I hope that makes sense.

It does make sense.

al, you are correct, which wil you said mate, we get pushed down the order.

Brisbane gave the "OK" for Brennan and The Suns(?) to sign Brennan as another uncontracted player.

Understand and have no issue, it is a win-win for both clubs i guess.

The loser is the clubs that have picks after Brisbane receive their "Compo Pick" for Brennan.

 

[one-eyed]

Trade week Day 3 summary

Blues utility Andrew Walker could be heading to South Australia. Port is understood to be considering handing the Blues its first national draft selection, pick 16, which Carlton would certainly accept.

Hawthorn is on the brink of snaring David Hale after trumping Melbourne's offer for the North Melbourne ruckman/forward. Melbourne offered up pick No.32, but the Hawks are prepared to give up the compensation pick it received for Campbell Brown departing to the Gold Coast.

Neither Adelaide nor Carlton was budging over ruckman Sam Jacobs, the Blues insisting on a first-round pick and the Crows offering a second-round choice (around No. 33). The Crows were hopeful a deal would be brokered by Monday.

Justin Sherman may finish trade week where he started it - as a Brisbane Lion - with the Swans told yesterday that he would rather see out the final year of his contract with Brisbane than move to Sydney. The Lions prefer Sydney's offer of pick 21 to the Bulldogs' pledge of a late-20s pick - their compensation selection for losing Jarrod Harbrow to the Gold Coast - but their hand may be forced should the Swans accept Sherman's reluctance and back away.

Talks between Collingwood and Fremantle on Chris Tarrant are also expected to stretch to the death. The Dockers want a player or, at the very least, a mid-range pick. Collingwood's pick No.25 is now gone in return for Andrew Krakouer.

Another player to be pre-listed by Gold Coast - North Ballarat defender Cam Richardson - has told the club he wants only to be drafted to North Melbourne, the Roosters' AFL affiliate.

Nathan Djerrkura remains likely to end up at either the Western Bulldogs or Hawthorn, with the Cats keen to get that deal moving soon.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/sport/josh-fraser-joins-jared-brennan-at-gold-coast-suns/story-e6frg7mf-1225935678533
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/all-hale-hawks-big-trade-coup/story-e6frf9jf-1225935674208
http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/sherman-demands-to-be-dog-or-stay-a-lion-20101007-169sf.html

[tiger101]

hale to hawks for the compo pick they got for brown to kangaroos

[wayne]

Don't know if anyone believes RFC_Official is actually an RFC Official, but he says that we were very, very, close to doing a deal yesterday and said that he wasn't necessarily talking about Houli.

[one-eyed]

Nathan Djerrkura off to the Bulldogs for their third-round selection which currently sits at 57.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/103908/default.aspx

[wayne]

Brad Ebert wants to be traded to Port Adelaide according to Trade Talk radio.

[one-eyed]

Hawthorn has clinched the deal to secure Kangaroos' ruckman David Hale. Roos get late first round draft pick in return - Hawks’ compensation pick for Campbell Brown..

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/hawks-land-hale/story-e6frf9jf-1225935970630

[tiger101]

thompson just looked like a dumb arse on tradeweek radio saying bris dont get a compo pick for agreeing to GC picking up a 2nd uncontracted player than got corrected by an emailer lol

[one-eyed]

Eagle McKinley off to the North for a late pick

[tiger101]

Eagle McKinley off to the North for a late pick

pick #86  north couldnt go wrong with that trade.