Last Chance Saloon for Titch?

[Francois Jackson]

anyone who rates him obviously doesnt go to games. Last year he played a few good games but never tore the game apart.

He is too skinny and more than that he is just plan dumb.

Useless farq

[Francois Jackson]

He's eithr too effing stupid or not talented in a defensive sense.

eff off.

bloke his dumb. Just a very dumb footballer

Did you go to the game tonight? See that effort against Blair which resulted in a Collingwood goal. Watch the tape.

What an embarassing effort that was.

Ramps its too late we said farq him off last year now once again he is worthless

[wayne]

you cant be a midfielder and have been around as long as he has and be making mistakes like he does.

He's a momentum killer, cost us goals, sure he might create some, but turns it over way too much and under no pressure at all half the time.

In a side that contains iffy disposers like Jackson and White, he stands out like dogs balls.

[jackstar is back again]

disgraceful effort.
Wasnt happy when he gave up chasing in the 3rd Q either.
Isnt a AFL Player

[tony_montana]

He's a momentum killer

Thats it in a nutshell and we look to him to be a creator, he is just too flimsical with his disposal, tonight he made 3 or 4 massive key errors which just stuffed us.

[Siberian]

Morton and Tuck are not world beaters, but they offer a lot more than this clown. watching the replay in WA just short of half time but this guy and Graham are useless. I also think Leigh Mathews is suffering from dementia, what is he talking about?

[Loui Tufga]

watching the replay in WA just short of half time but this guy and Graham are useless.

lol...Hold on to your hat, wait till the third!!

[Siberian]

I'm trying to survive Harley and Montagna as we speak! What a bunch of clowns!

[WilliamPowell]

disgraceful effort.
Wasnt happy when he gave up chasing in the 3rd Q either.

Sadly I agree

He was disgraceful last night

My goodness why did we sub Nahas out of the game and leave the this week's clanger king out there to butcher the ball int he final qtr?

Can anyone expalin it to me

[TigerLand]

*Sighs*

Edwards needs 6 weeks at Coburg in a forward pocket.

He isn't a midfielder, he isn't a wingman he is certainly not a rebounding defender.

If he can't mould into a small forward he'll be searching seek.com for a new career in August.

[Darth Tiger]

Surely there are better options off half-back than a guy who cannot keep his feet in contests, turns the ball over with poor lateral kicking efficiency and gets swiped away in tackles.

No more C graders !!!

Explore other transition options, please Dimma.

[mat073]

Shane Edwards can not kick....unfortunately after 70 odd games it may be time to count our losses.

I dont think he is ever going to make it.You never know...Port Adelaide might swap us pick 80 for young Titch.

[eliminator]

He is not a midfielder and not a defender. At best he is a forward porket but his kicking is woeful. I totally agree with the comments that he is a momentum killer. I remember one shot in the third quarter went out on the full. He turned the ball over under no pressure. Tuck is a 100 times better than him. Tuck can kick a goal, Tuck can take a contested grab and Tuck wins his own ball. The Thrashing Thomas gave Edwards for me may have spelt the end of the career of Edwards

[Dubstep Dookie]

He's a momentum killer, cost us goals, sure he might create some, but turns it over way too much and under no pressure at all half the time.

  it in nutshell.

[Francois Jackson]

The bloke cost us 3 goals last night

1. Poor kick in the 3rd out on the full

2. Blair pushing him like he was a feather in the goal square

3. Stopped running toward an opponent in the 3rd lead to yet another goal.

When is the RFc going to wake up to themselves. I just cant see how this bloke can be anywhere in our future plans. Tuck also but gee Tucky is so much of a better option than this spud. If your going down the youth path why Miller then?

He disposal is shocking, is so skinny gets pushed off the ball by Blair, has no awareness and IMO does not deserve to wear our jumper again.
At a pathetic 78kgs one must wonder what drugs our weights coach is on. He must be on some serious poo if you have blokes like him and Thursfield who have been in the system for 5 plus years yet still look like toothpicks.

Send him back to Coburg where he can stay.

Dont kid yourself people last year he played "okay" in only a few games and i bet they were against the Interstate teams