Who else is there that could do better than Dimma?

[Mr Magic]

Surprised there's been no mention of Wallace & Frawley.

[WilliamPowell]

People have been harping about it for nearly 30 years

Has to be










SHEEDY

But seriously, I am not sure the point of thread to be honest

Dimma will get a contract extension the only real question is how long will it be for IMV

[Owl]

Alan Jones

[The Big Richo]

Alan Jones

x2

[gerkin greg]

"Is that a wet towel on the back of my leg Mr. Jones?"

[YellowandBlackBlood]

People have been harping about it for nearly 30 years

Has to be


SHEEDY

But seriously, I am not sure the point of thread to be honest

Dimma will get a contract extension the only real question is how long will it be for IMV

Will all due respect WP, the point of the thread is to show that one cannot just say "sack Hardwick!" and end the conversation there. If he was to be sacked, someone would have to replace him who would do a better job. The simple fact is, it is hard to be sure that there is currently anyone out there who would fulfill this criterion. I am more than happy to hear people's suggestions regarding this topic.

[WilliamPowell]

Will all due respect WP, the point of the thread is to show that one cannot just say "sack Hardwick!" and end the conversation there. If he was to be sacked, someone would have to replace him who would do a better job. The simple fact is, it is hard to be sure that there is currently anyone out there who would fulfill this criterion. I am more than happy to hear people's suggestions regarding this topic.

I suppose it comes down to the fact I don't think he will be sack, seriously don't think it is an option and that he will get an extension.

Re your question asking is anyone out there who would fit? Are the answers allowed to included all current coaches even if they are contracted beyond 2012 or just former ones floating about in the media etc. Because if you are going to say "yep you can include current contracted coaches" then it becomes an even bigger hypothetical

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Will all due respect WP, the point of the thread is to show that one cannot just say "sack Hardwick!" and end the conversation there. If he was to be sacked, someone would have to replace him who would do a better job. The simple fact is, it is hard to be sure that there is currently anyone out there who would fulfill this criterion. I am more than happy to hear people's suggestions regarding this topic.

I suppose it comes down to the fact I don't think he will be sack, seriously don't think it is an option and that he will get an extension.

Re your question asking is anyone out there who would fit? Are the answers allowed to included all current coaches even if they are contracted beyond 2012 or just former ones floating about in the media etc. Because if you are going to say "yep you can include current contracted coaches" then it becomes an even bigger hypothetical

I agree that he will get an extension. Really he hasn't done a lot wrong. He did the correct thing and has built from the ground up with very limited resources.
I don't think you can include current coaches as the successful ones will be retained and any failures that get the sack we probably wouldn't look at.

[camboon]

Julia Gillard

[the claw]

lol if mick was available we would be mugs to not at least weigh it up.

lets just say at the end of this yr we finish 13th a very real possibility.lets say our bad is still terrible and the good passable.

id say the spectre of malthouse is very real and very large.

it may be a case of hardwick doing little wrong but the best man for the job getting the gig. footy can be harsh.

[Willy]

nice to see these threads up and about even before the season has begun. Onya, fellas.