Sack Hardwick [merged]

[Stalin]

but what's the point of replacing him with someone whose game style has a low chance of winning premierships?

dont get me wrong, I'm not defending Hardwick, I just dont think Lyon, or his style,is the answer.

What grand final side in recent years has not been build around a very solid defence?

I think Lyon and his style would fit the group perfectly

-.-

[Penelope]

i've put my arguments forward already and backed it up with real life facts.

your bum stuffed theories dont count counter this.

but basically if you cant kick more than 100 points per game you struggle to win premierships.

hawthorn last three years. 2452, most in the league, 2454, most in the league 2523, most in the league.

and you want to compare that with lyon coached teams, none of which have won a premiership?

I know which id prefer

[Stalin]

Your Sydney theory,

Isample size is one and two seasons and hence meaningless

I didn't say earlier to spare your feelings

[Stalin]

i've put my arguments forward already and backed it up with real life facts.

your bum stuffed theories dont count counter this.

but basically if you cant kick more than 100 points per game you struggle to win premierships.

hawthorn last three years. 2452, most in the league, 2454, most in the league 2523, most in the league.

and you want to compare that with lyon coached teams, none of which have won a premiership?

I know which id prefer

If you had the option of Clarkson or Lyon

Your words would be lovely

Yet you don't have such an option it would seem

But come back to earth it's Dimma v Lyon

[Penelope]

lmao

[Go Richo 12]

Do we have the "option" of getting Ross Lyon to Richmond?

[Chuck17]

Do we have the "option" of getting Ross Lyon to Richmond?

I prefer my fantasies to be full of other things rather than Lyons to RFC

[Stalin]

Do we have the "option" of getting Ross Lyon to Richmond?

give him enough money and probable yes

[Penelope]

and history says that chances are he wont win us a premiership, and nearly no chance he will win multiple premierships.

[Stalin]

He won one as midfield coach, beating judd/cousins/Kerr/cox will a humble group

He might win next season

[Penelope]

yeah, and Hardwick won one as an assistant too.

So he might win next too?

You can stick to your mights, I'll keep the more probables

[Stalin]

Saints DREW a grand final

And you are arguing

There is "nearly no chance", it's possible he can win one

Maybe you new a lie down ?

[Penelope]

Yes recent history shows us that if you dont coach a side to be able to average above 100 points per game, the odds are against you in terms of winning one premiership,(one team in 15 years) let alone Multiple premierships.(no teams in 15 years)

The sides that won multiple premierships in recent times all were consistently at the top of the scoring lists for those years.

Up to this point in time, teams coached by Lyon do not do this.

That is reality.

Just because you dont believe in something, reality doesnt change to suit.

[Stalin]

Lol multiple premierships

Let's win a final first eh

One last  time - you reckon the guy that drew a gf has no chance of winning a flag (be it at Richmond or freo).  Are you quite sure your happy with this position? Maybe think it over

Deep down I think u know having midfield coach flag ten year ago ,  senior coach a drawn grand final, more recently . And consistently taking teams to top two, grand finals your being a bit silly

[Penelope]

i made it very, very clear what i think.

if you want to discuss it don't change what i said to suit your own irrationality

and yes, if we get to a point we are good enough to win a premiership, i want to be in with a show of winning more than one. not just get lucky and win one against the odds.