2012 Richmond Delistings [merged]

[1965]

Reckon Gerks is a moral to get delisted from OER
 

Bit like when you got delisted from Richmond by Wallet

I wish we could delist a couple of the more painful posters on here.

Especially the funny ones. 

(  as he waits for the foul reply, thank god for the ignore list, some of the PMs have been a little nauseating )

[Coach]

I have him on my ignore list too, 65'.

[Jackstar is back!!!]

Gerks is back again again again 

Must be pretty useless to get the behind from Wallace lmao

Leave the comedy to me son
You material is a bit old

[Loui Tufga]

Gerks is back again again again 

Must be pretty useless to get the behind from Wallace lmao

Leave the comedy to me son
You material is a bit old

Old but Gold.....with a bit of truth in it to

[Jackstar is back!!!]

Give me a spell you clowns

[Andyy]

McGuane
Jackson
Nahas
White
Derickx
Graham

Enough is enough.

McGuane - 50/50. He's not going to cost much and if he does a reasonable job at filling a gap forward or backline I'd keep him. You can't blame him for our recent losses except maybe a crap game last night.
Jackson - You're joking. Every side needs tough players to go under the pack and protect the likes of young Cotchins etc. Same thing. Cheap player, tries hard, fit, tough - definitely worth keeping despite his lack of speed/skill IMO.
Nahas - Has kicked 32 goals this year. Hasn't been great the last few weeks but what more could you want? Seriously...

White - yeah I'd probably delist
Derickx - two years at RFC, one ruined by injury. Would consider another year/last chance but otherwise wouldn't be disappointed if he was delisted
Gus - As a backup ruchman for Maric I'd keep him simply for his mature body. Would rather lose Derickx or Brown.

I'd delist Post unless he pulls a miracle in the last two rounds. Would have said Miller and Moore but it looks like RFC has already acted there.

U delist a young promising tall in post but keep mcguane instead. No idea

After five years on Richmonds list I haven't seen enough from Post to label him as 'promising'. You must be blind. He takes a good mark every now and then but he hasn't put on enough size and his disposal is one of the lowest efficiencies at the club. After five years I'm almost ready to close the door unless he uses the last two games to really impress me.

McGuane isn't much better but he's tougher than Post, period. Thats why I'd keep him.

[MADTIGER2010]

Better idea than playing post 

Yeah if you don't really care about the club 

[Coach]

The club is stuffed if they delist Post. The point of no return

[MADTIGER2010]

Post is in his 4th year with about 30 games.
Grimes, astbury and griffiths are in their 3rd years with about 20 games.
Rance is in his 5th year with about 60 games.

The 4th or 5th year is where all these guys will flourish

[tigercub2012]

I can't wait 
You beauty we have hope
Hang in there members we are still on track but we must play finals next year

[torch]

Shane Edwards
Luke McGuane
Matthew White
Daniel Jackson

Matthew Dea
Dean MacDonald
Angus Graham
Andrew Browne

Daniel Connors
Kelvin Moore

They all need to be off our list!

ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!

DO WHATEVER IT TAKES TO GET RID OF THEM!

Dea will not be gone kid is in his third year.
Graham and Jako have a year to run after this year and can't be traded as nobody will be interested.
Edwards will not be going either.
Browne is questionable, You think Torch Browne should be delisted or Derickx?
Agree on White and McGuane.
As for the others why mention 3 players who have either retired been delisted or have no hope of coming back to the club and back on your earlier points why mention some players who didn't even play today?

I would keep Derickx because he is more agile then Browne. Browne is to slow!

I would offer Graham and Jackson to GWS for anything.

Dea is a genuine "nothing" player.

Edwards I would trade as bait to Adelaide or Port Adelaide!

[Ruanaidh]

miller heslin and one other rookies giving us 4 selections here.

I hope that 'other rookie' is A Maric. Piva, Ben and Gibson deserve one more year to sus-out if they can improve or not. Maric is older and just isn't up to it.

[gerkin greg]

So far ive got

Senior:
Moore - retired
Connors - sacked
McDonald - quitter
McGuane - delist
Webberley - delist
Graham - delist
Derickx - delist

Rookie:
Miller - retired
Maric - delist
Heslin - quitter

7 senior spots I predict 4 draft picks 3 free agents all going to plan, maybe 5 picks 2 agents

Pretty sure we don't have a full compliment of rookies so 4 new rookies, at least 2 mature age, plus international outside list Gideon Simon

12 new players
Good clean out IMO

[Loui Tufga]

So far ive got

Senior:
Moore - retired
Connors - sacked
McDonald - quitter
McGuane - delist
Webberley - delist
Graham - delist
Derickx - delist

Rookie:
Miller - retired
Maric - delist
Heslin - quitter

7 senior spots I predict 4 draft picks 3 free agents all going to plan, maybe 5 picks 2 agents

Pretty sure we don't have a full compliment of rookies so 4 new rookies, at least 2 mature age, plus international outside list Gideon Simon

12 new players
Good clean out IMO

You can now add Tigermonk to the quitters list

[YellowandBlackBlood]

 

So far ive got

Senior:
Moore - retired
Connors - sacked
McDonald - quitter
McGuane - delist
Webberley - delist
Graham - delist
Derickx - delist

Rookie:
Miller - retired
Maric - delist
Heslin - quitter

7 senior spots I predict 4 draft picks 3 free agents all going to plan, maybe 5 picks 2 agents

Pretty sure we don't have a full compliment of rookies so 4 new rookies, at least 2 mature age, plus international outside list Gideon Simon

12 new players
Good clean out IMO

Pretty good clean out Gerks. Think you've nailed it this time.
Hope the club has the same opinion.