Whose not up to it at Punt Rd!

[PuntRdRoar]

Not in any order but...

Mark Chaffey should be traded if we can get anything for him
Greg Tivendale should be traded if we can get anything for him
Andrew Krakouer should be traded
and
Ray Hall should be traded
Mark Graham should retire...
and theres afew others as well but i cant be stuffed naming names 

[JohnF]

add to that list:
-Campbell should retire at year's end
-Hilton should be delisted
-Morrison should be delisted
-Pettifer is borderline

There's probably quite a few kids we've got that won't be up to it as well but its too early to write them off just yet

[PuntRdRoar]

should we make a play for any players from other clubs...im not talking superstars...but for example...i think someone like Cameron Mooney from Geelong who is probably gonna get the arse from Kardinia Park wouldnt be bad at Punt Rd. Our kids would be better off if we had a couple of nutters in the starting 18. Brian Harris would be useful to.

[Ox]

Whoever it is,they'll find there's nowhere to hide now.

[Moi]

The good thing about doing a list this year is that the list is getting smaller.
We would have had about 20 last year and we managed to turn over a bit of our list.
Hate to say it, but if Roachy and Rainesy don't do something soon, I don't they might be cut in the next year or so.  But think there's a few before them based on their youth.

[mightytiges]

Wait until the end of the season before deciding.

I think circumstances will save Razor especially if Graham retires. We don't have enough key defenders as it is and he's done the job so far asked of him this year and beaten some decent forwards (Tredrea, Pavlich and Whitnall  ). He needs to come back this week and repay the Club for stupidly getting reported.

Cambo will retire while Rory and Morrison look gone already if they can't get a senior game in the next few weeks.

On the 3aw broadcast they said Wallace wasn't too pleased with some of Pettifer's and Tivs efforts against Melbourne.

[letsgetiton!]

i cant believe ppl are mentioning guys lkiek graham, who has been gr8 this yr!!!
campbell , fantastic off teh bench , hope he plays on
petts, come on, he is showing gr8 things!
krak, as above , name one player in the afl who plays 22 fantastic games in a row!!

guys like chaffey and tive are the ones who are letting us dwn

[Ox]

Definitely TIVENDALE.

He should be dropped out of a 20 storey building ffs.

[Bulluss]

The players who arent accountable for their opponents.

Tiva, Chaffey, Pettifer(has improved, but must man up)

And last but certainly not least KRAKOUER- his accountability to his opponent is probably the worst in our team. The way in which he constantly let Nathan Brown run off him was pathetic.

Krak is a joke for someone being paid $250 big ones, total waste of money.

[letsgetiton!]

The players who arent accountable for their opponents.

 Pettifer(has improved, but must man up)

his man was bizzel who was zoning off him1 if teh tigers were smarter and stopped boming to richo ,
 petts would have had a field day and made biz accountable thus free up richo!!!

[miastar]

I think Ray Hall has been pretty good this year.

Hilton can play and kick goals.  They should give hime a chance if he is  match fit. Kicked four on the weekend for Coburg.

Morrison has been playing OK for Coburg.  If he was ever going to get a game you would have thought it was on Friday with Hall out.

I think if  they get their opportunity and don't perform then their fate is in their own hands.