James Frawley

[Judge Roughneck]

WAT, our key defensive stocks look pretty good when compared with Key Forwards?
Whose spot does Frawley take?

Darrou as vfl full back

[Judge Roughneck]

WAT, our key defensive stocks look pretty good when compared with Key Forwards?
Whose spot does Frawley take?

Not sure they do, we said that years ago when we didn't recruit anyone and ended up taking Chaplin later on. I really think forward with Riewoldt, Griffiths, Hampson(will play there resting) , Vickery, Ivan, Lloyd and all the wingmen and midfielders we have kicking goals we are more than covered.

Down back, Newman will play his last year, Chaplin will be around 29, I am still not sold on Grimes holding up though he is very good, Rance will be there but honestly who else, with size and height..

Astbury, darrou, McIntosh

[WA Tiger]

WAT, our key defensive stocks look pretty good when compared with Key Forwards?
Whose spot does Frawley take?

Not sure they do, we said that years ago when we didn't recruit anyone and ended up taking Chaplin later on. I really think forward with Riewoldt, Griffiths, Hampson(will play there resting) , Vickery, Ivan, Lloyd and all the wingmen and midfielders we have kicking goals we are more than covered.

Down back, Newman will play his last year, Chaplin will be around 29, I am still not sold on Grimes holding up though he is very good, Rance will be there but honestly who else, with size and height..

Astbury, darrou, McIntosh

Astbury has still not proven himself and may nor, Darrou-you cant even count him, McIntosh-see Darrou. Frawley is proven.

[Penelope]

now apply the same thought process to the forward line.

[Judge Roughneck]

Forward line macking

HF: Martin / Cotchin
CHF: Deledio
HF: Lennon
FP: McBean
FF: Riewoldt
FP: Vickery / Maric / Griffiths / Hampson / Astbury / Elton / Aaron Edwards

+ rotation = Conca. Ellis. Vlastuin. Foley. Gordon. Lloyd. McDonuts. Bannfield. Aarnot. Knights. Ohanlon. Shane Edwards. King. Helbig...

Loaded plus Locked

[WA Tiger]

Forward line macking

HF: Martin / Cotchin
CHF: Deledio
HF: Lennon
FP: McBean
FF: Riewoldt
FP: Vickery / Maric / Griffiths / Hampson / Astbury / Elton / Aaron Edwards

+ rotation = Conca. Ellis. Vlastuin. Foley. Gordon. Lloyd. McDonuts. Bannfield. Aarnot. Knights. Ohanlon. Shane Edwards. King. Helbig...

Loaded plus Locked

 ..spot on the money.

Al, I honestly can't believe your comment, I thought you were more onto it than that mate..

[Willy]

WAT's not even angry. Just disappointed....

[WA Tiger]

WAT's not even angry. Just disappointed....

Please enlighten me William.

[Willy]

WAT's not even angry. Just disappointed....

Please enlighten me William.

Just sounded disappointed in Al in your last post.

[WA Tiger]

WAT's not even angry. Just disappointed....

Please enlighten me William.

Just sounded disappointed in Al in your last post.

Ah yes I was mate, the messiah let me down..

[Hard Roar Tiger]

WAT, our key defensive stocks look pretty good when compared with Key Forwards?
Whose spot does Frawley take?

Not sure they do, we said that years ago when we didn't recruit anyone and ended up taking Chaplin later on. I really think forward with Riewoldt, Griffiths, Hampson(will play there resting) , Vickery, Ivan, Lloyd and all the wingmen and midfielders we have kicking goals we are more than covered.

Down back, Newman will play his last year, Chaplin will be around 29, I am still not sold on Grimes holding up though he is very good, Rance will be there but honestly who else, with size and height..

When you put it like that, the forward line makes me more nervous than the back line. If Jack has a big injury, we might struggle. Beyond Jack we need mids to kick goals unless Vickers can finally arrive as a key forward - a big if.

[Yeahright]

Forward line macking

HF: Martin / Cotchin
CHF: Deledio
HF: Lennon
FP: McBean
FF: Riewoldt
FP: Vickery / Maric / Griffiths / Hampson / Astbury / Elton / Aaron Edwards

+ rotation = Conca. Ellis. Vlastuin. Foley. Gordon. Lloyd. McDonuts. Bannfield. Aarnot. Knights. Ohanlon. Shane Edwards. King. Helbig...

Loaded plus Locked

 ..spot on the money.

Al, I honestly can't believe your comment, I thought you were more onto it than that mate..

Quality > quantity, and boy is that lacking some quality if you remove the players that would have to be playing in the midfield

[Diocletian]

Frawley's just what need, but jeez I hope we're planning to make a big play for Jeremy Cameron the following year. I'd even arrange Martin's "tour of facilities" and drive him up there myself this time, if that's what it took.

As for lower profile fa's next year, reckon Ibbotson's worth a crack. Massively underrated.

[yellowandback]

Frawley's just what need, but jeez I hope we're planning to make a big play for Jeremy Cameron the following year. I'd even arrange Martin's "tour of facilities" and drive him up there myself this time, if that's what it took.

As for lower profile fa's next year, reckon Ibbotson's worth a crack. Massively underrated.

Your dreaming with Cameron. Remember they have a billion $ salary cap.

[WA Tiger]

WAT, our key defensive stocks look pretty good when compared with Key Forwards?
Whose spot does Frawley take?

Not sure they do, we said that years ago when we didn't recruit anyone and ended up taking Chaplin later on. I really think forward with Riewoldt, Griffiths, Hampson(will play there resting) , Vickery, Ivan, Lloyd and all the wingmen and midfielders we have kicking goals we are more than covered.

Down back, Newman will play his last year, Chaplin will be around 29, I am still not sold on Grimes holding up though he is very good, Rance will be there but honestly who else, with size and height..

When you put it like that, the forward line makes me more nervous than the back line. If Jack has a big injury, we might struggle. Beyond Jack we need mids to kick goals unless Vickers can finally arrive as a key forward - a big if.

See your point but we would have to have Riewoldt, A.Edwards, Vickery, a ruckman and a couple of mids go down at the same time for any concern as far as I can see.

Now if we have Rance and Chaplin go down or one of those two and Grimes we are in it deep, we just don't have the backups. Next year will be worse with Newman leaving.