Tivendale, Bowden and Chaffey should Go!

[Razorblade]

I'm pretty sure Tivendale had a lot of pine time, however when i did see him (not often) nearly EVERY possession of his was effective (or not a complete stuff up), so i've got no problems with him playing next week.

IMO he is suited a lot better at the MCG, where there is more space for him to do what he does.

I'd like to see him play against the saints at the G next week.

As for Simmonds, i made a post about him in another thread about him, but i wouldn't drop him.

[mightytiges]

Tivs did alright today. No noticable stuff-ups with is kicking. In fact did a great pass along the boundary line when squeezed on the members wing. The guy behind nearly spilt his beer when he found out who kicked it - "sh...., that was Tivendale" lol.

As for Chaff he's making me forget how bad he was last year. Totally spanked Hird. I can only think of two influential things Hird did - a chip pass to Lloyd and a goal to himself. The latter shouldn't a free to Hird either.

Joel will be happy - perfect winning record as captain  .

[Razorblade]

Ok i am convinced now that Tivendale plays 20 times better at the MCG then Telstra Dome!

As for Chaff owning Hird today,

[mightytiges]

Ok i am convinced now that Tivendale plays 20 times better at the MCG then Telstra Dome!

Yeah you're right Razor. Tivs does seem to play better at the MCG. Maybe the 'G being a bigger ground gives him more time and opportunity to swing on his left foot and kick long.