Edwards vs McGuane

[Ruanaidh]

Unfortunately, Edwards and McGuane may have stalled the development of Griff and Elton. In any case, it's one or the other and my vote is for Edwards. He is just a more natural footballer. In Finals hacks and 'athletes' are found-out whilst pure footballers rise to the top.

[Judge Roughneck]

Az has clearly now jumped ahead of Lukey. I gave him B.O.G. today. He needs though to back up that workrate and influence on the match next week before we head into the finals.

A Edwards has always been better than Lukas IMO. McGaune doesnt have much going for him outside of his defensive pressure.





Edited:  not funny, you know the rules re posting things that legally can get this site in trouble even in jest and what you posted falls into that category

[Stripes]

I still would take McGuane for his defensive pressure but Azza did show much more defensively and offensively today than he has wearing our jumper. Was it just because he was taking their second/ third best (18yr old) defender though. I wonder...?

[yandb]

Edwards is a flat track bully good against the lower teams but goes missing against quality sides Mcgaune offers more against these sides but is not the long term answer.

[Yeahright]

Lukas IMO.

HSHAHA


Edited see above

[WA Tiger]

Edwards looks fitter than McGuane, he is certainly stronger. IMO we should see how Edwards goes against the Dons, if he performs keep him in for the first week of the finals, if not..McGuane.

[Coach]

Edwards looks fitter than McGuane, he is certainly stronger. IMO we should see how Edwards goes against the Dons, if he performs keep him in for the first week of the finals, if not..McGuane.

No...just no. If Edwards is fitter & stronger then McG should never play another game for Richmond. We already know Aaron is a superior footballer but if he is fitter and stronger then whoa He's our man as 3rd tall. If not him then definitely not McG. If not Edwards.....Richo for one last game.

[WA Tiger]

Edwards looks fitter than McGuane, he is certainly stronger. IMO we should see how Edwards goes against the Dons, if he performs keep him in for the first week of the finals, if not..McGuane.

No...just no. If Edwards is fitter & stronger then McG should never play another game for Richmond. We already know Aaron is a superior footballer but if he is fitter and stronger then whoa He's our man as 3rd tall. If not him then definitely not McG. If not Edwards.....Richo for one last game.

Go and watch the last few replays of McGuane and Edwards comparatively, running out games or chasing....have a look at the difference, also have a look at the one on one's..

[Coach]

WGAF?

[WilliamPowell]

I would have though a bit hard to guage based on yesterday

Edwards was playing on a skinny kid, was always going to not only look bigger & stronger but actually be bigger and stronger

He will play next week against the "Followers of Ego" who are a bigger, stronger side than the kids that are Giants. Let's see how he goes against them

[WA Tiger]

Just saying Coach, if you don't GAF, don't comment then, was just saying that's all.

All I have noticed in the past he can hold himself better one on one, not just in yesterdays game but the ones he has played in previously and he runs games out better where McGuane looks spent.

[wayne]

Unfortunately, Edwards and McGuane may have stalled the development of Griff and Elton.

I don't think they have. If you're struggling at VFL level, you'll have no hope at senior level.

Riewoldt was kicking plenty of goals and performing well in the VFL before he got a call up. McBean is also doing well and probably would have played yesterday if he was fit.

Elton and Griffiths haven't shown much at all so far.

[Coach]

Just saying Coach, if you don't GAF, don't comment then, was just saying that's all.

All I have noticed in the past he can hold himself better one on one, not just in yesterdays game but the ones he has played in previously and he runs games out better where McGuane looks spent.

Please don't tell me how to post, guy.

[WA Tiger]

Just saying Coach, if you don't GAF, don't comment then, was just saying that's all.

All I have noticed in the past he can hold himself better one on one, not just in yesterdays game but the ones he has played in previously and he runs games out better where McGuane looks spent.

Please don't tell me how to post, guy.

Was not telling you how to post, was suggesting you don't bother posting..

[Coach]

if you don't GAF, don't comment then

Suggesting? I think not papa