Richmond vs Collingwood @ MCG Round 4

[Diocletian]

I reckon grigg is probably safe on the basis we lack outside runners, and possibly king.

But eff me if Newman and Pettard get a game against Collingwood ill know for sure Hardwick is going to coach our club into the ground.

Houli could easily play Grigg's role IMO.  Houli can at least kick and will at least attempt to tackle and contest when he has to. Can't afford both of them in the side.

[The Machine]

Would enjoy watching this line up next week:

B: Morris Astbury Batchelor
HB: Deledio Grimes McDonough
C: Ellis Martin Vlastuin
R: Hampson Thomas Cotchin
HF: Arnot Elton Gordon
F: Lloyd Riewoldt Griffiths

INT: Conca Jackson Helbig Lennon (S)

Make the outs earn the right to wear the jumper by finding hunger in the seconds

[🏅Dooks]

McDonough and Helbig are rubbish so is Batch

[Judge Roughneck]

McDonuts is a second year player...  To me, he seems like he can play.

Helbig may indeed be rubbish but has never been given a sustained go ala even a quarter of the opportunity of a houli/Grigg/petard/... At least he likes fighting and is tough. And can kick

Bach is ok.imo.

[Willy]

Helbig can't kick bro. His skills are poo.
Donuts can. Play Donuts in Houli's role. He will flourish with time.
Push Houli to the wing and Grigg to the twos.

[Jackstar is back!!!]

Reckon that Conca will be lucky to play
One good run in the last quarter might not get him a game next week

[Phil Mrakov]

McDonough is rubbish

Shows how much you know

[WA Tiger]

HOLD THE PRESS.......We might have the slimmest of chances in this game.

The Pies may have one reported and three of their best will be playing on one leg if they play at all....

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/collingwood-counting-cost-of-cats-loss-with-several-players-in-doubt-for-round-4/story-fni5f6hd-1226876070135

[Golfprotiger]

HOLD THE PRESS.......We might have the slimmest of chances in this game.

The Pies may have one reported and three of their best will be playing on one leg if they play at all....

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/collingwood-counting-cost-of-cats-loss-with-several-players-in-doubt-for-round-4/story-fni5f6hd-1226876070135

Still rather play them at full strength...

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Cloke will kick 7 instead of 10.

[Eat_em_Alive]

All four of those players could miss and they'd still find a way to win.. its called pride

[Stripes]

The Pies will find a way. Their midfield will dominate ours. For whatever the reason our midfield has dropped away this year. Thomas is not the answer imo. I hope Lids plays because Flossy is unlikely to do so. We seem to have too many experienced players who are under-done or lacking form. Our structures and game plan is not working atm.

[tony_montana]

HOLD THE PRESS.......We might have the slimmest of chances in this game.

The Pies may have one reported and three of their best will be playing on one leg if they play at all....

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/collingwood-counting-cost-of-cats-loss-with-several-players-in-doubt-for-round-4/story-fni5f6hd-1226876070135

They'll kill us even if they play on one leg, like Judd in the elim final

[Andyy]

IMO: Cloke will kick a bootload. Lids will be tagged out if he plays. Jack will be nowhere in sight. And we'll get overrun all through the middle.

[Lozza]

Watching the bombers dismantle the scum tonight gave me a horrible thought of what the pies will do to us on Friday, the scum just had no answer to the hard running bombers and its pains me to say it but in a nutshell we just don't and won't run that hard so we might be chasing alot of tail.