Jack Dyer Medal night / 2014 B&F - Winner: Trent Cotchin

[mightytiges]

6. Chaplin
7. Rance

Wtf

 

Yep, even though Rance missed about 7 games it still doesn't make sense as Chaplin was rubbish in the first half of the season. If Astbury hadn't done his kneecap, Chaplin most likely would've been dropped.

[Diocletian]

Chaplin was never going to be dropped.

[one-eyed]

Here's the full leaderboard:

[tigs2011]

6. Chaplin
7. Rance

Wtf

 

Yep, even though Rance missed about 7 games it still doesn't make sense as Chaplin was rubbish in the first half of the season. If Astbury hadn't done his kneecap, Chaplin most likely would've been dropped.

Rance came second in votes per game and Chappy 11th. Seems about right. If you play every game you are going to poll well no matter how poo you play. 

[one-eyed]

Here's the full leaderboard:

Other award winners

Bill Cosgrove Harry Jenkins Best First Year Player Award - Anthony Miles

Most Improved Player Award - Ben Griffiths

Michael Roach Leading Goal Kicker Award - Jack Riewoldt

Francis Bourke Award - Alex Rance

Best Offensive Player Award - Dustin Martin

Best Defensive Player Award - Alex Rance

Mr David Mandie AO OBE Community Award - Jake King

ME Bank Fairest & Best Award - Dustin Martin

Guinane Medal (VFL Best and Fairest) – Ross Young

http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2014-09-30/cotchins-jack-dyer-medal-treble

[one-eyed]

JDM Votes per Match

Miles          13.69
Rance        12.78
Cotchin      12.70
Maric         12.43
Ellis           12.30
Deledio      12.11
Martin       12.09
Astbury     11.38
S.Edwards 11.22
Riewoldt    11.00

Chaplin     10.35
Stephenson 10.00 (1 game)
Houli          9.91
Grimes        9.68
Newman     9.67
Batchelor    9.62
Foley         9.56
Morris        9.38
Thomas      9.31
Grigg         9.27

Petterd      8.88
Griffiths     8.56
Vickery      8.42
Gordon      8.33
Lloyd         8.25
Vlastuin     8.00
Dea           7.86
Hampson    7.55
Conca       7.53
Jackson     7.40

Arnot         7.25
A.Edwards  6.67
McDonough 6.14
Lennon       5.14
O'Hanlon     4.00
King           3.00

[WilliamPowell]

congrats to cotch

no disrespect intended but I reckon dusty has  been jibbed on 2 b&f's in a row

 Yep was the feeling of a lot of folks in the room. Missing the rd 22 game cost him the JD medal IMHO

Actually the thing that really staggered me is the amount of votes blokes got for the Elim Final, couldn't believe anyone got more than 10 votes that game 

[YellowandBlackBlood]

congrats to cotch

no disrespect intended but I reckon dusty has  been jibbed on 2 b&f's in a row

 Yep was the feeling of a lot of folks in the room. Missing the rd 22 game cost him the JD medal IMHO

Actually the thing that really staggered me is the amount of votes blokes got for the Elim Final, couldn't believe anyone got more than 10 votes that game 

Cotch seemed surprised he won. Good night though with a packed Crown Palladium. Auction items were a little disappointing IMHO. WAGS were easy on the eye!

[wayne]

Chaplin must have really satisfied the Fairest part of the award, because he would have barely got a vote for Best.

[WilliamPowell]

Cotch seemed surprised he won. Good night though with a packed Crown Palladium. Auction items were a little disappointing IMHO. WAGS were easy on the eye!

The Auctioneer was shocking, pathetic actually and agree with the items. Silent auction wasn't much better. Hate it when they put reserves (min bids) on these things, not the night for it IMHO should be about folks getting a bargain

Was an OK night I thought, not sure why Sandy seemed to need to yell into the mic, was so bloody loud 

[eliminator]

How on earth did Chaplin finish above Deledio. Brett's second half of the season was outstanding in particular he was outstanding against Sydney, West Coast and Adelaide. Makes no sense at all. Feel for Dusty believe he should have won it but Cotch is  a worthy winner and I mean no disrespect to him.

[Chuck17]

Chaplin must have really satisfied the Fairest part of the award, because he would have barely got a vote for Best.

As in fairly ordinary

[the claw]

theres 6 players who made top 10 and it explains why we are a middling side.

shame miles didnt play all yr he would have romped it in.

[MintOnLamb]

theres 6 players who made top 10 and it explains why we are a middling side.

shame miles didnt play all yr he would have romped it in.

'fo shoa

[Judge Roughneck]

Lol hardwick / Chaplin