Demon Jack Trengove could be traded to Richmond (Herald-Sun)

[Mr Magic]

Phew.

[WilliamPowell]

In the words of dimma

Our best players will just have to play better

 

 

Pay that Bents

[Francois Jackson]

Hold a minute

poor kid and to you roosy for trying to pool the wool over our eyes.

To the RFC well done for doing their due dilligence.

"Trying to pull the wool", 

Hello news flash we approached Melb, we instigated discussions not the other way around

So please don't accuse the MFC of trying to pull some sort of shifty here.

Both clubs followed due process, the kid failed the medical we've done the right thing (and yes kudos to our medical folks), the Dees have done the right thing time to move on.

Actual feel for the kid, obviously he isn't one of the lucky ones who gets over the navicular in a straight forward fashion. Thank goodness that it flared up again now and not in 3-4 months time after the deal was done.

Would think Conca stays now too 

please

stuff roosy and the dees. Never once heard the dees were wanting to keep him like GWS with Boyd.

They knew he is finished and tried to shaft us.

Wake up WP

[Mr Magic]

Blessing is that the foot didn't blow again in 6 months time.

Achillies & navicular injuries are notoriously difficult. Best steer clear.

[WilliamPowell]

They knew he is finished and tried to shaft us.

I don't need to wake up, facts we approached them. That isn't in dispute

They saw a player as expendable and a way to get another first round draft pick. just like we supposedly see Conca.

It hasn't happened, isn't going to happen so who cares

Our club has done their due diligence and found it's not worth proceeding. If you want to spend all your energy concocting conspiracy theories that's your choice but what's the point really?

Unlike you who thought the deal was worth the risk, I was always weary of this deal, navicular injuries are nasty. That fact he was running last week OK and it's flared again now proves it. No guarantees with navicular injuries

As I said its a relief it happened now and not in3-4 months after the deal was done. Because if he had passed the medical the deal would have been done today. And if it flared in 3 months you would be one of the first one here jumping up and down bagging the club about how they had stuffed up again.

We haven't lost anything, we sit where we were this time last week

As I said time to move on

[The Big Richo]

Not one drop of credit should got to anyone at Richmond here.

Staggering incompetence to be evening considering getting him.

[Judge Roughneck]

How is la la land going wp?

Still raining fairyfloss?

[one-eyed]

Jack Trengove stays a Demon after failing medical with Tigers

Peter Ryan 
afl.com.au
October 14, 2014 10:06 AM


THE PROPOSED deal that would have sent Melbourne's Jack Trengove to Richmond has been aborted after he failed a medical examination on Monday.
 
The 23-year-old former skipper's injured foot has not healed as hoped and he faces more rehabilitation with the Demons in the final year of his contract.
 
It is shattering news for the on-baller who was hoping to get a fresh start with the Tigers.
 
The Demons were going to trade him for pick No.12 and give Richmond pick No.23 in return.
 
Trengove played just two games last season after a crack was found in his navicular bone.
 
He has played 81 games with the Demons but has not been able to match the superb form he displayed in his first two seasons.

Melbourne football manager Josh Mahoney said the news that Trengove's navicular fracture had not healed as hoped was shattering.
 
"Jack had been progressing well from his navicular injury from earlier in 2014 with a CT scan eight weeks ago showing significant healing and was given the all-clear from the surgeon to progress to the next phase of his program," Mahoney told melbournefc.com.au.
 
"Jack then gradually increased his loading which included a period of time on the de-load treadmill before two weeks of running outside.

"Unfortunately, Jack experienced some pain in the associated areas around his navicular whilst running. This was considered normal after not running for six months, however further scans on Monday have unfortunately shown further damage to his navicular."
 
Melbourne intends to consult the surgeon for further advice about the treatment of Trengove's injury.

Richmond also released a statement, confirming the club would not pursue its plans to recruit Trengove.

“After doing our due diligence, including discussions with our medical staff, we have decided not to pursue further discussions," said Richmond’s general manager of football, Dan Richardson.

"We wish Jack all the best for his future career.”

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-10-14/trengove-stays-a-dee

[Judge Roughneck]

Which way is the knackery?

Take Chaplin with u jack

[dwaino]

But I already put his number on my guernsey.

[YellowandBlackBlood]

But I already put his number on my guernsey.

That's Cotch's number anyway dwaino so you're ok mate!

[dwaino]

But I already put his number on my guernsey.

That's Cotch's number anyway dwaino so you're ok mate!

Bieber would have had to give up his number. I'll just have to flip it upside for our prestigious number 6 

[one-eyed]

Jack Trengove has posted this message on facebook ...

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=366420220198879

[Francois Jackson]

They knew he is finished and tried to shaft us.

I don't need to wake up, facts we approached them. That isn't in dispute

They saw a player as expendable and a way to get another first round draft pick. just like we supposedly see Conca.

It hasn't happened, isn't going to happen so who cares

Our club has done their due diligence and found it's not worth proceeding. If you want to spend all your energy concocting conspiracy theories that's your choice but what's the point really?

Unlike you who thought the deal was worth the risk, I was always weary of this deal, navicular injuries are nasty. That fact he was running last week OK and it's flared again now proves it. No guarantees with navicular injuries

As I said its a relief it happened now and not in3-4 months after the deal was done. Because if he had passed the medical the deal would have been done today. And if it flared in 3 months you would be one of the first one here jumping up and down bagging the club about how they had stuffed up again.

We haven't lost anything, we sit where we were this time last week

As I said time to move on

 WP your right about one thing who cares its done but roosy that shark tried to pull one over us, that cant be disputed. even this piece below suggested they had concerns after he begin running which of course they say was "normal"

I applaud the club for doing their homework. The only issue i have is they may have thrown all their eggs in the trengrove basket

Jack had been progressing well from his navicular injury from earlier in 2014 with a CT scan eight weeks ago showing significant healing and was given the all-clear from the surgeon to progress to the next phase of his program," Mahoney told melbournefc.com.au.
 
"Jack then gradually increased his loading which included a period of time on the de-load treadmill before two weeks of running outside.

"Unfortunately, Jack experienced some pain in the associated areas around his navicular whilst running. This was considered normal after not running for six months, however further scans on Monday have unfortunately shown further damage to his navicular."

[one-eyed]

Jon Ralph on SEN - Trengove passed two medicals (CT scans) on Friday but Richmond did another type of scan on Monday and it showed his foot injury had flared up again (most likely as a result of not standing up to the initial medical tests).

If true, you can't knock our thoroughness in testing out the injury.