Richo vs Kouta - who comes out on top? ...... (afl site)

[one-eyed]

Versus: Richardson v Koutoufides

VIDEO: http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-04-15/versus-richo-v-kouta

Who comes out on top?



Vote here: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-04-15/versus-richo-v-kouta

Richo leading 56% - 44%

[lamington]

Richo by a country mile

[Phil Mrakov]

Kouta shouldn't have even been in the HOF. Was never good enough for long enough

[No More]

Kouta shouldn't have even been in the HOF. Was never good enough for long enough

We all hate Carlton but that's rubbish. I also have to say that for a period of about 2 years Kouta played football like I have never seen it played before and he was a highly skilled player for a long time before he was cruelled by injury, he was clearly the best player in the league over that period of 2 years that I talked about and even Judd at his best didn't play to that standard that Kouta reached. Having said that Richo was a star for more than a decade so its RICHO for mine.

[Phil Mrakov]

Kouta shouldn't have even been in the HOF. Was never good enough for long enough

We all hate Carlton but that's rubbish. I also have to say that for a period of about 2 years Kouta played football like I have never seen it played before and he was a highly skilled player for a long time before he was cruelled by injury, he was clearly the best player in the league over that period of 2 years that I talked about and even Judd at his best didn't play to that standard that Kouta reached.

[Diocletian]

he was clearly the best player in the league over that period of 2 years that I talked about and even Judd at his best didn't play to that standard that Kouta reached.

More like for about half a season in 2000.

[tony_montana]

Kouta's always said richo is the best player he's ever matched up on

[Golfprotiger]

Richo Man..........

[bojangles17]

Richo had 17 good years , Kouta , about 3,,,,, nuff said 

[No More]

he was clearly the best player in the league over that period of 2 years that I talked about and even Judd at his best didn't play to that standard that Kouta reached.

More like for about half a season in 2000.

Richo was outright robbed by the footscray hack for the brownlow, Richo performed better over a much longer period, but there was a 2 year period where the greek was just outstanding and he too was robbed of a brownlow IMHO.

[bojangles17]

You re prob right it was 2 good years rather than three

[Diocletian]

he was clearly the best player in the league over that period of 2 years that I talked about and even Judd at his best didn't play to that standard that Kouta reached.

More like for about half a season in 2000.

Richo was outright robbed by the footscray hack for the brownlow, Richo performed better over a much longer period, but there was a 2 year period where the greek was just outstanding and he too was robbed of a brownlow IMHO.

I agree - but the  peak of that period were he was, as you say, even better than Judd at his best, was only for about 3 months/half a season..and there was probably an absolute peak period of about 6-8 weeks within that again where he was nearly up there with Carey, Matthews & the Abletts. Remember it well because I was starting to get seriously peeed off that Carlton had such a player.