Our problem IMO is that we cant keep up with the trend of the game.
The years we went bigger, taller players the comp went smaller speedier players, now we nave gone smaller speedier (sort of) players the comp has gone to bigger bodied fast players. Look at the Crows and Sydney players on the weekend, same with the Lions and the GCS, GWS, Hawks, Freo and more, they all have 6ft players that are big and quick.
We have Jack and Vickery, who have slimmed right down and maybe Rance.....
We always seem to be a year out of the trend..