Seen enough of Shai
Don’t want to see anymore
Don’t think the kid actually gets the concept of team sport
No doubt has the ability to win the ball but his finishing off is questionable
Come off it. The guy was the youngest on the list till this year's intake. The fact he can win the ball is important. He has played about 10 games and you've seen enough? One thing he isn't is a small forward. Put him on a wing and let him run through the centre just as he did as a junior and in his best games in the VFL and you'll see a vastly different player. To do that at AFL level he needs to build his tank and be a Brad Hill type. On that point he has a long way to go, but in terms of talent he has more than many of the plodders on our list.
Brad Hill type??
Brad Hill has elite speed and endurance, Shai has neither of those things. In fact other than taking the occasional screamer, he really doesn’t have much AFL qualities IMO.
The thing I see most from a small sample size is he doesn’t work hard enough. That can obviously change but realistically it shouldn’t have to as he has had 2 years to work that out.
I’d trade him if we could get a pick under 30.
Draft genuine, good sized midfielders, no more Menadue, Bolton, Drummond types.
