He plays one ok game in 4 years and everyone forgets how poo he is. He was dragged multiple times in the VFL last season for soft pathetic efforts. Expect that to continue
He was picked to play last night and he performed pretty well.
Not sure what else you want, he can’t go back and change how he has played in the past.
If you’re going to criticise him when he plays poor, you can acknowledge when he has an ok game.
Keeps his spot based on that. If he’s crap next week he can be criticised and dropped then.