Each club's list rated, for the short and long termChris Doerre
ESPN
21 February 2020We're only weeks away from the start of the 2020 AFL season, but which club's list is best placed for short and long-term success?
ESPN's draft expert Chris Dorre assesses the strengths and weaknesses of every squad, for the immediate future and down the track.
Note - only players born in 1994 or later were considered in the following long-term outlooks. The 'core pieces' are those viewed as players a club can build around with confidence, and are projected to become top-10-on-list quality players on the average team.
RichmondShort-term outlookStrength: Even with the unexpected retirement of Alex Rance, Richmond's defence remains arguably the strongest in the competition. They have no shortage of quality tall defenders with Dylan Grimes, David Astbury and an emerging Noah Balta, who if developed in defence, can be a third difference-making tall. Richmond's tall defenders are well complimented by Bachar Houli, Nick Vlastuin and Jayden Short while Sydney Stack should become a fixture in Richmond's best side.
Weakness: Where Richmond have classically been weak is through the midfield. Over the years, Dustin Martin, Trent Cotchin, Shane Edwards and Dion Prestia have relatively lacked support. The emergence of Marlion Pickett, who should be a regular, and the development of Jack Graham and Jack Ross can see Richmond's midfield improve in 2020.
Projection: Richmond is the competition's dominant side and, on paper, is getting stronger.
Long-term outlook
Core pieces: Sydney Stack, Noah Balta, Dion Prestia, Nick Vlastuin, Toby Nankervis and Daniel Rioli.
Strengths: As often happens with the great teams, Richmond's youth develops rapidly, and the Tigers are likely to continue to see that over the next few seasons. Richmond's ruck division appears set with a number of young players able to perform through there.
Weaknesses: What Richmond are missing is young star power across the field. While Richmond are developing their talent effectively, their stars are their veterans.
https://www.espn.com.au/afl/story/_/id/28732045/afl-club-list-rated-short-long-term