Author Topic: 2024 AFL draft  (Read 57466 times)

Offline MaccaDacca

  • Jack Dyer medallist
  • ***
  • Posts: 141
  • For We're From Tigerland
Re: 2024 AFL draft
« Reply #810 on: Yesterday at 10:49:09 AM »
I feel like there are only 2 scenario's where trading up to pick 2 make sense.

1 - If we are wanting BOTH Lalor and FOS because neither would get past Carlton at pick 3 you'd think.

2 - If we want to get Harry Armstrong before Melbourne's pick 5.

Otherwise it just feels like a waste of the extra draft pick we'd need to sacrifice.

Oh and no way i'd include pick 6 in that scenario anyway.

Offline Tiger Khosh

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 4410
  • For We're From Tigerland
Re: 2024 AFL draft
« Reply #811 on: Yesterday at 01:00:35 PM »
Why the stuff would we trade pick 24 to a top club for a future first which essentially is the same pick in a standard draft. Give me a break.

Trade with north is what I'm hoping. Give them pick 11 or 18. For 2 and next yrs 1st.

What has happened to this deal as it appears it's gone cold according these so called experts

I don’t know how much merit it had to begin with because it seemed too good to be true for us.

Regardless of whether it’s in the works or not, I don’t think clubs can officially trade picks until draft night now as the deadline passed 1-2 weeks ago. Another home run idea by AFL HQ to add to the excitement of draft night  ::)

Online Andyy

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 9940
Re: 2024 AFL draft
« Reply #812 on: Yesterday at 02:41:16 PM »
Why the stuff would we trade pick 24 to a top club for a future first which essentially is the same pick in a standard draft. Give me a break.

Trade with north is what I'm hoping. Give them pick 11 or 18. For 2 and next yrs 1st.

What has happened to this deal as it appears it's gone cold according these so called experts

I don’t know how much merit it had to begin with because it seemed too good to be true for us.

Regardless of whether it’s in the works or not, I don’t think clubs can officially trade picks until draft night now as the deadline passed 1-2 weeks ago. Another home run idea by AFL HQ to add to the excitement of draft night  ::)

Or clubs have agreed/lodged pick trades and the AFL is making them wait until draft night to add to the spectacle lol

Offline Diocletian

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 19395
  • RWNJ / Leftist Snowflake - depends who you ask....
Re: 2024 AFL draft
« Reply #813 on: Yesterday at 04:12:50 PM »
The draft is all scripted like "reality" tv. Fmd clubs apparently need an entire week to sort out trades then all of a sudden they can do pick swaps on the spot within 5 minutes? :shh
"Much of the social history of the Western world, over the past three decades, has been a history of replacing what worked with what sounded good...."

- Thomas Sowell


FJ is the only one that makes sense.

Offline one-eyed

  • Administrator
  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 98034
    • One-Eyed Richmond
Re: 2024 AFL draft
« Reply #814 on: Yesterday at 11:21:04 PM »
AFL Draft 2024: ESPN's final, top 50 Power Rankings for November

Full article & profiles: https://www.espn.com.au/afl/story/_/id/42038414/afl-draft-power-rankings-november-2024-extended-top-50-prospects-bolters-sliders

1. Jagga Smith (October rank: 1)
2. Sid Draper (2)
3. Levi Ashcroft (3) - Brisbane father-son
4. Sam Lalor (6) - The yellow and black No. 4 guernsey will soon have a new owner at Punt Road.
5. Finn O'Sullivan (4)
6. Leo Lombard (5) - Gold Coast Academy
7. Tobie Travaglia (9)
8. Xavier Lindsay (7)
9. Alix Tauru (13)
10. Josh Smillie (8 )
11. Harvey Langford (10)
12. Isaac Kako (12) - Essendon NGA
13. Harry Armstrong (11)
14. Joe Berry (14)
15. Bo Allan (15)
16. Taj Hotton (19)
17. Jobe Shanahan (17)
18. Murphy Reid (18)
19. Luke Trainor (16)
20. Oli Hannaford (20)
21. Kayle Gerreyn (21)
22. Cooper Hynes (25)
23. Jack Whitlock (22)
24. Sam Marshall (24) - Brisbane Academy
25. Jesse Dattoli (27)
26. Hamish Davis (26)
27. James Barrat (29)
28. Alex Dodson (23)
29. Noah Mraz
30. Jonty Faull
31. Matt Whitlock
32. Harrison Oliver
33. Christian Moraes
34. Archer Day-Wicks
35. Ben Camporeale - Carlton father-son
36. Harry O'Farrell
37. Hugh Boxshall
38. Malakai Champion - West Coast NGA
39. Jack Ough
40. Luke Urquhart
41. Jasper Alger
42. Angus Clarke
43. Adrian Cole - St Kilda NGA
44. Josh Murphy
45. Tom Gross
46. Riley Bice
47. Tom Sims
48. Cody Anderson - Hawthorn NGA
49. Jayden Nguyen - Essendon NGA
50. Sam Davidson



Offline one-eyed

  • Administrator
  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 98034
    • One-Eyed Richmond
Re: 2024 AFL draft
« Reply #815 on: Yesterday at 11:41:18 PM »

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kf3lmLuKyzE

-----------------------------------------

2024 AFL Mock Draft: Picks 1-27 (second edition)

Mitch Keating
zerohang.com
November 15, 2024


1. Richmond: Sam Lalor
Lalor's 1st Mock Draft Selection: North Melbourne (Pick 3)
Richmond 1st Mock Draft Selection: Finn O'Sullivan

Position: Midfielder-Forward
Height: 188cm
State: Victoria
Club: Bacchus Marsh

After taking Oakleigh Chargers midfielder Finn O'Sullivan in our first Mock Draft, the Tigers set their sights on GWV Rebels bull Sam Lalor at Pick 1 in this exercise, with the Vic Country livewire another name heavily tied to Richmond's opening selection.

Having earned a likeness to high-impact onballers Christian Petracca and Jordan De Goey, Lalor's ceiling could place him on a path to succeed retired Tigers champion Dustin Martin, given his strength and explosiveness at the contest.

Lalor endured an injury-hit draft year but might just have the best upside of any talent near the top of this year's crop.

2. Richmond (Traded from North Melbourne): Finn O'Sullivan
O'Sullivan's 1st Mock Draft Selection: Richmond (Pick 1)

Position: Midfielder
Height: 182cm
State: Victoria
Club: Koroit

Talks of a trade between the Tigers and Kangaroos have been flirted with in recent weeks, with Richmond seemingly the only club capable of managing a deal for North Melbourne's opening pick, given their suite of selections.

A trade for Pick 2 would have to include Pick 6 heading to Arden Street, with another first-round pick also departing the Tigers. In this exercise, we see Pick 18 packaged with Pick 6 from Richmond for North Melbourne's Pick 2. The two clubs could dip into future selections and potentially upgrade 2025 selections to further satisfy the deal, but the three mentioned picks are the only ones that will impact this Mock Draft.

The move itself would see Richmond again add O'Sullivan early into the count, with the Tigers likely to be weighing up the Vic Country star and his teammate Lalor atop the draft board. Given the potential 50-50 call, they decide on moving for Pick 2 and going home with both young guns.

The two would complement each other nicely, with O'Sullivan a pure all-round midfielder who damages defences with his disposal.


3. Bris - Levi Ashcroft (bid)
4. Carl - Sid Draper
5. Adel - Harvey Langford
6. Melb - Jagga Smith
7. North - Alix Tauru
8. StK - Josh Smillie
9. GC - Leo Lombard (bid)
10. StK - Tobie Travaglia
11. Melb - Harry Armstrong
12. Ess - Isaac Kako (bid)

13. Richmond: Murphy Reid
Reid's 1st Mock Draft Selection: Richmond (Pick 7)
Richmond's 1st Mock Draft Selection: Tobie Travaglia

Position: Midfielder
Height: 181cm
State: Victoria
Club: South Melbourne Districts

The first big slider when comparing our first two Mock Drafts, with Richmond still securing Reid but doing so six picks later.

It'd be a great steal for the Tigers, given they traded Pick 6 in this exercise and still managed to sign Reid, who would join the already-selected Lalor and O'Sullivan to help headline the new era of midfielders at Punt Road.

Reid packs a punch as a forward half-threat who is equally damaging at the coalface, complementing the attributes that are brought by Lalor and O'Sullivan.

14. Richmond: Bo Allan
Allan's 1st Mock Draft Selection: West Coast (Pick 15)
Richmond's 1st Mock Draft Selection: Alix Tauru

Position: Midfielder-Defender
Height: 191cm
State: Western Australia
Club: Halls Head

Again, selecting the best available prospect when on the clock, this selection sees Richmond add to their midfield options for a fourth time with the view of utilising Allan as a defensive asset rather than an onballer to start his career.

The Peel Thunder premiership player can slot into a third tall backman spot in Adem Yze's rearguard while offering some inside-outside versatility through the middle of the field if needed.

The Western Australian skipper would be of great desire to the Tigers, who secure one of the more ready-made teenagers from this year's crop.


15. Dogs - Xavier Lindsay
16. Port - Luke Trainor
17. Freo - Joe Berry
18. GWS - Jobe Shanahan
19. GWS - Taj Hotton
20. Bris - Sam Marshall (bid)
21. Dogs - Cooper Hynes
22. North - Jonty Faull
23. Syd - Hamish Davis

24. Richmond: Jack Whitlock
Whitlock's 1st Mock Draft Selection: GWS (Pick 25)
Richmond's 1st Mock Draft Selection: Jonty Faull

Position: Key Forward
Height: 200cm
State: Victoria
Club: Shepparton

After trading their earlier selection, the Tigers will hope one of Whitlock or Jonty Faull - who was taken by the Kangaroos with the pick they acquired from Richmond in this exercise - will still be on the table.

The two-metre tall forward would fill a list need at Punt Road, with another key position attacker coming through the ranks sure to be a desire for Richmod's recruiters.

Whitlock is a mobile and high-leaping spearhead who would have plenty to learn from a player of Tom Lynch's stature, with the Tigers veteran also giving the draftee time to better his craft before earning a debut.


25. GWS - Harrison Oliver
26. Syd - Matt Whitlock

27. Richmond: Alex Dodson
Dodson's 1st Mock Draft Selection: Western Bulldogs (Pick 20)
Richmond's 1st Mock Draft Selection: James Barrat

Position: Ruck
Height: 201cm
State: South Australia
Club: Payneham

Dodson - viewed by most as the best ruckman on offer at this year's intake - slides seven spots and lands in the Tigers' lap to end the first round of the draft.

The South Australian has a wide draft range that positions him as a prospect who could be taken midway through the first round or early into the second, with Richmond a potential buyer with one of their earlier picks.

Given Toby Nankervis' reign at Richmond, Dodson would be afforded the needed time to add size and develop his craft before taking over the mantle in Adem Yze's ruck ranks.

https://www.zerohanger.com/2024-afl-mock-draft-picks-1-27-second-edition-156711/27/

Offline one-eyed

  • Administrator
  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 98034
    • One-Eyed Richmond
Re: 2024 AFL draft
« Reply #816 on: Yesterday at 11:47:55 PM »

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ch-k0BXhV6o&t=1144s

1,6 - Two of Lalor, FOS, Smith.

10 - One of Reid, Smillie, Langford
11 - Hotton

18, 20 - KPP - Jack Whitlock and/or a slider if Trainor

23, 24 - Cooper Hynes if we only take Lalor as a bigger body earlier.
             Dattoli, Hannaford if we already have taken both Lalor and Smillie.
             Faull.

Offline one-eyed

  • Administrator
  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 98034
    • One-Eyed Richmond
Re: 2024 AFL draft
« Reply #817 on: Yesterday at 11:49:12 PM »
A mix of two of the game's most damaging players, that's how top 5 draft hopeful Sam Lalor describes his style of play. The 18-year-old is just one of footy's next generation preparing to take the AFL by storm.


https://x.com/7NewsMelbourne/status/1856608956334157868

Offline one-eyed

  • Administrator
  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 98034
    • One-Eyed Richmond
Re: 2024 AFL draft
« Reply #818 on: Yesterday at 11:50:31 PM »
“I think Jagga is Trent Cotchin”: Why potential No.1 would be a clever Richmond pick

By Andrew Slevison
SEN
14 Nov 2024




Jagga Smith possesses similar traits to Richmond great Trent Cotchin and would be a clever draft selection by the Tigers.

That is the opinion of the Vic Metro coach who sees a likeness between Oakleigh Chargers midfielder Smith and three-time premiership captain Cotchin who was Pick 2 or the Tigers back in 2007.

While Sandringham coach Harding is adamant that Dragons star Levi Ashcroft should be Pick 1 and hopes the Tigers bid on him with the top selection, he does feel that Smith would be a worthy choice at the pointy end.

The Tigers, who have eight picks inside the first 24 (and six inside 20), have also been linked to the likes of Sam Lalor, Finn O’Sullivan and Harvey Langford as to who they could take with their first selection.

“Outside of Ashcroft, whether it’s Sam Lalor, whether it’s Jagga Smith, there are a number of players who could go Pick 1 in this draft,” Harding said on SEN’s Sportsday.

“We’re in an unusual case with Richmond where they’ve got six picks in the first 20. They’ll be looking to balance their picks.

“It’s a challenging and philosophical one for Richmond.”

Harding does see plenty of upside in GWV Rebels and Vic Country gun Lalor, who plays in a similar style to Tigers champion Dustin Martin, but wonders whether Richmond will opt for a player like Smith who will likely be durable and should be prolific.

“When you look at Sam Lalor, his physical size and attributes at 187-88cm as a powerful midfielder who has great ability to go forward, naturally there’s going to be the comparisons to ‘Dusty’ a little bit,” he added.

“But with the Richmond theme, I think Jagga is Trent Cotchin. I think that’s his path going forward.

“I’ve been fortunate enough to work with him over the last two years at Metro level and he was captain of our National Championship side this year. His leadership, his ability to train hard, to take feedback on board and to keep improving is first-class.

“I think Jagga’s volume of work makes him as close to a surefire pick as you’d like to see.

“There’s a couple of these guys at the top of the draft, Sam had injuries at the back end of the year with hamstrings, Finn O’Sullivan is a high-level talent who has battled injuries as well.

“They’re the risks that clubs have to take. When you’ve got multiple picks you might find that Richmond might take on that is more secure and one that is a little bit more speculative.”

Smith, who stands at 181cm, is a product of the Richmond Junior Football Club and attended Scotch College while paying for the Chargers and Vic Metro.

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2024/11/12/i-think-jagga-is-trent-cotchin-why-potential-no-1-would-be-a-clever-richmond