Author Topic: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players  (Read 17587 times)

Offline julzqld

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 3919
  • For We're From Tigerland
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #75 on: July 29, 2007, 08:52:38 AM »
Well Foley has shown us how valuable he is this year.  McGuane I'd keep for a while and maybe Howat.  Moore is gone as is Hall and Knobel.  Krak could be trade bait.  Not sure about the others.

Ramps

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #76 on: July 29, 2007, 10:04:14 AM »
the only player who will survive the cuts is foley...the rest are finished and in time Ill put up another list lol...

Ramps

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #77 on: July 29, 2007, 10:45:52 AM »
Ramps' New List of Non Richmond Premiership Players are in Bold- THE 2ND INSTALLMENT!

11. Joel Bowden - Hes a different player to brown at the same age. Doubt he'd be there.

12. Matthew Richardson (vet - outside) - Wont make it unfortunately becaue hell retire beforehand. Champion who deserved better!

13. Trent Knobel - NO

15. Kayne Pettifer - NO

16. Patrick Bowden - NO

17. Kane Johnson - NO

18. Kent Kingsley - NO

20. Ray Hall - NO

21. Shane Tuck - NO

23. Daniel Jackson - NO

24. Mark Coughlan - NO- Injuries will cruel him, he was lacking a yard before the knees, a Great
Bloke and a player who gave us hope when he started, Great Respect for him but I cant see it.

25. Jay Schulz - NO

27. Andrew Krakouer - NO

31. Chris Hyde - NO

32. Greg Tivendale - NO

33. Brent Hartigan - NO

35. Matthew White - NO - Hes a goer could be a squad player in a good side but I have doubts that in a premiership side a coach would pick him in the final 22.

38. Luke McGuane - NO - I cant see it, hopefully Im wrong, but we need a bigger full back in Time.

40. Kelvin Moore - NO

43. Cameron Howat - NO

There are some others who escaped who were borderline like Meyer and afew others as well- they have been given the benefit of the doubt


Moi

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #78 on: July 29, 2007, 10:50:46 AM »
Why did you give Meyer the benefit of doubt ahead of the others?

Ramps

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #79 on: July 29, 2007, 10:56:09 AM »
Meyer showed at Geelong last year that he can play off half back. Hes a good kick- which we dont have many of. For now he survived my cut because he can kick well. Tambling also survived my cut...believe me, both were very close to getting listed today. But ive stuck 20 blokes on a list, it just goes to show how badly weve managed our list that my list has run to 20 players 2 years in a row and people are wanting more people on it. in the end, its just an opinion. I hope all the players can turn it around, especially someone like Mark Coughlan- who as i said, i have alot of respect for.

Moi

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #80 on: July 29, 2007, 11:02:29 AM »
I hope Meyer can make it too, he has the skills.
Just his heart I worry about.

Glad you kept him there  :thumbsup

Passionfruit

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #81 on: July 29, 2007, 11:08:52 AM »
Ramps' New List of Non Richmond Premiership Players are in Bold- THE 2ND INSTALLMENT!

11. Joel Bowden - Hes a different player to brown at the same age. Doubt he'd be there.

12. Matthew Richardson (vet - outside) - Wont make it unfortunately becaue hell retire beforehand. Champion who deserved better!

13. Trent Knobel - NO

15. Kayne Pettifer - NO

16. Patrick Bowden - NO

17. Kane Johnson - NO

18. Kent Kingsley - NO

20. Ray Hall - NO

21. Shane Tuck - NO

23. Daniel Jackson - NO

24. Mark Coughlan - NO- Injuries will cruel him, he was lacking a yard before the knees, a Great
Bloke and a player who gave us hope when he started, Great Respect for him but I cant see it.

25. Jay Schulz - NO

27. Andrew Krakouer - NO

31. Chris Hyde - NO

32. Greg Tivendale - NO

33. Brent Hartigan - NO

35. Matthew White - NO - Hes a goer could be a squad player in a good side but I have doubts that in a premiership side a coach would pick him in the final 22.

38. Luke McGuane - NO - I cant see it, hopefully Im wrong, but we need a bigger full back in Time.

40. Kelvin Moore - NO

43. Cameron Howat - NO

There are some others who escaped who were borderline like Meyer and afew others as well- they have been given the benefit of the doubt




Very accurate assessment.

Ramps

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #82 on: July 29, 2007, 11:16:51 AM »
This list is just an ongoing opinion, I had Nathan Foley on this list 12 months ago he has proved to everyone he is a very very good footballer now- he plays hard tough footy with passion. Hopefully players realise that they have a brilliant opportunity to play for a great club with a great history and do a Foley. And if I could pick just 1 player from my list to prove me wrong... i hope Cogs comes back and kills em.

The disastrous state of our list is also shown because blokes like Collins and Petersen and those guys havent been seen and I refer back to the very first posts in this thread where i stated that i wouldnt sacrifice any kid without seeing enough first - and if they dont come on as we hope we are well and truly up ..... creek.

Tigermonk

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #83 on: July 29, 2007, 12:09:47 PM »
you could cut only 2 players from a team & introduce 2 new players & it can make 10 bad players everyone wants cut into a team of champions because the team plays different around the 2 newbies but cutting a list aggressively can cut your own throat & you can lose some good players

example Rodan was really going nowhere but put him into Ports side in a different role & game plan & he is showing good form but bring him back to Richmond next year he will turn to a sideways chip kicker who runs in circles cause we dont play direct football & got no gameplan after 1 kick out of defence

Moi

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #84 on: July 29, 2007, 12:35:47 PM »
Very accurate assessment.
This is where you have a bob each way.  The list is crap and one that Terry inherited, but everything is all his fault.
Can't work you out!

Passionfruit

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #85 on: July 29, 2007, 01:03:22 PM »
Very accurate assessment.
This is where you have a bob each way.  The list is crap and one that Terry inherited, but everything is all his fault.
Can't work you out!

Pretty easy to work out Moi.
Terry inherited an ordinary list.
In MY opinion he has recruited extremely poorly, you cant tell me that the recruits have been any good. Blind man freddy would of picked Deledio as No 1 ::)
JON, Myer, Tambling and hardly world beaters. throw in McGaune( cant keep his feet and falls over alot)
P. Bowden, T. Knobel ,K. Kingsley= Total waste of space.
And if anyone say that Knoble is injured , GUESS WHAT, he ws injured all the time with the Saints and struggled to get through a game.
Just maybe, the brains at punt road want to do a bit of homework on future players instead of organising the supplying of ''Tiger skins"" and Polo jackets for members ;) ;) ;)

The list has GOT WORSE
He has also "" fallen in love"" with players who arent up to it. E.g Jay Schultz and they go and offer him a new contract ::) Daniel Jackson,  Krakouer and dont forget Kelvin Moore everybody on here was talking about Kelvin Moore ::)   Kelvin Moore cannot play footy at AFL, do you actually watch ?

You say the list is crap and I agree, but it has steadily got worse over the past 3 years through terrible recruiting, if people cant see that, I dont know what to think,

Terrys game plan is a mess, the "" blind mice"" game plan was there AGAIN  for viewing last night.

I tell you what my fault is Moi ,and  i am one of many to blame, was voting for the CASEY ticket 3 years ago.

Ramps

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #86 on: October 22, 2007, 03:09:41 PM »
Bump  ;D

Offline tigersalive

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 2772
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #87 on: October 22, 2007, 03:16:30 PM »
Well I named 12 names in the list, 2 I know can play in Hughes and Oakley Nicholls- I know they can play because I followed sport as a kid watching both AFL and Soccer, and watching lots of junior games in both, and I know I dont need folders full of crap to tell me who can sort of play and who cant but anyway...Hughes and Oakley-Nicholls can play. Casserley, I havent seen much of and Im not gonna sacrifice any kid without giving a proper chance (I must be getting more sensible in my older age lol) So that means that 9 players already got listed as not being in Richmonds next Premiership side.

1) Moore, - Staying
2) Hartigan, - Gawn
3) Limbach, - Gawn
4) Humm, - Gawn
5) Roach, - Gawn
6) Rodan, - Gawn
7) Chaffey, - Gawn
8) Howat, - Staying.
9) McGuane, - Gawn

Stafford (Retirement) makes 10 - Gawn

Gaspar (Traded or Delisted or Retired) makes 11 - Gawn

Daniel Jackson (Where will he play, what position, what job role in the team- hasnt really improved in last 12 months) makes 12

Trent Knoble (tries hard, but do any of us believe he'll be there on a Grand Final Day for Richmond) makes 13 - Gawn

Nathan Foley (In and under, busts a gut, tries hard, a goer, but he isnt gonna be their either) makes 14 Staying  :shh

Andrew Krakouer (Not impacting, dont know where his headed, wont be there on a Grand Final Day makes 15 - Gawn

Greg Tivendale (Improved this year, Sell Sell Sell, stock price at its highest, 1 good year doesnt cover up 3 or 4 not so good ones makes 16 -  still here  ;D

Ray Hall makes 17- We wont win a Premiership with Ray. Tries hard. Good run, but wont be there on the big day. We need a Premiership CHB and FB. Ray at the moment isnt that and hes not a Ruckman.  - Gawn

drumroll....my shock selection

Shane Tuck (Hasnt gone on from last year, just treading water again. Effective enough though to keep his trade value decent. In stock market terms his PE is high now, so It may be time to cash out).  Staying.

So thats 18 players who for mine are not future Richmond premiership players.

EDIT: DONT MIND ME IM BLIND AND DIDNT SEE THE UPDATED.  :rollin
EAT EM ALIVE!

Ramps

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #88 on: October 22, 2007, 03:17:09 PM »
From the first list all those bolded now gone!


1) Moore,
2) Hartigan,
3) Limbach,
4) Humm,
5) Roach,
6) Rodan,
7) Chaffey,
8) Howat,
9) McGuane,
10) Stafford
11) Gaspar
12) Daniel Jackson
13) Trent Knoble
14) Nathan Foley
15) Andrew Krakouer
16) Greg Tivendale
17) Ray Hall
18) Shane Tuck

Most of the 2nd installment are gone as they appeared in the first list.



Ramps

  • Guest
Re: Ramps' not future Richmond premiership players
« Reply #89 on: October 22, 2007, 03:24:30 PM »
Still reckon Richo, Bowden and afew others wont get there because of age. Time will beat them.

JON Hughes Meyer and afew of the others better get a wriggle on shortly coz they may find themselves in Ramps installment No 3  ;D