IMHO the biggest problem with the A-League is the "product" itself, that is the game.
Again IMO the crowds are now reflecting that. The novelty has worn off
The way it is played by the majority of clubs in the A-League is BORING and I see that as it being its biggest weakness. It sends me to
I will give Melb Heart one thing - they actually seem to play an attractive style of soccer
The next biggest problem are the private owners. They don't appear to be involved for the betterment of the game, involved because they want a toy that makes them money
As for what we had before - I wasn't interested in the NSL at all. Apart from South Melb I couldn't name many more clubs. And the reason I wasnt interested was because unless you were a "fan" as such you wouldn't have known it was going on unless there were violence at games.
That is the one thing the A-League has going for it - people know about it because it's been promoted well. Doesn't mean people are interested it just means people know about it