What a stuffing mundane argument this is.
From my perspective a dud in footballing terms is a bloke with little ability that can't get much of a kick or is painfully soft.
Even at the local level there are seriously talented blokes that don't take their football serious enough but can play. I wouldn't call them duds, just blokes that don't give enough of a poo or are pumpkin heads. Ditto Connors, Stack, Marty McGrath etc
You blokes are of the opinion that you're a dud if you get delisted. That's your view, live and let live