Jay Schulz [merged]

[Mr Magic]

With Kingsley gawn, at 22 he's a better prospect than the crap we'd likely get in return through a trade.

Keep and hope he plays well next season.

[DallasCrane]

With Kingsley gawn, at 22 he's a better prospect than the crap we'd likely get in return through a trade.

Keep and hope he plays well next season.

Spot on Mr Magic

For Richmond to get better, Sarge has to get better.

[mightytiges]

Sarge will have Toovey or Cox on him on Sunday so he could have a day out if he works hard all the time and uses his size properly. When he's in the seniors he needs to see which was Richo leads and run to the opposite side.

[Mr Magic]

With Kingsley gawn, at 22 he's a better prospect than the crap we'd likely get in return through a trade.

Keep and hope he plays well next season.

Spot on Mr Magic

For Richmond to get better, Sarge has to get better.

I really hope we keep him.

He's 23 next year & whilst this season again was disappointing for him there's no point in scapegoating Jay for our ruined season. There are more pressing problems than him IMO. Healing our midfield woes & ruck division is the priority.
Richardson ain't getting any younger and it's likely more opportunities will present themselves next year. At this point I have seen nothing to suggest Riewoldt or Hughes are a better option.
In the final year of his contract. it's going to be a case of now for Schulz & whilst it defies logic, I think he can do it still despite how frustrating he is.

In saying that if a club looking for a KPF offered a second round selection for him I would take it.

[bluey_21]

sarge = frustrating 

keep for me, but only because of our lack of kpp

[mightytiges]

Credit where it's due. Sarge's efforts today over 4 quarters is what he needs to do every week if he does survive past trade week and is at Punt Rd next year. He also kicked the crunch goal on the siren before half-time to keep Coburg in the game.

[bluey_21]

was crap at the marking and goal-kicking game he was meant to play

but his work at ground level was fantastic

[Passionfruit]

send him home.

An absolute Dud!

[retygas]

Keeper for me. And hasn't the Crows experiment proven to be a bad thing look at Sugar, the biggest dud.

[tigersalive]

See if we can swap him for Ryan Murphy somehow.

Both of those boys need a chance of scenery imho.

[cub]

was crap at the marking and goal-kicking game he was meant to play

Yeah, but wasn't really the day for that type of play.
Riewoldt started first 5 mins ok then dissapeared, finished off ok with a bit of luck chucked in.

[bluey_21]

was crap at the marking and goal-kicking game he was meant to play

Yeah, but wasn't really the day for that type of play.
Riewoldt started first 5 mins ok then dissapeared, finished off ok with a bit of luck chucked in.

yeah in all honesty it was unbelievably windy. I remember one of the early kicks by a willy player was dragged way way left from its target

[Passionfruit]

send him home.

An absolute Dud!

I hope we all watched him today, has no idea

[julzqld]

Can't blame Richo for that.

[Gordon Bennett]

send him home.

An absolute Dud!

I hope we all watched him today, has no idea

Jack - You seem to take too much pleasure in running down people, whether they be players or coaches. That's how it appears to me, anyway.