Which of these players would get a game in any other AFL team's 22?

[Mr Magic]

Jackson
Hartigan
Moore
Tivendale
Hyde
Meyer
Hall
Gaspar
Tambling
Krakouer
Knobel

?

[Stephanie]

Jackson - Essendon
Hartigan - Carlton
Moore - Collingwood
Tivendale - Essendon
Hyde - Carlton
Meyer - Collingwood
Hall - Essendon
Gaspar - Carlton
Tambling - Collingwood
Krakouer - Essendon
Knobel - Carlton

 

[Hellenic Tiger]

Knowing Collingwood they would be licking their hands together with glee claiming it was 1982 all over again when Cloke and Raines defected. Most could end up there I can visualise the farce that is their press conference with theme New additions believe Pies will win the flag or Pies list even stronger now or Mick Malthouse says Collingwood once again alegitimate premiership threat.
Some of those names there have more than run their race at AFL Level.

[mightytiges]

Jackson
Hartigan
Moore
Tivendale
Hyde
Meyer
Hall
Gaspar
Tambling
Krakouer
Knobel

?

Most clubs would take Tambo as he's only 20. He would be in the best 22 of bottom 8 sides and would get the occasional game at a top club where he would be surrounded by a team full of A-grade players.

Both SA clubs would give Meyer a chance being an ex-South Aussie but he wouldn't be in their 22.

Tivs, Krak and Hyde would only get picked up cheap in the PSD as temporary back-up in case of injury.

Other clubs wouldn't go near the rest. 

[Hellenic Tiger]

Tivs wasn't even wanted by any club when he was listed as trade bait at the end of 2005. I would say they would pass on him. Agree on the back up calls on some of the players  MT after all Rodan would have been on that list had he not been pick up by Port.

[letsgetiton!]

Tivs wasn't even wanted by any club when he was listed as trade bait at the end of 2005. I would say they would pass on him. Agree on the back up calls on some of the players  MT after all Rodan would have been on that list had he not been pick up by Port.

and 2006, and 2004.

tiv is nothing

and btw, imo, many clubs would jump at an opportunity to get krak, he is more valuable than most think

[WilliamPowell]

From the list I reckons there is 5 definites and 1 possible and 1 maybe
 

[torch]

Jackson ---- GOLD COAST KANGAROOS ... LMFAO

Hartigan --- RE-DRAFTED

Moore --- NO ONE !

Tivendale --- NO ONE !

Hyde --- NO ONE !

Meyer --- I Wouldn't Let Go ... But ... obviously Port Adelaide or Adelaide

Hall --- NO ONE !

Gaspar --- LMFAO NO ONE !

Tambling --- RE-DRAFTED

Krakouer --- Don't Know

Knobel --- NO ONE !

[Mr Magic]

Jackson
Hartigan
Moore
Tivendale
Hyde
Meyer
Hall
Gaspar
Tambling
Krakouer
Knobel

?

Most clubs would take Tambo as he's only 20. He would be in the best 22 of bottom 8 sides and would get the occasional game at a top club where he would be surrounded by a team full of A-grade players.

Both SA clubs would give Meyer a chance being an ex-South Aussie but he wouldn't be in their 22.

Tivs, Krak and Hyde would only get picked up cheap in the PSD as temporary back-up in case of injury.

Other clubs wouldn't go near the rest. 

I reckon this is the most accurate post.

This thread isn't about those who might be picked up as a speculative draft pick like Rodan(who'll end up in reserves for Port).

Tambling is the only one on that list IMO that would possibly get a game in any other teams 22.

A sad indictment on our list that we have so many reserve grade footballers who are supposedly ready to be senior players.

Could be a very tough season coming up..

[julzqld]

Really you guys - you bag Jackstar for being negative.  Then you turn around and say that practically half our senior side aren't fit to play for Richmond let alone any other club.  I, for one am getting pretty sick of all the negativity, especially as it is only just turned March.  It reminds me too much of another Richmond forum.

[mightytiges]

Really you guys - you bag Jackstar for being negative.  Then you turn around and say that practically half our senior side aren't fit to play for Richmond let alone any other club.  I, for one am getting pretty sick of all the negativity, especially as it is only just turned March.  It reminds me too much of another Richmond forum.

Not trying to be negative Julz. Those names are only a quarter of our list and a number would be in the make or break year category (Harts, Jacko, Moore) or nearing the end like Gas anyway. Just means we aren't there yet as a strong list with depth which isn't a surprise to anyone. If we went through our whole list plenty would be chased by other clubs. Most after our talented youngsters. There's plenty to be positive about but it's going to take time and like most things it'll probably take a bit longer than initially planned and hoped for.   

[Rodgerramjet]

Tambling and Krakouer.

And as said elsewhere Meyer MIGHT get a go in SA.