Jack Riewoldt - Triple Coleman medallist [merged]

[nahadaman]

Might get a gun for him?

[TigerTime]

no way. everyone talks about how kpp take longer to develop but no one is giving this kid a chance, his yr has not been as bad as many think considering how bad we are travelling and how bad we deliver the ball inside 50
jack will be a gun dont worry about that

[Ramps]

Im a big supporter of trading out this year but to JW whilst he is not a superstar he is a keeper - so from me its a no.

[camboon]

No way, its hard to get forwards who compete and Jack can only get better. Could even make a good CHB

[nahadaman]

I'm just not that convinced with him. He seems a bit of a nuff. If we keep him I hope your right and he becomes a superstar for us. Before everyone else realises he is a nuff and we dont get as much for a trade on him down the track. He could be a superstar but something tells me it wont be at Richmond.

[WA Tiger]

No way in the world, why would we trade away the only tall forward we have and for what, he is only 20 or so years old. By the time we have finished trading away players like; Lids, Foley, McGuane, Raines, Moore, Reiwoldt, Thursty and just about every other player in the team that has been mentioned for trade we will be in a worse state than what we are.

We need to build this team around some players and we need to let these players mature NOT trade them away. There is nothing wrong with Reiwoldt and in time he will be one of the best Forwards in the comp IMO so stick fat with these players for God's sake.

[Gracie]

The fact that Riewoldt takes strong marks in the forward line and has a presence means he should be a keeper. Forget his conversion rate at the moment. His cousin had all sorts of question marks over him early and his conversion rate wasn't flash.

No do what WAT says and build a team around him

[nahadaman]

Hey camboon, I like that idea as a CHB.

[TigerLand]

 
 

No.

[wayne]

Yeah good idea, we'll try trade him for either Sellar, Thorpe, Gumbleton, Hansen or Reid.

They're all from the 2006 draft and are performing so much better than Jack. 

[TheUmpire]

I'm just not that convinced with him. He seems a bit of a nuff.

Stupid! The best performed 20 yo KPP from his draft class. There is a nuff involved here, but it ain't Jack.

[Smokey]

Hhhhhm, let me think.

A 20 year old key position player with 39 games under his belt in his 3rd year, averaging nearly 13 disposals, 7 marks, 3 tackles and 3 shots at goal per game in a developing team screaming out for key position players.  If he had kicked straighter we would all be lauding him as the second coming.  He averages more disposals, marks, tackles and shots at goal than Tom Hawkins in a team that starves it's kpp forwards by comparison.  Get real.

[blaisee]

Hhhhhm, let me think.

A 20 year old key position player with 39 games under his belt in his 3rd year, averaging nearly 13 disposals, 7 marks, 3 tackles and 3 shots at goal per game in a developing team screaming out for key position players.  If he had kicked straighter we would all be lauding him as the second coming.  He averages more disposals, marks, tackles and shots at goal than Tom Hawkins in a team that starves it's kpp forwards by comparison.  Get real.

has shown a heap more than

Thorpe
Dowler
both Browns
Gumbleton
Sellar
hansen


is critical to the future of this club

basically any KP around his age

[mat073]

Crazy talk.....No Way

[Hellenic Tiger]

Agree no way this kid could be traded.

Would be football suicide if the club thought otherwise.