Review priority draft pick: Wallace
8:21 PM Sat 1 September, 2007
By Jason Phelan
Exclusive to AFL BigPond Network
RICHMOND coach Terry Wallace has called on the AFL to review its priority draft pick system following his team’s loss to St Kilda at the MCG on Saturday.
The Tigers stood to lose a precious extra pick at the end of the first round of this year’s NAB AFL National Draft if they had beaten the Saints, which was very much on the cards early in the last quarter of the match.
Wallace argued the system as it stands leaves clubs struggling at the bottom of the ladder in an untenable situation in the dying stages of a season; open to unfair scrutiny and unjust innuendo.
“For the first time in 30 years that I’ve come to a game as a player or coach I felt compromised in my position and I never want to be in that position again,” Wallace said.
“I thought it was not fair, not right and shouldn’t be the way that we play the game.
“Young people who are coming up and growing up playing our great game with the notion that somebody might be going out not to play because there might be bigger prizes; I don’t think we should be teaching our young people those lessons in life in general.
“I felt compromised … myself and I thought I was put in a position where I was going to get scrutinised more heavily, if the game finished up the way that it finished, than what we deserved to be.”
Joel Bowden and Nathan Foley, important ball winners for the Tigers, spent time on the bench when the game was up for grabs on Saturday.
Using them as an example, Wallace said he resented being left open to scrutiny as to his motives in that situation, explaining Bowden was a spent force and Foley was resting as a part of the regular midfield rotation.
“I thought our players and our football club showed that we were at least honourable in everything that we did,” he said.
“We put players out on the ground who we could have put away quite easily - Tuck with a broken thumb, King had a massive ankle [problem] last week - but we wanted to play. Our players wanted to put their best foot forward for their supporters in what’s been a really tough year.
“We decided that we didn’t want to go down a pathway of being perceived, under any circumstances, of not trying to win a game of football.
“I couldn’t look my players in the eyes if they wanted to win and I was doing things to be going against their endeavours in the game.
“Others have got to live by what they’ve decided to do and they can have a moralistic view of whether they think that’s right or wrong, but the Richmond Football Club … we just refused to go down that pathway.
“I thought we were at least honourable in everything that we did, but we shouldn’t be in that position. It’s a tough position to be in and personally I think something’s got to be done about it.”
Wallace said the ramifications of a Richmond win would have been far-reaching for the future of the club and that a priority pick was an unhealthy incentive to lose and could prove too tempting for some clubs.
“For people to say that a priority pick doesn’t necessarily win premierships or change the flow of where a football club’s going; the premiership was won last year on the back of Chris Judd playing magnificent football and what’s Chris Judd? He’s a priority pick,” Wallace said.
“One of our biggest problems leading into today was how are we going to stop Nick Riewoldt and guess what? He’s a priority pick. It makes an enormous difference to the way things are structured up.
“If we had won the game of football today, we lose control of the first uncontracted player in the [pre-season] draft and the negotiations around that [as well].
“What that meant for St Kilda going back a few years when they were in that position, they were actually able to secure Aaron Hamill and Fraser Gehrig from the one trade period through being in that position.
“The last time we were in this position we got Trent Knobel and Troy Simmonds out of exactly the same position.”
Wallace did not put forward an alternative model but did suggest outgoing Essendon coach Kevin Sheedy should be drafted into an AFL think-tank to explore better ways of aiding teams that regularly under-performed.
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/Default.aspx?tabid=6301&newsId=50278