Richmond vs Carlton match thread [merged]

[Ox]

Thanks.
That's really,"Far Out" of you man!

Looks like a another late nighter for io.

[tigersalive]

Direct gameday live link Ox.

http://xml.afl.com.au/swf/live_stats.htm

Had to go manually find it since the link didnt work for me on the AFL site. 

So you'll have Eddie on SEN, Mark McClure on ABC or Rexy on 3AW.   

[richmondrules]

Direct gameday live link Ox.

http://xml.afl.com.au/swf/live_stats.htm

Had to go manually find it since the link didnt work for me on the AFL site. 

So you'll have Eddie on SEN, Mark McClure on ABC or Rexy on 3AW.   

Damn good to see when you click on the Judd dot there he is in all his glory in his WCE jumper. 

[Ramps]

A Good win against an undermanned Carlton who were missing some very decent players. A wins a win however and our Membership campaign for 2008 has been saved. I didnt take notes just doing this from memory of the game.

Jake King- Excellent after initial error, guts, spirit, competitive. 8/10
Will Thursfield- Good Job tonight considering the Carlton capability to deliver inside 50 to key fwds- 7/10
Joel Bowden- Average, first half poor, second half better - 5/10
Chris Newman- Average, I expect better from Chris- 5/10
Graham Polak- Below Average Performance for mine, Needs to do more 4/10
Kelvin Moore- Good performance from Kelvin I thought 6/10
Richard Tambling- Showing signs, showing abit of hardness at the contest, good in 2nd half - 6/10
Shane Tuck- Very Good tonight I thought, Didnt turn it over as much from what I saw - 7/10
Andrew Raines- Ok performace, still wants to be a he man, didnt cost us this time - 6/10
Kayne Pettifer- Average performance from Kayne, can play alot better - 5/10
Matthew Richardson- Richo is Richo - 7/10. A Good Performance.
Jordan McMahon- Poor in the first half, better in the 2nd, Average overall 5/10
Brett Deledio- Below Average tonight, 2 goals gets him a 5/10, If he hadnt kicked 2 Id give him a fail.
Jay Schulz- Tried very hard but it was Average Performance for mine, 5/10
Nathan Brown- Excellent when he went onto the ball. A Class Player, can do more though - 7/10
Troy Simmonds- Battled hard, Carlton had very average Rucks - 5/10
Kane Johnson- Was Good tonight- 6/10
Nathan Foley- Another Very Good Performance from RFC's No 1 midfielder 7/10
Daniel Jackson- I thought Dan did Ok tonight, showed enourmous courage on occassions 6/10
Cleve Hughes- One great effort, seems to have lost some mobility needs to play games. Needs time.
Adam Pattison- Ok performace- 5/10
Cam Howat- I thought he went ok, got lots of it but I prefer others in the role 6/10 for what he produces

[bluey_21]

Some pretty harsh judgements but overall pretty good sum up of individual performances ramps

GO TIGES

[Little Jackie]

A Good win against an undermanned Carlton who were missing some very decent players. A wins a win however and our Membership campaign for 2008 has been saved. I didnt take notes just doing this from memory of the game.

Jake King- Excellent after initial error, guts, spirit, competitive. 8/10
Will Thursfield- Good Job tonight considering the Carlton capability to deliver inside 50 to key fwds- 7/10
Joel Bowden- Average, first half poor, second half better - 5/10
Chris Newman- Average, I expect better from Chris- 5/10
Graham Polak- Below Average Performance for mine, Needs to do more 4/10
Kelvin Moore- Good performance from Kelvin I thought 6/10
Richard Tambling- Showing signs, showing abit of hardness at the contest, good in 2nd half - 6/10
Shane Tuck- Very Good tonight I thought, Didnt turn it over as much from what I saw - 7/10
Andrew Raines- Ok performace, still wants to be a he man, didnt cost us this time - 6/10
Kayne Pettifer- Average performance from Kayne, can play alot better - 5/10
Matthew Richardson- Richo is Richo - 7/10. A Good Performance.
Jordan McMahon- Poor in the first half, better in the 2nd, Average overall 5/10
Brett Deledio- Below Average tonight, 2 goals gets him a 5/10, If he hadnt kicked 2 Id give him a fail.
Jay Schulz- Tried very hard but it was Average Performance for mine, 5/10
Nathan Brown- Excellent when he went onto the ball. A Class Player, can do more though - 7/10
Troy Simmonds- Battled hard, Carlton had very average Rucks - 5/10
Kane Johnson- Was Good tonight- 6/10
Nathan Foley- Another Very Good Performance from RFC's No 1 midfielder 7/10
Daniel Jackson- I thought Dan did Ok tonight, showed enourmous courage on occassions 6/10
Cleve Hughes- One great effort, seems to have lost some mobility needs to play games. Needs time.
Adam Pattison- Ok performace- 5/10
Cam Howat- I thought he went ok, got lots of it but I prefer others in the role 6/10 for what he produces

Pretty fair assessment.
The talking point of the night must be the color of Deledio,s, hair 

[tigersalive]

A Good win against an undermanned Carlton who were missing some very decent players. A wins a win however and our Membership campaign for 2008 has been saved. I didnt take notes just doing this from memory of the game.

Jake King- Excellent after initial error, guts, spirit, competitive. 8/10
Will Thursfield- Good Job tonight considering the Carlton capability to deliver inside 50 to key fwds- 7/10
Joel Bowden- Average, first half poor, second half better - 5/10
Chris Newman- Average, I expect better from Chris- 5/10
Graham Polak- Below Average Performance for mine, Needs to do more 4/10
Kelvin Moore- Good performance from Kelvin I thought 6/10
Richard Tambling- Showing signs, showing abit of hardness at the contest, good in 2nd half - 6/10
Shane Tuck- Very Good tonight I thought, Didnt turn it over as much from what I saw - 7/10
Andrew Raines- Ok performace, still wants to be a he man, didnt cost us this time - 6/10
Kayne Pettifer- Average performance from Kayne, can play alot better - 5/10
Matthew Richardson- Richo is Richo - 7/10. A Good Performance.
Jordan McMahon- Poor in the first half, better in the 2nd, Average overall 5/10
Brett Deledio- Below Average tonight, 2 goals gets him a 5/10, If he hadnt kicked 2 Id give him a fail.
Jay Schulz- Tried very hard but it was Average Performance for mine, 5/10
Nathan Brown- Excellent when he went onto the ball. A Class Player, can do more though - 7/10
Troy Simmonds- Battled hard, Carlton had very average Rucks - 5/10
Kane Johnson- Was Good tonight- 6/10
Nathan Foley- Another Very Good Performance from RFC's No 1 midfielder 7/10
Daniel Jackson- I thought Dan did Ok tonight, showed enourmous courage on occassions 6/10
Cleve Hughes- One great effort, seems to have lost some mobility needs to play games. Needs time.
Adam Pattison- Ok performace- 5/10
Cam Howat- I thought he went ok, got lots of it but I prefer others in the role 6/10 for what he produces

Pretty fair assessment.
The talking point of the night must be the color of Deledio,s, hair 

Yep but Petts a 6 or 7 I reckon. Was better than 5.

[Ramps]

I marked Petts down because hes actually played better in the past. In the end, this is just a personal opinion, its neither right nor wrong just a point of view.

[rogerd3]

dan jackson well done son, gotta love those facilties in the MCC...rogerd3 has had way too many, go tigers.

[Fishfinger]

When Jackson kicked the loooong goal in the last I was telling people around me that he was Judd's man. 
The Carlton fans didn't seem too keen to listen.

[mjs]

I think most on here are not getting carried away with that win - which is wise.

Only two I slightly disagree with

Tambling 6/10 - you are kind
McMahon 5/10 - you are a bit hard

When you see Deledio, Brown, Judd (super talent) Murphy and Gibbs get a touch you immediately see the class - I just don't see that with Tambling.

[Ramps]

Just on Gibbs gee I wasnt really looking at Carltons team all that much but I didnt see him alot ... was I mistaken or did he have a shocker.

[Fishfinger]

McMahon's passes to the advantage of the forwards are something I haven't seen since Leon Cameron and Stuey Maxfield. One on his wrong foot in the third quarter was sensational.

[rogerd3]

When Jackson kicked the loooong goal in the last I was telling people around me that he was Judd's man. 
The Carlton fans didn't seem too keen to listen.

yeh funny that.

[rogerd3]

I think most on here are not getting carried away with that win - which is wise.

Only two I slightly disagree with

Tambling 6/10 - you are kind
McMahon 5/10 - you are a bit hard

When you see Deledio, Brown, Judd (super talent) Murphy and Gibbs get a touch you immediately see the class - I just don't see that with Tambling.

didnt see gibbs much at all actually.