The point is that he becomes a restricted free agent at the end of 2012 so he comes under different rules, he isn't being poached under the out of contract rules, he is being grabbed under the restricted free agent rules which means, we get sweet FA if they did make a play but yeah I see the point about the magic hat and it would be up to the AFL but I don't know what they would rule on it and would prefer not to test the water frankly. We could argue that if they are using their magic bucket of money for the start up then he should come under the magic compensation draft pick hat...