Rating Trade Week

[Puntroadroar]

How do we all feel the club went during this week?

[JohnF]

Would have to say A (8/10)

Miller did pretty much all that was required of him

Would have got a nine if we got a good deal for Zantuck, but after hearing what Essendon were offering, I'm glad that deal didn't go through.

Did well to secure two first round picks for Ottens in my opinion. Doesn't look that glamorous a deal in light of the stupidity of North Melbourne and Sydney with their offers for Nathan Thompson and Jolly, but I think we will still win out on this deal.

The Fiora for Simmonds deal was nothing short of superb. 

[froars]

10/10:

To get two picks for a dud
To get rid of a bigger dud with no loss of trade pick
Getting Simmonds
To keep Zantuck and shove it up Sheeds and in such a great way
5 picks under 20 :-)
Going for youth instead of old Hacks
This is the best outcome for 20 years

So yes, i am very happy!

[Fishfinger]

I think we have come out very well off. If Ottens had gone to North it would have been unbelievably good.
Most would probably disagree, but I would like to have seen Moloney come to Richmond instead of pick 12.
9/10.