Richmond Versus Carlton - Game Day Thread

[one-eyed]

Bucks calling Lids lazy again. Just working on natural ability. He's had 99 minutes on ground out of 120. He should be working harder with a 30 min rest over the game.

[one-eyed]

Final Score

Richmond   3.4   6.6   7.14  12.17-89
Carlton       3.3   9.8  13.9   16.13-109

Goals: Riewoldt 3, Nahas 2, Vickery 2, Deledio, Morton, Newman, King

[WA Tiger]

Scores aside we won that game but the hand balls...... I really think Jade won't get the job as he seems to be playing off Wallace's game plan... IMO.

[one-eyed]

Possies:

370 - 352   (172k, 198h)

Cousins     35
Jackson     32
Deledio      29
Cotchin      26
Tuck          25
Newman     23
Tambling    19
King          17
McGuane    16

Tackles:  72 - 81
Hitouts:  30 - 42

[Francois Jackson]

Anyone wanna rate Edwards, King and Hislop?

yeah ill rate them.  stuffin    P A T H E T I C.

3 things about today

im content about the result. going to plan perfectly.

secondly im glad jade cant get it right & win games because we dont want another geesh on our hands and quite frankly he is rubbish.

thirdly those 3 you mentioned Ramps are the reason why we are ridiculed and laughed at by most in the league.

Great day for Post and Vickery. Now where r those fools a month ago who said not to play Vickery. NFI some of you on here



Edit: swear filter avoidance

[mat073]

The highlight for me was that goal by Deledio in the last quarter....Great team goal.

[julzqld]

Scores aside we won that game but the hand balls...... I really think Jade won't get the job as he seems to be playing off Wallace's game plan... IMO.

Unfortunately it's the scores that count.  Riewoldt needs some to settle him down before going for goal like Cambo used to do to Richo.  Was it really windy or are our skills simply shocking?

[Francois Jackson]

Scores aside we won that game but the hand balls...... I really think Jade won't get the job as he seems to be playing off Wallace's game plan... IMO.

Unfortunately it's the scores that count.  Riewoldt needs some to settle him down before going for goal like Cambo used to do to Richo.  Was it really windy or are our skills simply shocking?

the wind was very bad, wrappers all over the ground in the first half.

That being said dont think it made a difference dont think it makes a difference to Jack. He needs some direction on how to kick.

[Jacosh]

Bucks calling Lids lazy again. Just working on natural ability. He's had 99 minutes on ground out of 120. He should be working harder with a 30 min rest over the game.

Lids was head to head with Judd for most of the second half and i would say came out on top with him having 12 disposals and a goal to 10 diposals for Judd.  I wouldnt call that lazy, Tagging Judd is no easy task.

[mightytiges]

Bucks calling Lids lazy again. Just working on natural ability. He's had 99 minutes on ground out of 120. He should be working harder with a 30 min rest over the game.

Lids was head to head with Judd for most of the second half and i would say came out on top with him having 12 disposals and a goal to 10 diposals for Judd.  I wouldnt call that lazy, Tagging Judd is no easy task.

I got the feeling from what Bucks said today he would love to coach Lids. He obviously was paying close attention to Lids' game. Lids was very good today and had the better of Gibbs and then Judd but Bucks obviously saw what Lids needs to do to step up from the good player he is to an elite player in the Judd/Ablett class. More constructive criticism albeit very direct than bagging Lids as such. 

[Go Richo 12]

WAT, i dont think that the Jade is using TW's game plan, i just think the boys are struggling to lose it after 4 1/2 years! Daniel, give credit where credit is due, Kingys game was far fron "effin pathetic". He won his position today. Pleased with the kids, Post and Vickers are going to be real good players for us.
Plenty of positives today

[wayne]

Fevola....

Do you reckon he even knew whether the Blues were winning out there today?

One of the most selfish players I have ever seen.

Sure he chased and put pressure on today, but it was only so he could get a career best.

Blues have no chance of any real success with him in the side.

[Judge Roughneck]

Enjoyed the game - at least we did not get smashed.

I regards to calling Lids lazy - I thought he was on Judd for abit of the game which is not easy. He finshed with 30 touches, 2 goals which is not too shabby.

Vickery showed a bit leading + Post looks the goods, thank Geez they are playing him as a forward. If Reiwoldt learns how to kick he will be a good player. Along with Morton, Nahas etc. if looks like we might have a forward line in the future.

Good that Cotchin got lots of it. Thought Tambling was not bad.

---

King, Polo, McGaune, Edwards, Hislop, Moore really need to do abit more.

Some of Thursfeilds efforts vs. Fev when the ball hit the ground was not flash.

[Infamy]

Moore was injured you drop kick

[Jackstar is back]

Scores aside we won that game but the hand balls...... I really think Jade won't get the job as he seems to be playing off Wallace's game plan... IMO.

Unfortunately it's the scores that count.  Riewoldt needs some to settle him down before going for goal like Cambo used to do to Richo.  Was it really windy or are our skills simply shocking?

the wind was very bad, wrappers all over the ground in the first half.

That being said dont think it made a difference dont think it makes a difference to Jack. He needs some direction on how to kick.

My kids contributed to 2 pie wrappers on the ground.