Jamie O'Reilly [merged]

[Chuck17]

Shame a lot of the others didnt

[bojangles17]

was a bit stop and start , but hey, his first game, with a bit of confidence Im sure we'll see some run in his game, was pretty confident in his won ability to short pass . handled the ball well, clearly he is good material to work with having come this far in a short time, looking forward to see how he turns out following next pre season

[WilliamPowell]

I thought he really struggled with the pace of the game but on the whole he deserves to play next week

[Chuck17]

I thought he got more into the game today.  Looks fairly composed for a new recruit from a different code.

Lot of development to do on this kid but doesn't look too bad.

[wayne]

Kicking looks neat and can get the ball and make smart decisions. Credit to the development team.

[eliminator]

Impressed by his kicking skills

[tony_montana]

for a player new to the game i was and am most impressed with his decision making. Still very early but just get he feeling hes one of those types that understands their limitations. Once a player does they can be moulded to play a role easily.

[TigerLand]

Huge credit to the development team, a great example of teaching a player how to kick "post" draft,

They don't get much plaudits but this looks to be a good win by the development staff.

Amazing what happens when you have them at your club lol.

[Infamy]

Yet after one game some were saying he was out of his depth and should be dropped immediately

Fools!

[jackstar is back again]

Yet after one game some were saying he was out of his depth and should be dropped immediately

Fools!

8 kicks 8 handballs, hardly match winning stuff.
some here are easy pleased, although he was better than last week.
Gave away a stupid free kick which gave them a goal and didnt have enough brains to get back on the mark.

[Infamy]

Yet after one game some were saying he was out of his depth and should be dropped immediately

Fools!

8 kicks 8 handballs, hardly match winning stuff.
some here are easy pleased, although he was better than last week.
Gave away a stupid free kick which gave them a goal and didnt have enough brains to get back on the mark.

Where did I say he put together a match winning performance?
Simply pointing out how stupid it is to write off a player after one game where he was overawed by the step up

[Fluffy Tiger]

Yet after one game some were saying he was out of his depth and should be dropped immediately

Fools!

8 kicks 8 handballs, hardly match winning stuff.
some here are easy pleased, although he was better than last week.
Gave away a stupid free kick which gave them a goal and didnt have enough brains to get back on the mark.

16 possies in second AFL game is not a bad effort.

Here is something easy for you Jack. Write a list of the players on the Richmond list that you have not said were poor, not up to afl standard, should be traded, should never play again, wouldnt get a game at another afl club or any one of your endless negative coments. It wont be a long list but a least we would have it all in one place for future reference.

Give the kid a chance.

[Penelope]

Yet after one game some were saying he was out of his depth and should be dropped immediately

Fools!

8 kicks 8 handballs, hardly match winning stuff.
some here are easy pleased, although he was better than last week.
Gave away a stupid free kick which gave them a goal and didnt have enough brains to get back on the mark.

So what does a player have to do in their first couple of games for you not to write them off?

[jackstar is back again]

this is elite footy afterall.

here is the list.
Lids
Reiwoldt
Cotchin
Cousins( retiring )
Martin.
Newman ( last 2 years )
J.Post- ( this kid can can play -although hasnt shown it )
Astbury
Griffiths
Collins ( terrible yesterday  though )
Moore.
Foley
Jackson.
BrownE

take Cousins out, and you have 14 players to take us to our next finals

Add Edwards,Tuck, King, Graham

[jackstar is back again]

Yet after one game some were saying he was out of his depth and should be dropped immediately

Fools!

8 kicks 8 handballs, hardly match winning stuff.
some here are easy pleased, although he was better than last week.
Gave away a stupid free kick which gave them a goal and didnt have enough brains to get back on the mark.

So what does a player have to do in their first couple of games for you not to write them off?

Kid the kid a rule book for a start