Give us your 1, 2, 3, 4 as at 19 August

[Danog]

1. Hinkley
2. Richardson
3. Hardwick






4. Rawlings

ditto

[cub]

I really don't know enough about Hinkley, Hardwick or Richardson to make an informed judgment. On the other hand I have seen enough of Jade to know he would be my last preference.

Stripes

Think that goes for most of us! Just perception rather than anything else.

[Beren]

1. Hinkley
2. Rawlings



3. Richardson



4. Hardwick

[Jackstar is back]

1/ ben cousins ( playing coach )

Got more knowledge than all four put together.
That tells you alot about the 4 applicants

[tiga]

1/ ben cousins ( playing coach )

Got more knowledge than all four put together.
That tells you alot about the 4 applicants

ohhh great...no matter what happens, another 3 years of Jacks coach bagging coming up hot and steaming!


For me

Hardwick
Hinkley
Richardson

[Chuck17]

ohhh great...no matter what happens, another 3 years of Jacks coach bagging coming up hot and steaming!

Definitely something to look forward to isnt it

[the_boy_jake]

1/ ben cousins ( playing coach )

Got more knowledge than all four put together.
That tells you alot about the 4 applicants

Jack you keep mentioning Cousins as a player coach.

Also you keep saying how Sheeds had an innovative succession plan if he were to get the job and it wasn't James Hird but someone else.

Sheeds spoke to Cousins and effectively got him to Punt Road.

I would have thought coaching was the last thing on Cuz's mind but putting 2 and 2 together (prob getting 5) did Sheedy want to groom Cousins to coach us in 2-3 years time?

[DallasCrane]

1. Hinkley
2. Richardson
3. Hardwick






4. Rawlings

My feelings exactly

[Jackstar is back]

1/ ben cousins ( playing coach )

Got more knowledge than all four put together.
That tells you alot about the 4 applicants

Jack you keep mentioning Cousins as a player coach.

Also you keep saying how Sheeds had an innovative succession plan if he were to get the job and it wasn't James Hird but someone else.

Sheeds spoke to Cousins and effectively got him to Punt Road.

I would have thought coaching was the last thing on Cuz's mind but putting 2 and 2 together (prob getting 5) did Sheedy want to groom Cousins to coach us in 2-3 years time?

The Ben Cousins thing was in jest.
Will say this though.
Sheeds did have a succession plan,
He offered his services to the club with a succession plan .
March told him, the he didnt want him as coach. Thus Sheeds pulled out as a candidate -FACT
Major reason being that Sheeds wanted a ""complete clean out" of the club,all board members and all senior positions.
March told him to go and jump.
It is true that Sheedy instigated-masterminded in getting Cuz to Punt Road, not Wallace.
In the current climate, I would of thought the K. Sheedy model would of been great for our football club.
Now we will get a coach that has been overlooked by other clubs, you figure that out.

[the_boy_jake]

The Ben Cousins thing was in jest.
Will say this though.
Sheeds did have a succession plan,
He offered his services to the club with a succession plan .
March told him, the he didnt want him as coach. Thus Sheeds pulled out as a candidate -FACT
Major reason being that Sheeds wanted a ""complete clean out" of the club,all board members and all senior positions.
March told him to go and jump.
It is true that Sheedy instigated-masterminded in getting Cuz to Punt Road, not Wallace.
In the current climate, I would of thought the K. Sheedy model would of been great for our football club.
Now we will get a coach that has been overlooked by other clubs, you figure that out.

Fair enough.

[tigersalive]

1/ ben cousins ( playing coach )

Got more knowledge than all four put together.
That tells you alot about the 4 applicants

Jack you keep mentioning Cousins as a player coach.

Also you keep saying how Sheeds had an innovative succession plan if he were to get the job and it wasn't James Hird but someone else.

Sheeds spoke to Cousins and effectively got him to Punt Road.

I would have thought coaching was the last thing on Cuz's mind but putting 2 and 2 together (prob getting 5) did Sheedy want to groom Cousins to coach us in 2-3 years time?

Now we will get a coach that has been overlooked by other clubs, you figure that out.

Let me know what other jobs Richardson, Hinkley and Rawlings applied for to be overlooked.  ???  Because if you didn't know they chose not to apply for the Kangas job.  FACT. 


Yeah, nailed the fact and the wink and all.  On fire.   

[Infamy]

Can't really split the top 3, they all have strengths and weaknesses. Would be nice if we could get more than one of them.










4. Rawlings

[sugark]

1/ ben cousins ( playing coach )

Got more knowledge than all four put together.
That tells you alot about the 4 applicants

Jack you keep mentioning Cousins as a player coach.

Also you keep saying how Sheeds had an innovative succession plan if he were to get the job and it wasn't James Hird but someone else.

Sheeds spoke to Cousins and effectively got him to Punt Road.

I would have thought coaching was the last thing on Cuz's mind but putting 2 and 2 together (prob getting 5) did Sheedy want to groom Cousins to coach us in 2-3 years time?

The Ben Cousins thing was in jest.
Will say this though.
Sheeds did have a succession plan,
He offered his services to the club with a succession plan .
March told him, the he didnt want him as coach. Thus Sheeds pulled out as a candidate -FACT
Major reason being that Sheeds wanted a ""complete clean out" of the club,all board members and all senior positions.
March told him to go and jump.
It is true that Sheedy instigated-masterminded in getting Cuz to Punt Road, not Wallace.
In the current climate, I would of thought the K. Sheedy model would of been great for our football club.
Now we will get a coach that has been overlooked by other clubs, you figure that out.

JJ, Sheeds was overlooked by Melbourne for D.Bailey of all people

By your last comment you are assuming that we appoint Hardwick that we are getting someone that was overlooked by other clubs.  If we appoint Hinkley or Richardson are they people that have been overlooked by other clubs...no they are not.

The same way that Sheedy and Malthouse were given a chance as untried coaches we are about to do the same to someone and you never know what we may unearth.

But what the heck these sort of FACTS don't suit your argument, and you will continue to rubbish all things Richmond because they didnt see anything in you.

I'll say it again, let it go and support the Tiges instead of carrying this bitter grudge forever and a day.

[Jackstar is back]

1/ ben cousins ( playing coach )

Got more knowledge than all four put together.
That tells you alot about the 4 applicants

Jack you keep mentioning Cousins as a player coach.

Also you keep saying how Sheeds had an innovative succession plan if he were to get the job and it wasn't James Hird but someone else.

Sheeds spoke to Cousins and effectively got him to Punt Road.

I would have thought coaching was the last thing on Cuz's mind but putting 2 and 2 together (prob getting 5) did Sheedy want to groom Cousins to coach us in 2-3 years time?

The Ben Cousins thing was in jest.
Will say this though.
Sheeds did have a succession plan,
He offered his services to the club with a succession plan .
March told him, the he didnt want him as coach. Thus Sheeds pulled out as a candidate -FACT
Major reason being that Sheeds wanted a ""complete clean out" of the club,all board members and all senior positions.
March told him to go and jump.
It is true that Sheedy instigated-masterminded in getting Cuz to Punt Road, not Wallace.
In the current climate, I would of thought the K. Sheedy model would of been great for our football club.
Now we will get a coach that has been overlooked by other clubs, you figure that out.

JJ, Sheeds was overlooked by Melbourne for D.Bailey of all people

By your last comment you are assuming that we appoint Hardwick that we are getting someone that was overlooked by other clubs.  If we appoint Hinkley or Richardson are they people that have been overlooked by other clubs...no they are not.

The same way that Sheedy and Malthouse were given a chance as untried coaches we are about to do the same to someone and you never know what we may unearth.

But what the heck these sort of FACTS don't suit your argument, and you will continue to rubbish all things Richmond because they didnt see anything in you.

I'll say it again, let it go and support the Tiges instead of carrying this bitter grudge forever and a day.

I let it go ages ago, aint got nothing to do with me, so why you keep referring to me
I couldnt give a stuff actually.
What I will say that knowing the applicants involved, I wouldnt think success is close by.
None of the applicants have the presence to impose themselves on this club, as the problem is much more deeper, as we all know

[WilliamPowell]

I really don't know enough about Hinkley, Hardwick or Richardson to make an informed judgment. On the other hand I have seen enough of Jade to know he would be my last preference.

Stripes

Actually you make a good point there Stripes and with that in mind and using that criteria I stick to what I've believed all along

1. Rawlings
2. Richardson


3. Hinkley (and yes I have watched the video speech)












4. Hardwick