Kamdyn McIntosh - 150th game this week [merged]

[The Machine]

Keep for mine. Should be playing before Ellis anyway IMO.

[big tone]

For me I really like McIntosh and what he brings, but what this year has shown me more than anything else is it isn’t always the better you know.

McIntosh is a good player but not a great player and if he does leave there is the potential to replace/find a champion take his spot.
If he left it gives another young guy a chance in his position.

Sydney Stack has shown me there are guns out there that can completely change the club if given the chance.

[Slipper]

McIntosh is a role player who plays his role well in our team.

His pace and endurance are important to our pressure game, and I would have thought we’d want to keep him.

[Diocletian]

The archetypal "good ordinary player".....handy to have around but easily expendable....

[the claw]

i dont get the angst about this bloke going.

Name one thing he does to a very high level i cant think of one.
Running hard and runnining straight just doesnt cut it theres so much more to the game than this

For a bloke who has played so much on a wing his numbers over the duration, that is they have been constant are poor.
Couple this with the panic kicks the regular fumbles when under pressure the lack of composure the paltry amount of ball he gets even as a defensive wing he is more than expendable.

In saying that id have him in the team before a bloke like Ellis every day of the week.

For me its simple every single team has room for improvement and that includes us. W e need to evolve and keep evolving by weeding out blokes like Ellis and unfortunate to say McIntosh.
Theres plenty of blokes who have big holes in their games who have been around for awhile and just have not addressed the deficiencies.

Good ordinary sums him up and it implies we have to find a bit better and improve.

[Diocletian]

Lets face it, it's highly unlikely his trade value ever going to be higher...

[Andyy]

Premiership player, adds serious currency! Personally I'd like to keep him but would prefer to try Balta and see if he can do a better job

[Rampsation]

Big chance to come in next week i reckon

[Francois Jackson]

run with role?

has the tank, has experience.

yes for me

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Pretty good test for who comes in is the VFL GF.....

[Assange Tiger 😎]

^

Bloody oath

[Owl]

Man I don't wanna lose Macca, he is a tiger

[Diocletian]

A very handy but severely flawed and easily replaced fringe player with premiership medal- the exact sort you should be looking to trade while they still have currency... 

[yandb]

Yes Diode your assessment of Mcintosh is probably as good as your assessment of Soldo.

[Diocletian]

So you're saying he's flawless player that's not easily replaced? Ok then.....