Official Richmond Team -v- Geelong (Rd 7)

[tigs2011]

Surprised there hasn't been more said about it but it's got me particularly flummoxed why we have brought Adwards back in favour of a Elton, McBean or O'Hanlon.
I just don't rate this bloke.

Because he. Had it on a string last week first game back from a lay off, had either of those rookies chalked up 26 touches8 or 9 marks and a couple of snags, yeah you re right, they'd be belting the door down for a spot too

VFL is this 30yr olds level now. He'll soon enough be kicking bags in the country for years.

Imagine the coin he'd make there. Then again we're probably paying him big cash as it is.

[Golfprotiger]

No Pettard - yes......

[eliminator]

 

[TigerMonk]

No Pettard - yes......

Maybe so but he played a superb game in the 2nds to show he has good VFL skills 

[Judge Roughneck]

Was this the best side that rfc could have fielded

[Eat_em_Alive]

Intially I was not pleased with the selections made, however tge question I ask is this:
Should Newy, shed, aedwards, vickery etc not played
Would griff, arnott, elton etc have dug deep enough to fight back? Or would those kids have waited and watched lids and co try to do the work?

Perhaps we were only one match selection wrong from getting the 4 points but we will never know now

[Mr Magic]

Surprised there hasn't been more said about it but it's got me particularly flummoxed why we have brought Adwards back in favour of a Elton, McBean or O'Hanlon.
I just don't rate this bloke.

Because he. Had it on a string last week first game back from a lay off, had either of those rookies chalked up 26 touches8 or 9 marks and a couple of snags, yeah you re right, they'd be belting the door down for a spot too

He was our weakest link today. Absolute non event.
Must not play again.

[tony_montana]

Griff for Azza and who knows what could've happened