Grimes vs Rance

[lamington]

I have to disagree knighted. Early in his career yes and that pantsing from Travis Cloke is a standout. But he improved his game then became unbeatable. He has franklin’s measure when he was still good at Sydney and he crushed Tex Walker when he was still a good forward in the GF.

[Knighter]

I saw Rance get beaten by Walker multiple times plus Hogan, Cloke, Josh Kennedy, DeGoey in the Prelim in 18 and even the big Doofus from #lolnorf. On the other hand he could shut down Franklin and Hawkins. Also Astbury played on Walker in the 17 GF.

[Rampsation]

Rance is better than Grimes. Id pick Rance first over Grimes.

[Andyy]

I saw Rance get beaten by Walker multiple times plus Hogan, Cloke, Josh Kennedy, DeGoey in the Prelim in 18 and even the big Doofus from #lolnorf. On the other hand he could shut down Franklin and Hawkins. Also Astbury played on Walker in the 17 GF.

Pretty sure Hogan kicked about 2 goals on Rance and took maybe 2 contested marks against him.

Honestly if you can remember the games he was beaten the he has done very well. You've listed max 10 games out of 200.

[Hard Roar Tiger]

They are both champions of the club but Rance is the best defender I’ve seen in yellow and black.

[Tiger Khosh]

Grimes is an A+ defender and champion of the club.

Rance was a generational talent in the same bracket as dusty. They sit on a different level to all the other premiership players of this dynasty.

[Diocletian]

5 years from now the correct answer will be Balta...