Where do you predict he will play next year?
I actually don't think he will play again for anyone
He is contracted to GWS until the end of 2017 so unless they relent and trade him he will remain a GWS until the end of his contract
And NO if I was GWS I wouldn't trade him either
So you wouldn't trade him and get something for him? Even if he refused to play for you? It's ok to prove a point for a year but if it's going to hurt your club they should do a trade and potentially get a very good pick for him IMO. Or a decent player.
Would you be happy to get nothing for Titch Edwards if he was deadset keen on returning to SA? Or would you try to broker a deal and at least have a say in what you get in return.
IMO AFL footy has changed and if players want to leave for whatever reason and you have done everything in your power to try and change their minds and failed, then do the best you can on the return deal. No point cutting off your nose despite your face.