Noah Cumberland [merged]

[Hard Roar Tiger]

Our sub last night was shocking.
Pee off Mansell or Rioli and bring in HRS.

[lamington]

For me it should have been sonsie. I know he hasn’t piled on goals but would at least give us some unpredictability in the midfield mix

[georgies31]

I got no problems with spray , but our kids a copping it what about most of our senior blokes been all away on holiday most of the year or when they do get the footy they kill us with mistakes premiership players or not they should be accountable to.

[Francois Jackson]

I got no problems with spray , but our kids a copping it what about most of our senior blokes been all away on holiday most of the year or when they do get the footy they kill us with mistakes premiership players or not they should be accountable to.

agree Georgie i dont mind Samson at this stage under the circumstances. Older players have been average, and not the most popular opinion but i include dusty in that.

Paid to kick goals and he didnt. If it was lynch who missed those last night, this site would have latched on to him like a fly on poo.

[WilliamPowell]

agree Georgie i dont mind Samson at this stage under the circumstances. Older players have been average, and not the most popular opinion but i include dusty in that.

Paid to kick goals and he didnt. If it was lynch who missed those last night, this site would have latched on to him like a fly on poo.

Like you have with the fitness bloke 

 

[one-eyed]

Read the full article here: https://theshinboner.com/2023/04/26/fortnightly-focus-sam-taylor-gws-esava-ratugolea-geelong-noah-cumberland-richmond-analysis-afl/

[one-eyed]

Cumberland 1 disposal after halftime and that was a handball.
Last week 2 disposal after halftime.
Wow that’s 3 disposals in 4 quarters and no goals.

https://twitter.com/cr2000000/status/1652625029560152065

[georgies31]

I didn't mind Dimma criticism last week rightfully needs yo stay involved in games.

[Andyy]

Thought he tried enough but we were kinda getting fisted in the A after half time with nothing happening up forward anyway.

Not happy but also not worried when the team is going this poo.

[WilliamPowell]

After half time only?

I thought he had a mare for the entire game myself

[Assange Tiger 😎]

Had a bad day. Looks lost with his set shots

Still, this is probably the first truly bad game he has played at this level. Young players have these sorts of games. Stick by him

[mat073]

Worst game I’ve seen him play .

[Knighter]

Worst game I’ve seen him play .

The coach bagging him out last week probably didn't help his confidence.

[eliminator]

Playing on the wing at one stage did not help either.

[MintOnLamb]

We need to put faith in these players and give them confidence, having them in and out of the team they are all hanging on a thread. Any mistakes they make are magnified.

Not saying all is perfect but look at Ellis, Butler, chol, mrakov, higgins, all doing ok. Sure not world beaters but better than a lot on our list.

I think it is time to clear out older players and get games into our youth. Riewoldt and Votchin should both retire.