I don’t see where someone claimed that lynch had a better season than Dixon. I certainly never claimed this. But whose had a better career? That would be without a doubt Lynch.
Now can we apply the same logic to your Jeremy Cameron selection? Who had a better season last year between him and Lynch? Again that would be without a doubt Lynch. So which is it? Are you picking players based on their performances last season or the balance of their careers or do you just change this to suit your argument of not picking a tigers player?
Lol it was quite obvious that i picked players on personal preference and on the yr they had. fmd i mentioned Dan Butler as the best performed small fwd and didnt pick him. Robbie Gray had a ordinary yr by his standards and i did pick him.
I didnt pick Hawkins who won the coleman medal by a decent margin because i chose to pick a player i like more in Cameron who had an ordinary year.
I picked Dixon a 200cm fwd over lynch 199cm a similar player in the real tall fwd role. I wasnt picking two 199-200cm tall fwds in the same fwd line. I picked Dixon because i really liked the season he had. But how dare i like an opposition players season.
If you want me to pick a fwd line based solely on their careers ill happily do that if need be. but i dont think tom lynch will be one of the talls.
I picked Cameron because i think he has been very good for a long time. to me he is a differnt type of KPF to Lynch.
I had Riewoldt Gunston and Darling as third tall more mobile types all bunched together should you pick any of them on the yr they had ? you can make a good case for and against all of em.
Just my opinion but i dont think JR had the best of seasons generally down on what he has done in previous seasons.
I think plenty here have agreed with that.
Nope your just playing the man because you mistakenly think i just ignore our players. you get upset because i didnt put a richmond player in a team.
If i was picking from the current bunch of talls based on their careers to date then the options would be
Franklin, Kennedy, Riewoldt , Hawkins and Cameron. If kicking goals is a major part of a Key Forwards role then Cameron is only behind
Franklin when it comes to average goals per game and would have to be in the mix. . id probably pick the first three if picking a side based on their careers to date.
I think you will struggle to find a post where i have been highly critical of Lynch or Riewoldt especially over the the last 10 yrs.
If im not posting about em it usually means im happy.
At the end of the day supporters are too precious and are blinkered and incapable of balanced views on our own, they are always better than oppo players and oppo players are always worse this thread is an example.
