One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on February 08, 2011, 01:25:39 PM
-
Daniel Jackson (hamstring tendonitis) - TBA
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/107450/default.aspx
-
Great sign (touch wood) with only one player out. I wonder who will step up into the tagging role in his absence...Grigg perhaps?
-
Great sign (touch wood) with only one player out. I wonder who will step up into the tagging role in his absence...Grigg perhaps?
Gus and Farmer won't play either as they've hardly trained all preseason so we really aren't missing just one player.
Yep Stripes Grigg will probably have to tag as we don't have many other options as far as taggers. Kingy might be able to do a shutdown role in the midfield but whoever he tags only has to push forward to make him a liability.
-
Richmond
(practice match v Port Adelaide at Alice Springs, Friday)
Daniel Jackson (hamstring tendonitis) - TBA
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/afl-injury-list-stuff-2/story-e6frf9jf-1225915529309
-
Richmond
(practice match v Port Adelaide at Alice Springs, Friday)
Daniel Jackson (hamstring tendonitis) - TBA
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/afl-injury-list-stuff-2/story-e6frf9jf-1225915529309
Isn't Jackson named to play this week?
-
yep
-
Injury update - 23/3/2011
Mitch Farmer (heel) - test
Jake King (suspension) - 1 week
Tom Hislop (knee) - 2-3 weeks
Kelvin Moore (hip) - TBA
Ben Griffiths (shoulder) - ongoing assessment
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/109730/default.aspx
-
Injury update - 23/3/2011
Mitch Farmer (heel) - test
Jake King (suspension) - 1 week
Tom Hislop (knee) - 2-3 weeks
Kelvin Moore (hip) - TBA
Ben Griffiths (shoulder) - ongoing assessment
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/109730/default.aspx
On going assessement seems to be the politically correct terminology for "we aint gotta clue" ;D
A number of clubs have players listed OGA
-
looks like we can a add a few more players to the list.
-
looks like we can a add a few more players to the list.
Looks like your user name is going to last you for another 18000 years
-
Injury update - 23/3/2011
Mitch Farmer (heel) - test
Jake King (suspension) - 1 week
Tom Hislop (knee) - 2-3 weeks
Kelvin Moore (hip) - TBA
Ben Griffiths (shoulder) - ongoing assessment
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/109730/default.aspx
Hislop is still on our list??? :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
-
Injury update - March 29, 2011
Richmond
Mitch Farmer (heel) - test
Ben Griffiths (shoulder) - ongoing assessment
Tom Hislop (knee) - 2-3 weeks
Kelvin Moore (hip) - TBA
-
I really think Moore is a great loss.
-
I really think Moore is a great loss.
How's that?
-
I really think Moore is a great loss.
How's that?
Well wouldnt you say he is the biggest and most imposing backman we have?? He is able to crash the packs and really put some muscle on the opposition. He also runs of his opponent quite a bit which in turns creates movement up the ground...thats what I have seen him do anyway.
-
WAT, the mad one is just continuing his broken record about Moore. He thinks that Moore is a dud while Mcguane is is a top line player. He will never see that the main difference between the two is that Moore understands how to play zone defence and defend a space, while Mcguane can only play man on man.
-
I really think Moore is a great loss.
How's that?
Well wouldnt you say he is the biggest and most imposing backman we have?? He is able to crash the packs and really put some muscle on the opposition. He also runs of his opponent quite a bit which in turns creates movement up the ground...thats what I have seen him do anyway.
Moore is a good player. :thumbsup
-
what's Moore's status at the moment?
Is he right to go?
He didnt play too many pre-season games did he?
A couple of weeks at Coburg is probably in order, before he's back in the mix.
-
WAT, the mad one is just continuing his broken record about Moore. He thinks that Moore is a dud while Mcguane is is a top line player. He will never see that the main difference between the two is that Moore understands how to play zone defence and defend a space, while Mcguane can only play man on man.
Ah, no worries al.... :thumbsup
-
what's Moore's status at the moment?
Is he right to go?
There's now an update in the thread about him. He's 3 weeks away from playing.
-
The mystery about O'riely was revealed last night. He's suffering shin splints and is a couple of weeks from resuming with coburg.
Xman is also a couple of weeks away.
...and the one everyone is dying to hear about, Hislop. :P
Had extra bone removed from both knees last year after needing jabs to play early in the season. He then suffered tendonitis in the knees which has disrupted his pre season.
-
Coburg could have user orielly today.
The mystery about O'riely was revealed last night. He's suffering shin splints and is a couple of weeks from resuming with coburg.
Xman is also a couple of weeks away.
...and the one everyone is dying to hear about, Hislop. :P
Had extra bone removed from both knees last year after needing jabs to play early in the season. He then suffered tendonitis in the knees which has disrupted his pre season.
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 4 April):
Mitch Farmer (heel) 1-2 weeks
Tom Derickx (heel) 1-2 weeks
Alex Rance (suspension) 2 weeks
Luke McGuane (suspension) 2 weeks
Tom Hislop (knee) 2-3 weeks
Kelvin Moore (hip) 2-3 weeks
Ben Griffiths (shoulder) Ongoing assessment
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 12 April):
Luke McGuane (suspension) 1 week
Alex Rance (suspension) 1 week
Tom Hislop (knee) 1-2 weeks
Kelvin Moore (hip) 1-2 weeks
Ben Griffiths (shoulder) Ongoing assessment
-
They never give the full injury list
Why the stuff is that ??
RFC_O ?? ??
-
They never give the full injury list
Why the eff is that ??
RFC_O ?? ??
Who do you think is missing al?
-
They never give the full injury list
Why the eff is that ??
RFC_O ?? ??
Who do you think is missing al?
Not speaking for al
But where's O'Reilly?
Where's Farmer - last week he was -2 weeks now he isn't on the list at all :-\ Saturday night he said he may play for Coburg this week - would think that warrants the term "test"
Where's DerickX?
-
They never give the full injury list
Why the eff is that ??
RFC_O ?? ??
Who do you think is missing al?
Billy has answered for me
-
Derickx and Farmer have been back in full footy training for the past week or so and will play for Coburg this weekend.
Moore, Hislop and Griffiths are in full training as well and it's now about getting footy specific work into them after being out for so long. They will be back playing in the next couple of weeks more than likely via Coburg.
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/roar%20vision%20archive/tabid/11454/contentid/346413/default.aspx
-
Thanks :thumbsup
-
Derickx and Farmer have been back in full footy training for the past week or so and will play for Coburg this weekend.
Moore, Hislop and Griffiths are in full training as well and it's now about getting footy specific work into them after being out for so long. They will be back playing in the next couple of weeks more than likely via Coburg.
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/roar%20vision%20archive/tabid/11454/contentid/346413/default.aspx
All great news. Particularly about the X-Man and Griff.
-
Tiger pair return from injury
richmondfc.com.au
By Tony Greenberg
Wed 13 Apr, 2011
Two of Richmond’s mature-age recruits over the past couple of years will return to the playing field with Coburg in the VFL this weekend after being sidelined with injury in the opening rounds of the 2011 season.
Mitch Farmer, 22, and Tom Derickx, 23, will line up for the Coburg Tigers in their clash with Northern Bullants at Coburg City Oval on Sunday (April 17).
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/6301/newsid/111545/default.aspx
-
I'd rather an unfit Derickx than a fit Graham in the 1s.
-
I wouldn't
Understand the concerns with Goose but think you are overrating the "WAFL wonder" there ;D
-
Need to be careful not to put too much expectations on Derickx
-
:lol thats funny wanting unfit players playing, just goes to show how stupid some people are :banghead
-
I wouldn't
Understand the concerns with Goose but think you are overrating the "WAFL wonder" there ;D
Derickx 1 game has shown more than Angus has in 5 years
-
:lol thats funny wanting unfit players playing, just goes to show how stupid some people are :banghead
You stupid old man, it was a figure of speech.
Get out and socialise you geriatric
-
Dan Connors out injured this week, but he didn't make the injury list.
-
connors has bruised ego
-
I wouldn't
Understand the concerns with Goose but think you are overrating the "WAFL wonder" there ;D
Derickx 1 game has shown more than Angus has in 5 years
agree :thumbsup
-
connors has bruised ego
total bullSH1T
when r u going to stop ur effing bs
sometimes your opinions, not facts , show how laughable u r
if connors was not injuured he would be playing, how do i know, he told me so as did dimma when i spoke to them today
get ur facts straight jack
-
connors has bruised ego
total bullpoo
when r u going to stop ur effing bs
sometimes your opinions, not facts , show how laughable u r
if connors was not injuured he would be playing, how do i know, he told me so as did dimma when i spoke to them today
get ur facts straight jack
Lighten up X
Jack was being funny and it was a goodie coming from Jack who rarely shows any humour ;D
-
connors has bruised ego
total bullpoo
when r u going to stop ur effing bs
sometimes your opinions, not facts , show how laughable u r
if connors was not injuured he would be playing, how do i know, he told me so as did dimma when i spoke to them today
get ur facts straight jack
Lighten up X
Jack was being funny and it was a goodie coming from Jack who rarely shows any humour ;D
u only say that cos u cant stand connors
jack should be an afl coach he apparently knows it all
-
u only say that cos u cant stand connors
Facts are x you & I both know (as Jack does) that there is no way in the world they would drop Connors
Only reason he isn't playing this week is because he is injured
That's why Jack's comment was funny ;D
And yes you are correct I don't like Dan Connors as a player in a team sport and I have my reasons ;)
-
connors has bruised ego
total bullpoo
when r u going to stop ur effing bs
sometimes your opinions, not facts , show how laughable u r
if connors was not injuured he would be playing, how do i know, he told me so as did dimma when i spoke to them today
get ur facts straight jack
Serious question here X, how much are the bananas this week, ? $12.99 a kilo ? :birthday
-
:whistle
-
:whistle
:whistle :whistle :whistle :birthday
-
I wouldn't
Understand the concerns with Goose but think you are overrating the "WAFL wonder" there ;D
True GG but it would be impossible to underrate the Goose.
-
Different injury lists on the AFL and RFC sites ???....
Richmond*
Ben Griffiths (shoulder) - ongoing assessment
Tom Hislop (knee) - 1-2 weeks
Kelvin Moore (hip) - 1-2 weeks
*as provided by the club on April 13, 2011
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/112015/default.aspx
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 19 April):
Daniel Connors (ankle) Test
Kelvin Moore (hip) 1-2 weeks
Ben Griffiths (shoulder) 1-2 weeks
Ben Jakobi (foot) 2-3 weeks
Jamie O’Reilly (foot) 2-3 weeks
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/injury%20list/tabid/9411/default.aspx
-
Hopefully the RFC site's one is the accurate one and Big Ben is only 2 weeks away and more importantly his shoulders hold up :pray.
-
Given the one on the RFC site is 6 days newer than the AFL site it should be more accurate
-
Matt Hornsby with the latest medical report....
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/roarvisionarchive/tabid/11454/contentid/348274/default.aspx
Connors hurt his ankle (minor) last week at training so missed the Friday nighter but trained fully today and is right to go.
Farmer and Derickx got through the allocated gametime at Coburg on the weekend and they'll ramp that up this weekend.
Hislop is back training and if he gets through this week he'll play for Coburg this weekend.
O'Reilly - shin sorness that lingered but he's now pain free and back running. We'll progress his volume at training and he should be right in a couple of weeks.
Griffiths - in full contact training. If he continues that for the next week or so he'll be back playing.
-
no mention about Connors injury to his ego ?? :lol
-
Great news RE Griffiths
-
Matt Hornsby with the latest medical report....
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/roarvisionarchive/tabid/11454/contentid/348274/default.aspx
Connors hurt his ankle (minor) last week at training so missed the Friday nighter but trained fully today and is right to go.
Farmer and Derickx got through the allocated gametime at Coburg on the weekend and they'll ramp that up this weekend.
Hislop is back training and if he gets through this week he'll play for Coburg this weekend.
O'Reilly - shin sorness that lingered but he's now pain free and back running. We'll progress his volume at training and he should be right in a couple of weeks.
Griffiths - in full contact training. If he continues that for the next week or so he'll be back playing.
Thats good news on all fronts, if we dont have anymore (big if) then we could have a full list to choose from in 3-4 weeks. Griffiths is the one I really want to see on the park but Farmer and Derickx also put preasure on the players in the team so are important.
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 27 April):
Ben Griffiths (shoulder) Test
Daniel Jackson (suspension) 1 week
Jamie O’Reilly (foot) 1-2 weeks
Ben Jakobi (foot) 1-2 weeks
Kelvin Moore (hip) TBA
-
Didn't I read somwhere that both Conners and Thursfield sustained injuries playing for coburg on the weekend?? Does anyone no how bad they were?
Cheers
-
The injury list is a joke.
Why even print it?
What about Dea Web etc.
-
I think Davey is injured :o
-
Kelvin Moore (hip) TBA
What does this mean exactly ???
last week he was 1-2 weeks; now it's back to "TBA"
Another setback?
-
Kelvin Moore (hip) TBA
What does this mean exactly ???
last week he was 1-2 weeks; now it's back to "TBA"
Another setback?
sounds like it
i think once griffiths is ready it may be a good chance for miller to hold down chf
we know miller can play down back
-
Doesn't sound good for Kel does it :-\. He's had the hip issue all through the preseason from memory and it looks like we'll have to forget about him this year if it keeps on reoccurring six rounds into the season :(.
-
Hips are just about the worst injury you can get when expecting a time frame to return from rehab..
Just one of the hardest and most frustrating injuries to come back from quickly
-
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 11 May):
Shane Tuck (ribs) Test
Daniel Connors (hamstring) Test
Will Thursfield (leg) 1 week
Matt Dea (leg) 1 week
Jamie O’Reilly (foot) 2 weeks
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Here's Matt Hornsby talking about our injuries:
http://bigpondvideo.com/RichmondTV/353169/medical-room-round-7/
* Whitey has recovered quite well. Scans and X-rays all clear. We subbed him off more given the state of the game and brought Nason on. Whitey will be training later this week and we expect to put his hand up for Sunday.
* Tucky has recovered quickly. Put his hand up to play but we'll make a judgement on that later in the week.
* Moore - We're being conservative as he's had issues with his hip in the past. Thorough planning in place and he's sticking to that and heading in the right direction. Focussing on strength training. Expect him back in full training in a couple of weeks.
* Dea and O'Reilly - both had minor stress reactions but they were caught early so nothing sinister. We'll build up their running volume in next week and half and then they should be back into full training.
-
Moore will probably be playing by midseason. While he's a good defender our defence will be better without him. We tend to use him as a tall defender and he's usually outsized by 5-10cm and 10kg. He rarely plays stuff, but if he did we'd struggle. Being outsized like this is not what you want with one of your key defenders.
-
"We generally like playing only two tall defenders, and then the third one has to have the capacity to play tall or small, which Kel Moore and Will Thursfield can do" - D.Hardwick
Considering Thursty isn't in the side, be interesting to see who's spot Moore takes if/when he comes back in. McGuane is the smallest of the guys currently playing.
-
"We generally like playing only two tall defenders, and then the third one has to have the capacity to play tall or small, which Kel Moore and Will Thursfield can do" - D.Hardwick
Considering Thursty isn't in the side, be interesting to see who's spot Moore takes if/when he comes back in. McGuane is the smallest of the guys currently playing.
Mcguane plays FB. I don't want Moore playing FB we'll get smashed
-
Because he is 1cm shorter and 1kg lighter than McGuane? :lol
and Rance has been FB last 3 weeks, McGuane CHB
-
Mcguane plays FB. I don't want Moore playing FB we'll get smashed
Me either.
Moore's overly enhanced reputation grows the longer he's missing.
Just a footballer and a replaceable one at that.
-
Because he is 1cm shorter and 1kg lighter than McGuane? :lol
and Rance has been FB last 3 weeks, McGuane CHB
2cm shorter and 3cm+ shorter standing reach 8)
Mcguane is our best 1 on 1 tall defender and he plays taller than 192cm. You don't want to go any shorter than 192cm. Rance, Grimes and Astbury are all between 193cm and 195cm. Do you really want to have Moore as one of our KP defenders and being drawfed by his opponent every game? He'll have to play to his 100% best and usually break even because he's going to get outbodied a few times per game. Deledio, Newman and Batchelor all provide better skill and run as smaller defenders
-
Moore doesn't play FB. Read what Hardwick said. Moore is more ( :-*) of a Nick Maxwell type.
Rance, Grimes & Astbury are the way forward. McGuane is depth.
Just a footballer and a replaceable one at that.
Agree. Could be traded to GWS.
-
Moore doesn't play FB. Read what Hardwick said. Moore is more ( :-*) of a Nick Maxwell type.
Rance, Grimes & Astbury are the way forward. McGuane is depth.
Just a footballer and a replaceable one at that.
Agree. Could be traded to GWS.
Well he's 3cm shorter than maxwell too ;D
-
;D
Maxwell wears high heels
-
Moore will get a game when fit regardless of what you effers think :police:
-
Because he is 1cm shorter and 1kg lighter than McGuane? :lol
and Rance has been FB last 3 weeks, McGuane CHB
2cm shorter and 3cm+ shorter standing reach 8)
Mcguane is our best 1 on 1 tall defender and he plays taller than 192cm.
He also plays much lighter than a 192cm KPD should play :shh Its embarrassing watching him unable to break tackles by midgets like Ballantyne, betts, the tip rat etc
-
;D
Maxwell wears high heels
Well yes he does, but that makes him 200cm :laugh:
-
He also plays much lighter than a 192cm KPD should play :shh Its embarrassing watching him unable to break tackles by midgets like Ballantyne, betts, the tip rat etc
Thankfully McG doesn't play FB
-
Enough with the insults ::) and stick to the topic!
-
I rate Moorey.
-
Please add WP to the injured list
WP: Rotator cuff inflammation caused by a slight strain :'( :'( = bloody sore
-
Moore doesn't play FB. Read what Hardwick said. Moore is more ( :-*) of a Nick Maxwell type.
Rance, Grimes & Astbury are the way forward. McGuane is depth.
Just a footballer and a replaceable one at that.
Agree. Could be traded to GWS.
Know for a fact, at the start of the season, McGuane was classed our best tall backman. He has had a solid start to the season so i'm pretty sure he is more than depth!
For me, if Moore is to be a part of our side, he will need to add a few feathers to his cap. Could he play on a wing? or could he be that third tall forward?
McGuane, Grimes and Rance for me for the tall backs.
-
He also plays much lighter than a 192cm KPD should play :shh Its embarrassing watching him unable to break tackles by midgets like Ballantyne, betts, the tip rat etc
Thankfully McG doesn't play FB
He's only played there everygame for the last 3 years 8)
-
no he hasn't 8)
-
Moore will probably be playing by midseason. While he's a good defender our defence will be better without him. We tend to use him as a tall defender and he's usually outsized by 5-10cm and 10kg. He rarely plays stuff, but if he did we'd struggle. Being outsized like this is not what you want with one of your key defenders.
I don't agree.
The way I see it
grimes = full back.
Rance = chb.
Astbury and Moore should be the3rd back. I think I the future it's not unrealistic to have all 4 in the back 6 as a possibility.
Mcgaune chb at coburg thusty full back. Deapth player. Off one to goal coast/gws for decent picks.
-
Mcguane plays FB. I don't want Moore playing FB we'll get smashed
Me either.
Moore's overly enhanced reputation grows the longer he's missing.
Just a footballer and a replaceable one at that.
ya - but is he a better footballer than mcgaune?
Post is another who can play key back. Best football in U18s was chb /
roaming marking player ala polak from memory.
-
Moore had a solid season last year and there is definitely a future for him in our backline. I would prefer either McGuane or Moore to be the third tall. It would be great if Grimes developed into a great full back or centre half back. If Grimes is full back there is certainly room for Astbury at centre half back. If there is competition for spots eg for full back it only means that our backline will improve
-
Moore had a solid season last year and there is definitely a future for him in our backline. I would prefer either McGuane or Moore to be the third tall. It would be great if Grimes developed into a great full back or centre half back. If Grimes is full back there is certainly room for Astbury at centre half back. If there is competition for spots eg for full back it only means that our backline will improve
if grimes fb
astbury chb
then rance will be the 3rd tall with Moore and mcgaune in no mans land.
Cannot see rance being dropped. Nor iron first grimes.
-
Thats how i see the future Bents
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 16 May):
Matthew White (shoulder) Test
Shane Tuck (ribs) Test
Daniel Connors (hamstring) 1-2 weeks
Will Thursfield (leg) 2 weeks
Matt Dea (leg) 2 weeks
Jamie O’Reilly (foot) 2-3 weeks
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Shane Edwards (cheek) TBA
-
Heard Kel Moore will not play this season.
-
Daniel Connors injury is of interest ;)
-
Daniel Connors injury is of interest ;)
Why because he told a pre-match 2 weels ago it was a quad injury and the club is now trumpeting it's a hammie ;D
-
Daniel Connors injury is of interest ;)
Why because he told a pre-match 2 weels ago it was a quad injury and the club is now trumpeting it's a hammie ;D
Correct, although I thought is was an injury to his ego, which is unrepairable
-
Correct, although I thought is was an injury to his ego, which is unrepairable
:rollin :rollin
Now jack - I reckon it's time you got told what I was told on Sunday about Gus but in this we will substitute Gus with Dan
You're just too tough on him :rollin :rollin :jump
:thumbsup
-
Heard Kel Moore will not play this season.
"TBA" at this point of the season without having kicked a ball in anger would certainly suggest that.
-
Moore will probably be playing by midseason. While he's a good defender our defence will be better without him. We tend to use him as a tall defender and he's usually outsized by 5-10cm and 10kg. He rarely plays stuff, but if he did we'd struggle. Being outsized like this is not what you want with one of your key defenders.
I don't agree.
The way I see it
grimes = full back.
Rance = chb.
Astbury and Moore should be the3rd back. I think I the future it's not unrealistic to have all 4 in the back 6 as a possibility.
Mcgaune chb at coburg thusty full back. Deapth player. Off one to goal coast/gws for decent picks.
the way i see it atm grimes = 3rd tall. astbury = chb. would as soon as possible or as soon as he strings some decent footy together give gourdis a go at fb. for me kel moore to play as a genuine flanker.
imo we are still screaming out for a 193 195cm 100kg fb.
grimes has all the attributes to play fb in time but i have real concerns about his size or weather he will ever bulk up enough to play the role.
one only has to look at what happened yesterday to see the need for a genuine big bodied no nonsense fb.
have said it many times will say it again. mcguane is a dud. and i still dont see rance making it especially in the air. really was comedy capers again with these two and graham.
for me with what players we have id like to see the back half go.
fb/ grimes - gourdis - batchelor/newman/farmer
hb moore - astbury/post - deledio/conca/dea
-
Gourdis, grimes, rance, Post, astbury all in 195cm-193cm range.
Do we need more or do we need to give our current stock more time before we wrote them off?
-
Matt Hornsby with the medical/injury report:
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/roarvisionarchive/tabid/11454/contentid/355268/default.aspx
Edwards - not too bad. Pulled up well and feels fine now. He had a depressed fracture of the cheekbone on the outside by the eye. Lucky in that regard. Club doctor knew straight away and so finished him up for the game. He wanted to come back on but the pain soon kicked in 20-30mins so sent him to the hospital for scans and subsequent surgery. Surgeon is very optimistic that the issue is short-term and Shane will be back running and doing non-contact training next week and will play either side of the bye.
Whitey and Tucky - both had collision injuries. Both really optimistic to push their case forward for selection. Just need to train well this week.
Connors - tracking well now and running at full pace and kicking the footy again. Expect return to full training next week and play the weekend after this.
Griffiths - going well. He's injury free. A matter of gametime which we'll manage again this weekend and him building up match fitness.
-
Gourdis, grimes, rance, Post, astbury all in 195cm-193cm range.
Do we need more or do we need to give our current stock more time before we wrote them off?
dont think anyone is arguing about height. size and strength well that is another thing altogether.
based purely on strengths and weakness gourdis and rance are not likely to make it. grimes is the only well rounded player there and hes not likely to ever be a monster. is post even a backman seems those in charge dont think he is.
as stated on another thread i would like to see us play gourdis at fb when he finds some form. grimes as the third tall defender with astbury or post at chb. would like to see moore make up a quartet of talls by playing him as a running flanker. add some running and class in deledio and conca or even batchelor to round it out.
in time i think both conca and batchelor along with newman should will go to the midfield to give blokes like dea and orielly a go at showing something.
-
Good to see young Ben Jakobi taken off the injury list, was really excited about this kid when he played in the NAB cup he and Contin showed great aggression and midfield nous for young players.
-
Good to see young Ben Jakobi taken off the injury list, was really excited about this kid when he played in the NAB cup he and Contin showed great aggression and midfield nous for young players.
Talent wise Jakobi has got 'it'.
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 24 May):
Shane Edwards (cheek) Test
Will Thursfield (leg) 2 weeks
Matt Dea (leg) 2 weeks
Daniel Connors (quad) 3 weeks
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 24 May):
Shane Edwards (cheek) Test
Will Thursfield (leg) 2 weeks
Matt Dea (leg) 2 weeks
Daniel Connors (quad) 3 weeks
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Well seeing Kel told us pre match on Sat night that he going in for surgery he should be listed as:
Kel Moore (hip) SEASON
Ditto Grimes, would be pointless trying to bring him back this season. Take your time with him Tigers
I note Dan Connors injury is now listed as Quad instead of Hammy
Said it before hard to take what they release seriously; seriously ;D
-
shame about grimes - but turn it into a positive he can look at some serious strength/size and conditioning improvements for the rest of the season and the pre season - come back 10kg bigger next year
Time for Post/Astbury or Gourdis to step up
-
shame about grimes - but turn it into a positive he can look at some serious strength/size and conditioning improvements for the rest of the season and the pre season - come back 10kg bigger next year
agree, hamstring surgery wont stop him building his upper body, and a lack of running should help him pile on the pounds
and you're right, gives us a chance to look at another young defender
definite positives
still prefer him out there but thems the breaks
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 30 May):
Shane Edwards (cheek) Available
Daniel Connors (quad) 1-2 weeks
Will Thursfield (leg) 2 weeks
Matt Dea (leg) 2 weeks
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
-
mitch morton anyone? ???
-
mitch morton anyone? ???
On strike till the club buys him a house ;)
-
Daniel Connors, longest injury of all time.
Thought Ego,s were a 2-3 week injury.
-
mitch morton anyone? ???
Biggest let down of the year for mine, even when not injured....just a waste, he has wasted his shot at the big time. Really if he doesn't show something soon, after he returns.... :help
-
Daniel Connors, longest injury of all time.
Thought Ego,s were a 2-3 week injury.
C'mon J, you should know a bruised ego is 2-3 weeks, but a broken ego, that's a longer setback ;)
-
mitch morton anyone? ???
Biggest let down of the year for mine, even when not injured....just a waste, he has wasted his shot at the big time. Really if he doesn't show something soon, after he returns.... :help
Morton's quest to become a midfielder hasn't worked so far. Houli has basically come in and taken Mitch's spot in the side. Morton has natural skills but it's when he doesn't have the ball that's the problem.
-
Daniel Connors, longest injury of all time.
Thought Ego,s were a 2-3 week injury.
C'mon J, you should know a bruised ego is 2-3 weeks, but a broken ego, that's a longer setback ;)
Jack should know, he has the biggest ego out of anyone
-
Not the most reliable source but here's the Herald-Sun's injury list for Richmond:
RICHMOND
INJURED:
Daniel Connors (quad) 1 week
Matt Dea (leg) 1 week
Will Thursfield (leg) 1 week
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) 8 weeks
Kel Moore (hip) indefinite
Mitch Morton (personal) indefinite
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/footy-barometer-round-12/story-e6frf9jf-1226041482103
-
Matt Hornsby talks about how we managed the boys over the bye
http://bigpondvideo.com/RichmondTV/360170/medical-room-first-bye/
* Bye came at a good time. Guys with fatigue, niggles and soreness. So good to have a physical break however kept them switched on mentally. Had to work on individual programs. Approach this week to training has been positive and they've attacked the track hard.
* We've cycled our group giving guys with niggles a week off so those niggles don't become serious issues later down the track. Done that over recent years given the young side we have. The structure of the byes for us this year have been good: 10 weeks - break - 7 weeks - break - 6 weeks.
* Individual programs are accessed via the net so they don't need to come into Punt Rd and there's no excuse not to follow them. They are a really diligent group so they've stuck to these programs. Really important to have them mentally freshened up as well so they don't drift through the week and a right and ready to go for the Swans game on Sunday. They head up there Saturday morning.
* Edwards has trained without restriction over the past two weeks so he's ready to go.
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 8 June):
Shane Edwards (cheek) Available
Daniel Connors (quad) 1 week
Will Thursfield (leg) 2 weeks
Matt Dea (leg) 2-3 weeks
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
-
Injury Update
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
He was on crutches last night at the player sponsors dinner
So I do not know why we continue to go down the "TBA" path
Kel has said himself he wont play this season so why not just list it as "season"
-
Injury Update
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
He was on crutches last night at the player sponsors dinner
So I do not know why we continue to go down the "TBA" path
Kel has said himself he wont play this season so why not just list it as "season"
Because it might be longer than that? :'(
-
Injury Update
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
He was on crutches last night at the player sponsors dinner
So I do not know why we continue to go down the "TBA" path
Kel has said himself he wont play this season so why not just list it as "season"
Because it might be longer than that? :'(
Surely we are just looking at this season, nothing more; nothing less
-
RFC's Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 14 June):
Pat Contin (quad) 1 week
Nick Westhoff (hamstring) 2 weeks
Daniel Connors (quad) 2-3 weeks
Matt Dea (leg) 3 weeks
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
Herald-Sun's injury list:
Daniel Connors (quad) 1 week
Matt Dea (leg) 1 week
Will Thursfield (leg) 1 week
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) indefinite
Kel Moore (hip) indefinite
David Astbury (knee) season
-
Matt Hornsby with the medical room update
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/roar%20vision%20archive/tabid/11454/contentid/362686/default.aspx (http://www.richmondfc.com.au/roar%20vision%20archive/tabid/11454/contentid/362686/default.aspx)
-
Matt Hornsby with the medical room update
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/roar%20vision%20archive/tabid/11454/contentid/362686/default.aspx (http://www.richmondfc.com.au/roar%20vision%20archive/tabid/11454/contentid/362686/default.aspx)
Interesting to hear Hornsby say Moore has had positive news post-scope. Opposite news to the rumour about Kel possibly being forced to give it away due to the hip injury.
Hopefully Matt is right about Grimes as well.
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 21 June):
Pat Contin (quad) 1 week
Nick Westhoff (hamstring) 2 weeks
Daniel Connors (quad) 2 weeks
Matt Dea (leg) 2 weeks
Matthew White (knee) 2-4 weeks
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 27 June):
Nick Westhoff (hamstring) Test
Daniel Connors (quad) 1 week
Matt Dea (leg) 2 weeks
Matthew White (knee) 2-3 weeks
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
-
Richmond Tigers Updated on: 26/06/2011
Player Injury Onset Estimated Return
David Astbury dislocated patella Rnd 12 End of season
Reece Conca concussion Rnd 14 Rnd 15 Test
Daniel Connors quadriceps strain Rnd 5 Rnd 16 Looks to have had another recurrence
Pat Contin quadriceps strain Rnd 10 Rnd 14
Matt Dea diagnosis unknown Rnd 7 Rnd 16 Leg injury
Dylan Grimes hamstring strain Rnd 9 Indefinite Recovering from surgery on a tendon rupture, unlikely to return this season
Kelvin Moore hip cartilage injury Preseason Indefinite
Troy Taylor diagnosis unknown Pre-season Indefinite Personal reasons
Will Thursfield calf strain Rnd 5 Rnd 14 Test
Nick Westhoff hamstring strain Rnd 10 Rnd 15
Matthew White knee MCL Rnd 13 Rnd 18
http://injuryupdate.com.au/afl.php
-
Lol Taylor - "diagnosis unknown" :lol
-
Richmond Tigers Updated on: 26/06/2011
Player Injury Onset Estimated Return
Pat Contin quadriceps strain Rnd 10 Rnd 14
Sadly we can't win the flag unless we get The Scarlett Pimpernel back on the park soon.
-
Aka spongebob
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 4 July):
Nick Westhoff (hamstring) 1 week
Daniel Connors (quad) 1 week
Matt Dea (leg) 1 week
Matthew White (knee) 1-2 weeks
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
-
Here's an idea for you RFC, instead of spending your time giving us dribble info on every bloody social media wanksite, how about giving the members some useful, genuine information about the state of our injured players instead of fobbing us off with this insulting TBA garbage every week?
-
definitely prefer insulting TBR over insulting TBA garbage
-
definitely prefer insulting TBR over insulting TBA garbage
:clapping
-
Here's an idea for you RFC, instead of spending your time giving us dribble info on every bloody social media wanksite, how about giving the members some useful, genuine information about the state of our injured players instead of fobbing us off with this insulting TBA garbage every week?
TBA would be code for gone for the season.
-
TBA would be code for gone for the season.
or...Tradeable Bout August ?
-
TBA would be code for gone for the season.
or...Tradeable Bout August ?
:lol
-
Here's Matt Hornsby's medical report:
http://bigpondvideo.com/RichmondTV/369538/medical-room-round-15/
Grimes is ahead of Astbury and Derickx in terms of his post-injury rehab. Grimes is back running strongly and met his surgeon recently who was optimistic about his progress while the other two are training well off their legs. We're taking a cautious approach with all of them but happy with their progress.
-
TBA would be code for gone for the season.
or...Tradeable Bout August ?
:lol
x 2
:thatsgold :jump
-
Young Dave Astbury just getting body right for 2012 coming alone great thanks to @GameReady #swooper
(http://c0013849.cdn1.cloudfiles.rackspacecloud.com/x2_7046bff)
http://lockerz.com/s/117730303
-
Gus is a dead spit for Guy Smily
(http://expertvoices.nsdl.org/highlights/files/2008/02/guysmiley.jpg)
-
Young Dave Astbury just getting body right for 2012 coming alone great thanks to @GameReady #swooper
(http://c0013849.cdn1.cloudfiles.rackspacecloud.com/x2_7046bff)
http://lockerz.com/s/117730303
Gus ffs...
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 11 July):
Daniel Connors (quad) Available
Matt Dea (leg) Available
Matthew White (knee) Available
Nick Westhoff (hamstring) 1 week
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
-
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
Why do we persist with this TBA crap
Even Cameron on his "chat" last week said none of these blokes will play again this season - so for crying out loud list them as "SEASON"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
Why do we persist with this TBA crap
Even Cameron on his "chat" last week said none of these blokes will play again this season - so for crying out loud list them as "SEASON"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
x2
-
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
Why do we persist with this TBA crap
Even Cameron on his "chat" last week said none of these blokes will play again this season - so for crying out loud list them as "SEASON"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Absolutely. :cheers
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 19 July):
Daniel Connors (leg) Assess
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
-
From today's Herald-Sun:
RICHMOND
INJURED:
Jake Batchelor (concussion) test
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Chris Newman (knee) TBA
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/footy-barometer-round-19/story-e6frf9jf-1226102058181
-
From today's Herald-Sun:
RICHMOND
INJURED:
Jake Batchelor (concussion) test
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) TBA
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
Kel Moore (hip) TBA
Chris Newman (knee) TBA
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/footy-barometer-round-19/story-e6frf9jf-1226102058181
What a relief.... good to see Newy's slipped right into the "TBA" mix
I don't reckon I'd cope if it said Newman (knee) 3 weeks....it would be so ................ er......"un Richmond like"
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 27 July):
Daniel Connors (leg) TBA
Chris Newman (knee) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
Kel Moore (hip) Season
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) Season
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) Season
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/injury%20list/tabid/9411/default.aspx
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 27 July):
Daniel Connors (leg) TBA
Chris Newman (knee) TBA
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
Kel Moore (hip) Season
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) Season
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) Season
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/injury%20list/tabid/9411/default.aspx
If Connors gets a couple of games later in the year then the club may still be assessing what to do with him, trade or keep. If he is rested he will be here without a doubt.
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 2 August):
Brad Helbig (ankle) 2 weeks
Daniel Connors (leg) 2-3 weeks
Chris Newman (knee) 3-4 weeks
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
Kel Moore (hip) Season
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) Season
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) Season
-
Did Connors have his leg chewed off by a lion?
Slowest recovery ever.
-
Dimma says only 28 players to choose from this week ...... but only 7 on the injured list. We must have a number of players unavailable for other reasons ..... Anyone got any ideas?
-
would say the Connors injury would have to be garbage
-
the whole injury list is.
they keep a few secrets in this area.
-
Wonder what the story will be for Conners next week ? Blown Nostrils ;D
Whats wrong with Big Bird Wings Griffiths ? ;D
And when is Dmac moving out of Ronald McDonalds house :lol
-
Matt Hornsby with his injury update
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/roarvisionarchive/tabid/11454/contentid/379064/default.aspx
Jackson - X-ray/MRI yesterday and got positive news. He copped a corky to shin. See how he trains this week. Some chance to play.
Newy - we're optimistic and Newy is keen to get back playing. He's had 3 running sessions doing more each time. Now it's about building up his workload in the coming week or so. We're hopeful he can play the last 2 games.
Moore - more significant surgery yesterday for his degenerative hip problem. We've set a path on this to be aggressive to help him long-term. Early days but at this stage expect him to have as solid preseason leading into 2012.
Connors - frustrated with tendon issue in his quad. Notoriously slow to heal. He's quite good up to 90% but is struggling to overcome that top end so we don't want to push it and cause a major problem. So we need to be conservative which means allow it to heal and strengthen. He's pretty close and had a good session today so we are hopeful he'll see some action before the end of the season.
Grimes - has started to rejoin in training. Able to run at top speed, aggressive change direction, acceleration and deceleration - specific footy movements - and he's copping with that very well. Great to see him get to the stage where he's not far off joining full training.
Astbury and Derickx - being more conservative with them as they are coming back from significant injuries. Dave has started running and running well. Derickx is a bit behind Dave as he's coming back from ankle surgery.
-
Connors, never been up to 50 % :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :birthday :birthday :birthday :birthday :birthday
-
Dimma says only 28 players to choose from this week ...... but only 7 on the injured list. We must have a number of players unavailable for other reasons ..... Anyone got any ideas?
Gourdis is suspended!
-
the injury list is like dial before you dig - not worth a pinch of poo.
-
Daniel Jackson's twitter:
"Just spent 2 hours with K Moore at hospital, in good spirits after successful surgery but a bit flat they could do nothing for his red hair!"
-
Daniel Jackson's twitter:
"Just spent 2 hours with K Moore at hospital, in good spirits after successful surgery but a bit flat they could do nothing for his red hair!"
for an apparently bright bloke he comes across as a deadbeat
-
Someone should have hit Jackson over the head with a stool pan, hard, so he doesn't play today.
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 16 August):
Jake Batchelor (shoulder) Test
Chris Newman (knee) 1-2 weeks
Daniel Connors (leg) 2-3 weeks
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBA
Brad Helbig (ankle) Season
Kel Moore (hip) Season
David Astbury (dislocated kneecap) Season
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) Season
-
Connors 2-3 weeks, ah that should read 'season'
-
and should include the Goo (suspended ATM I think)
:thumbsup
-
and should include the Goo (suspended ATM I think)
:thumbsup
Yes he is
Eligible for round 24 IIRC
-
Injury Update
Richmond player injuries and suspensions (at 23 August):
Reece Conca (soreness) Test
Chris Newman (knee) 1-2 weeks
David Astbury (knee) Season
Jake Batchelor (shoulder) Season
Daniel Connors (quad tendon) Season
Tom Derickx (ankle fracture) Season
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) Season
Brad Helbig (ankle) Season
Kel Moore (hip) Season
-
RICHMOND
Matt Dea (undisclosed injury) test
Reece Conca (soreness) test
Chris Newman (knee) season
David Astbury (knee) season
Jake Batchelor (shoulder) season
Daniel Connors (quad) season
Tom Derickx (ankle) season
Dylan Grimes (hamstring) season
Brad Helbig (ankle) season
Kel Moore (hip) season
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/footy-barometer-round-23/story-e6frf9jf-1226041482103
-
Rest Conca again and set him up for a huge pre season.
Newman let him go till next season.
No point risking anyone in a round 24 game where only pride is at stake.
-
Daniel Conners = flared nostrils ;D quad what a load of utter rubbish :shh