Rate a Tiger's year - 3. Brett Deledio?

[Judge Roughneck]

If you look at mike best 50 players in the league, there are few players ahead of deledio who are younger or have more talent.  

Has the abilty to be top 5 players in the game. Most important player on richmond list for next 1-10 years IMO.

I like deledio at hbf / chb. However I reckon he'd be a weapon in the forward line next to Taylor, griffiths, riewoldt.

[tony_montana]

his season was nothing exciting a 5

I thought this year was far better than the 2 previous when he won the Jack.  I gave him an 8.

TM..care to elaborate why you think it was nothing exciting and only a 5.  What are you judging him against?

Harry O 

[WilliamPowell]

Great year

Game against Adelaide at the MCG a standout. Hios leadership stood out that day - made a statement by action - wasn't going to let that game slip 

[TigerTimeII]

Great year

Game against Adelaide at the MCG a standout. Hios leadership stood out that day - made a statement by action - wasn't going to let that game slip 

yep agree


thats why i gave him a 9

if he had have say kicked a few more goals as a rebounding defending rather than just being a quarter back i would have given him a 10

[mat073]

Deledio had a really solid season,probably his best yet.

I just hope he gets a taste of finals action soon.He is a 128 game finals virgin.That is a real indictment on our club.

[Con65]

thats why i gave him a 9

if he had have say kicked a few more goals as a rebounding defending rather than just being a quarter back i would have given him a 10

So X - you think Lids has pretty much reached his best with no more room for improvement except for kicking a few more goals?